Final Crisis: Requiem #1

Final Crisis: Requiem #1

Event\Storyline: Final Crisis Writer: Peter J. Tomasi Artist: Doug Mahnke Publisher: DC Comics Release Date: July 9, 2008 Cover Price: $3.99 Critic Reviews: 10
8.2Critic Rating
N/AUser Rating

  • 10
    Comic Book Resources - Doug Zawisza Jul 11, 2008

    This book is as close to a perfect read as I have encountered lately. Once the cover was closed, I looked around the house for someone to share this with, but the wife and kids were gone. Undoubtedly, this will be a book I point to time and again when someone asks me why I read comics. Without hesitation, consider me the chairman of the "Let's get Tomasi and Mahnke to do he next big event book" committee. At the very least, know that I'll be right there waiting for the next title these two creators get to sink their ideas into. The only thing missing was a nice plate of Chocos and a glass of milk sitting next to me when I wrote this review. Read Full Review

  • 10
    The Weekly Crisis - Kirk Warren Jul 10, 2008

    Seriously, you have to read this book. You will literally care about the Martian Manhunter after reading it and probably wonder what was going through DC's head when they killed him off. My only worry is they'll have a rushed resurrection shortly after to nullify the impact of this amazing issue, but that's just me being a bit overly cynical. Read Full Review

  • 9.5
    Comic Book Revolution - Rokk Krinn Jul 14, 2008

    Final Crisis Requiem #1 was a gem of a read. Tomasi and Mahnke combine to deliver a proper send-off that was completely fitting to a character as classy and loveable as J'onn. I will miss Martian Manhunter, but I appreciate the excellent manner in which Tomasi handled J'onn's death. This issue is without a doubt an incredible tie-in issue. This might be the best tie-in issue to a mega-event that I have read in a very long time. Read Full Review

  • 9.0
    Comic Book Bin - Herv St-Louis Jul 15, 2008

    Im not against Mahnkes interpretation of the Martian Mahnunter, as it gives it a unique look among all the football-player-like super heroes he used to fight with. The death of the Martian was gruesome but effective. It did show some of his emotions through his eyes which lack irises. Thats a feat. Read Full Review

  • 8.5
    X-Man's Comic Blog - x-man75 Oct 30, 2008

    It was a tad slow at times, but it really caused me to care about the Martian Manhunter, who I'd never given much thought to before. Read Full Review

  • 8.4
    Weekly Comic Book Review - J. Montes Jul 14, 2008

    Doug Mahnke draws some strikingly detailed art and handles the ensemble cast like a pro, while Peter Tomasi delivers a strong, heartfelt script. It won't make you cry or anything, but it will make you appreciate one of DC's most under appreciated (and lovable) characters. Is the cover price a bit too high? Yeah. But then again story told here is much more comprehensible and compelling than the first two issues of Final Crisis we've been fed so far. Read Full Review

  • 8.0
    Comics Bulletin - Erik Norris Jul 11, 2008

    If I had to find one fault with the book is would be during the closing pages. There is an extreme usage of narration for a number of pages, and if you have read my previous reviews you know this type of storytelling tends to irk me. I always feel there is a better way to get story points across. But wouldnt you know it, Tomasi makes use of the narration both literally and in a great context. So by the time I reached the end of the issue, it didnt bother me. It actually led to a fantastic scene with Jonns closest friends honoring him in the grandest way possible. Finally, the books last page might make the biggest of DC fanatics shed a tear just like the heroes did in the pages that preceded it. Read Full Review

  • 7.6
    IGN - Jesse Schedeen Jul 9, 2008

    DC has released surprisingly few Crisis tie-ins so far. For whatever problems this issue may have, it still managed to impress me with its quality. I really hope Requiem will set the standard for the numerous tie-ins that are to come. Read Full Review

  • 7.0
    Major Spoilers - Matthew Peterson Jul 15, 2008

    Stephen gave this book a low grade due to what he saw as schmaltz, but I have to say, I was very much moved by this one. J'onn's various histories are resolved into one, with nice touches referencing the Ostrander series, events throughout the DCU, even giving us a nice nod to the "Bwah ha haaa" era of the Justice League. There's sentiment to be found here, yes, but as a Manhunter fan, it worked for me. The main problems that I had with the issue were the point-blank depiction of homicide, and the fact that the J'onn seen on the cover and in the coffin aren't the character as he is usually depicted. Honestly, is the character's funeral the best place to do a graphic overhaul? But, all in all, this issue worked for me, both as an epitaph, and as a story, and I'm glad to see that the most powerful being in the DCU went out on his feet, fighting every step of the way. These kind of issues are always tough, though. As Barry Allen proved a couple decades ago, having a charac Read Full Review

  • 4.0
    Eye On Comics - Don MacPherson Jul 9, 2008

    One of the most frustrating aspects of this one-shot is the fact that a pivotal character isn't even identified. I read Justice League of America in the 1980s, so I know who she is. Newer readers, hell, even not-so new readers, will likely not recognize Gypsy, an obscure JLA member who most recently appeared in Birds of Prey. It's a shame Tomasi doesn't use her super-hero name at all in this script. Her inclusion is clearly meant to incorporate the Detroit era of the Justice League, but it's done without really talking about that time in J'Onn's "life." Yet another problem that plagues this issue is poor placement of word balloons; there's no obvious flow to them as the various heroes document their friend's history. If the pointlessness of this comic book weren't frustrating enough, this non-story isn't even executed well. Read Full Review

Be the first to rate this issue!

Click the 'Rate/Write A Review' link above to get started.

Recommended For You

Reviews for
the Week of...