This one-shot is a bit like of of those cost saving episodes of a television series where we receive a series of clips from the old episodes that are inter-cut by some new material of the cast lamenting days gone by. Now yes this is all new material that hasn't been offered up before, but it's certainly ground that has been gone over quite thoroughly in the monthly titles with the only real new insight coming from a brief little scene with Metamorpho where we learn his problem is rather serious. Now the scene where Thunder has it out with her father was fairly interesting, and since I'm a big Impulse fan the brief little scene with Bart held my attention, but in the end this was a thirty page story where precious little actually occurred that hadn't already been set in stone in the pages of the monthly titles. As for the eight page tribute to Donna Troy, it's clear Phil Jimenez is deeply invested in the character, as he offers up a wide range of elements from her life and pretty much t Read Full Review

Not Ivan Reis's best work, I much preferred Carlos Barberi's style fitting with the Titans that were depicted. It's okay. A little ambiguous for someone who doesn't know about the previous series and from what I know, there was a decent gap between them so it's a little jarring having a lot of references that have nothing to connect to but it is Geoff Johns after all, it's his MO.