What If?: What If Magneto Had Formed The X-Men With Professor X? #1
Series Next

What If?: What If Magneto Had Formed The X-Men With Professor X? #1

Writer: Chris Claremont Artist: Tom Raney Publisher: Marvel Comics Release Date: December 29, 2004 Critic Reviews: 2 User Reviews: 2
5.5Critic Rating
6.5User Rating

X-Men legend Chris Claremont joins with the hot-shot artistic team of Cully Hamner (inside) and Jim Cheung (outside) to ask a question that MUST be answered only with speculation. Imagine a world where the Master of Magnetism had chosen a different path. Or perhaps he could have swayed Xavier from his own beliefs? These two legends stalk the halls of X-Men Canon, and at last the question is asked, "What if things had been different?"

  • 7.0
    Comics Bulletin - Michael Deeley Jan 4, 2005

    Like the What If? specials about Spider-Man and the Fantastic Four, this ends with heroes similar to normal Marvel continuity, but with enough changes to make them unique. This would give X-Men fans plenty to think about as it shows how deeply the Xavier/Magneto rivalry has shaped the X-Mens history. Read Full Review

  • 4.0
    Comics Bulletin - Shawn Hill Jan 6, 2005

    Answers: Not to be found here. What if nothing changed at all is a dull question. Read Full Review

  • 3.0
    Green Goblin Oct 5, 2021

    The potential of the idea was wasted. So many different changes, but I can't imagine how Prof or Eric could be the reason of it. The story almost goes nowhere. That's so stupid. Also it was so boring and almost not interesting. At least was a nice art and cool naked Kitty funny moment, but I think it can insult somebody.

    I disappointed. That's not what I wanted from that comic and not what I could enjoy.

  • 10
    EdNothIng Sep 25, 2019

Reviews for the Week of...