The Smart Division #2

CRITIC REVIEWS Back to Top

• 10

  Nerd Initiative - Matthew Roth

  Sep 30, 2026

  The Smart Division #2 will inject a level of fear into the reader that they may not have thought an issue could do. This may be a story, but, Zack, John, and Hassan blur the lines of reality, posing ethical questions regarding AI and leaving us with an ending that sinks us deeper into the mystery. Read Full Review

• 10

  Comics Bodega - tahoejbennett

  Sep 30, 2026

  Overall, sci-fi fans will geek out over this series. But it’s not just for them. Brilliant storytelling, appealing & often mesmerizing illustrations, top-notch professional lettering, and the feelings THE SMART DIVISION seeks to emote from the reader, coupled with such a cohesive creative team – all attractive aspects to which practically anyone will enjoy and appreciate. Read Full Review

• 9.8

  Fanlight Zone - Richard Coryell

  Sep 30, 2026

  The Smart Division #2 builds confidently on the series’ opening mystery with sharper tension, compelling character conflict, and an unsettling exploration of AI and corporate power. Zack Kaplan keeps the investigation unpredictable, while John J. Pearson delivers immersive artwork that strengthens the book’s noir atmosphere. This is a smart, suspenseful second issue that leaves the case more dangerous and more intriguing than ever. If this series isn’t already on your Pull List, reconsider that decision NOW. Read Full Review

• 9.5

  Comic Book Clique - Frank Jarome

  Oct 01, 2026

  The Smart Division #2 is a very strong follow-up to the stellar first issue, giving us an intriguing murder mystery and a tech-driven world that is all too plausible. I don't think that AI has evolved to the point where the various crime-based models are possible just yet, but I doubt they're that far off. There's a chance that we could look back at this series down the line and see it as a prediction, not just a comic book. Read Full Review

• 9.2

  Comic Watch - Ryan White

  Oct 01, 2026

  In conclusion, this story is a strong addition to the Dark Horse catalog, and I would highly recommend it. Like I said, no spoilers; you should really check it out for yourselves and support these talents because they really did great work on this issue. Read Full Review

• 8.0

  AIPT - Robert Reed

  Sep 30, 2026

  The Smart Division #2 is sharp techno-noir, with stylish layouts and an interesting premise. However, the second issue doesn't quite live up to the promise of the first, losing momentum in the issue's closing act. Read Full Review