/11_medium.jpg)
Prev
我覺得 Hickman X-men 很無聊。。。真的不滿意 ：（
THE TREES ARE KILLING THE CHILDREN!
Rated T+
X-Men #11 gives readers a sight they haven't seen in a long time- Magneto cutting through his foes like a hot knife through butter, and it's glorious. Hickman and Yu work together perfectly to give readers a treat they haven't had since Magneto joined the X-Men way back in the Utopia days and capture the force of nature that is Magneto. X-Men #11 is as close to perfect as one can get. Read Full Review
I picked up this issue of X-Men expecting to be let down. Yet somehow I walked away from this satisfied in ways I did not think possible for a tie-in to Empyre of all stories. This creative team made this story their own, and the best takeaway was knowing that Krakoa is more prepared than any other attempt at making an island nation. Read Full Review
As we wrap up another issue of this classic X-Men run, the wait between issues seems to get longer and longer. Hickman is one of the best writers in comics. Period. Each issue brings us closer to the end, and the build up has been great so far. You probably couldnt have asked for a better team on art duties. Yu and Gho crush it this issue and I hope we see more of them on this series. X-Men is the best book from Marvel right now. Read Full Review
X-MEN #11 is an exciting tale that elevates Magneto's importance to the Mutant Landscape while showcasing his leadership abilities, tenacity, and his clever ingenuity with his abilities. This issue felt like something Jonathan Hickman has wanted to write for a long time and was simply looking for an avenue or excuse to justify an entire issue dedicated to the Master of Magnetism. Read Full Review
X-Men #11 sees the Cotati invade Krakoa and mutantkind's savior rises to the challenge! Read Full Review
This is a fun book, and an excellent study of Magneto as a leader, and a Hero, for the world. Read Full Review
In many ways, it highlights the tie-in nature of X-Men #11 in a way that feels unnecessary. In one sense, it'd be tempting to call X-Men #11 filler, biding time until Summoner makes their move, presumably in the upcoming X of Swords event. But once the reader is past the prologue, Hickman and Yu deliver such a fun ride that it doesn't matter. This is an exciting book with some creative action beats, and it plays well whether you're reading the larger event or not. It would have been nice if the issue simply focused on that. Read Full Review
A painfully unnecessary tie-in to Empyre is redeemed by being a showcase the awesome badassery of Magneto. Read Full Review
It's a breath of fresh air to read a tie-in (of sorts) that doesn't feel like a tie-in. Very fun read. Read Full Review
X-Men #11 is a strong showing for the flagship "Dawn of X" title. Read Full Review
Overall, this story has no bearing on the greater X-Men universe, but if you are a fan of Magneto, this issue will still be worth a read. Read Full Review
Now THIS is how you do a tie-in issue! I may be biased because I love Magneto, but this issue was just so cool. Erik's obliteration of the Cotati leader alone is probably one of my favorite moments from Hickman's X-Men run so far.
终于！EMPYRE这个大事件有了在水准线上的一期，也是唯一一期。EMPYRE的主线写得非常一般，X战警、神奇四侠等支线也非常无聊。只有Hickman凭借他高超的编剧技巧拯救了这个拉胯的大事件，事实证明优秀的漫画编剧可以最大限度挽救编辑部愚蠢的设计。
at last! The big event of EMPYRE has an issue on the horizontal line, and it is also the only issue. The main line of EMPYRE is very general, and the branch lines such as X-Men and Fantastic Four are also very boring. Only Hickman saved this hip-pulling event with his superb screenwriting skills. It turns out that excellent comic screenwriters can save the stupid design of the editorial department to th more
Hickman handles Magneto fantastically here, and his writing of him is definitely what makes this issue so good. Yu's art is once again great, but Magnto was on a different level here and I loved just about every page he was on. The Empyre event definitely didn't weigh this issue or the previous one down and I'm very glad about that.
Happy to see Hickman and Yu deliver a good comic book yet again. Not hindered at all being a tie in to Empyre. I'm skipping the event and have no problem following. At this point I feel bad for the people who never read a Hickman series. It reminds me of the Avengers book of 2012 where I felt lost months at a time but then the payoff years later especially after reading the FF books before Secret Wars was really nice. Trade waiting might be better if you can't stand his style.
Magneto getting it done
Art 4/5
Story 5/5
Holy hell, this was an incredible issue. Magneto destroying Cotati like he's eating breakfast and Exodus being this mysterious cult leader are the highlights of this month's mutant comic.
I liked this issue a lot. I don't have much else to say. It's really well-written.
No big deal but Magneto is... pretty cool.
-Like the reappearance of the summoner
-Exodus' speeches always draw me in
- Magneto was great this issue, loved seeing him take commanded
-The combos of powers was awesome
-Humor was good this issue when it appeared
This was a really fun issue. Hickman writes a great Magneto.
What a great Magneto issue!
I like this issue and what is was trying to do...My only complaint is the a lot of the action scenes looked the same.
Something I’ve always loved about the X-men is the large volume of characters and that’s probably my favorite thing of this current saga. The Cuckoos, Magneto, Sage, Iceman, Magma! Love it!
Was better than last issue. I enjoyed Magneto and just the overall plot. Always enjoy yu on the art.
A Cotati invasion gives Magneto an excuse to be a badass. Which is cool, but was anybody doubting his badassitude? Wholly separate from the fight content, Mr. Hickman's weird Arakko plot slowly nudges forward. I felt that in both words and art, this was a top-notch execution of a story I failed to connect with.
Mostly a filler issue before the xover starts
Blah. At this point, I can't wait for Hickman to be done with this story, and I don't even care what the big reveal he's obviously building towards is anymore.
© 2024
