Phonogram: The Immaterial Girl #3

CRITIC REVIEWS Back to Top

• 9.6

  Comicsverse - Kara Waltersdorff

  Oct 17, 2015

  There are only six issues as it is a mini-series, but there are two prior collections out there, so go pick them up before you dive into this one! Read Full Review

• 9.0

  Doom Rocket - Scott Southard

  Oct 15, 0205

  I can't say enough good things about this issue or this series en toto. It's culturally smart, academically playful, and it's immersive to boot. I want to join the Phonogram coven, play the next track on the record, and get wrapped up in MTV's warm, static embrace. Read Full Review

• 8.0

  Newsarama - Pierce Lydon

  Oct 13, 2015

  The longer and longer this creative team works together, the more their brilliance crystallizes. It's amazing to see a team work this in sync with each other. This volume of Phonogram is bar far the weirdest and most ambitious yet and the whole team is up to the challenge. There's a lot about this book that might turn people off. It's joyfully weird and unapologetically silly sometimes. And for the people that doesn't work for, I'll point you to the back-up story in which David gets a girl to leave him alone by unabashedly enjoying something he loves (in this case, My Chemical Romance). Gillen and company aren't going to change. They're exploring the reasons that we are the way we are and doing it the only way they know how - with no guilt or shame about how much of the stuff they love they can cram into a comic book. Read Full Review

• 8.0

  Comic Bastards - Nick Philpott

  Oct 14, 2015

  I'm loving Immaterial Girl every month in new and exciting ways I would not have expected, and if you're missing out on it, I don't know what to tell you. Phonogram is back, and it's finally really magic. Read Full Review