Secret Invasion: X-Men #1

CRITIC REVIEWS Back to Top

• 8.0

  Comics Bulletin - Christopher Power

  Aug 12, 2008

  Overall, this was a fun book filed with classic superhero action. I highly recommend it to any X-fan. Read Full Review

• 7.0

  Comic Book Resources - James Hunt

  Aug 18, 2008

  Cary Nord's artwork is enjoyable superhero fare of the kind that he's good at. Using San Francisco as the battlescape gives Nord the chance to show off some nice city panoramas, effectively grounding the location and providing beautiful backdrops at the same time. Between his art and Carey's writing, "Secret Inasion: X-Men" is a decidedly different take on the events of the crossover, and a welcome chance to see some of the more sidelined X-Men take a prominent role. Read Full Review

• 6.7

  IGN - Daniel Crown

  Aug 13, 2008

  Now, before you accuse me of assigning a low score without too much malignity, I just can't justify a high rating for a book that doesn't do anything new, or even approach pertinence. Carey's script is entertaining and Nord's pencils are beautiful, so in that respect I applaud Marvel for handing the title over to capable hands, but at the same time, Secret Invasion: X-Men seems like nothing more than a routine action book without much consequence. Read Full Review

• 6.0

  The Weekly Crisis - Kirk Warren

  Aug 13, 2008

  It has the potential to be every bit as enjoyable as the WWH XMen battle royale without being a required read either. I was expecting this to be much worse than it turned out and I'll happily pick up the rest of this tiein. Read Full Review

• 5.0

  Weekly Comic Book Review - Kyle Posluszny

  Aug 13, 2008

  Secret Invasion: X-Men #1 is dangerously close to falling into the "skip" category. The Nightcrawler elements make this one worth it for X-fans, but all other had best keep their expectations in check. Read Full Review