Ryan's Profile

Joined: Jun 16, 2018

Recent Activity

Ryan rated Detective Comics #483 Jan 8, 2026
8.0

Detective Comics #483

By: Paul Levitz, Howard Chaykin
Released: Apr 4, 1979

“THE CURSE OF CRIME ALLEY.” Batman takes on a new villain by the name of Maxie Zeus!

+ LikeComment
Ryan reviewed Detective Comics #482 Jan 8, 2026
6.5

U know the bad guy is on borrowed time if they find out Batman’s identity

Detective Comics #482

By: Paul Levitz, Michael Golden
Released: Feb 7, 1979

“NIGHT OF THE BODY SNATCHER!” Batman takes on the villainous ape Xavier Simon, whose plan is to place his mind inside Batman’s body!

+ LikeComment
Ryan reviewed Detective Comics #481 Jan 8, 2026
6.0

Marshall Rogers provides tremendous art but O’Neil’s plot is pretty weak

Detective Comics #481

By: Dennis O'Neil, Don Heck
Released: Dec 6, 1978

“TICKET TO TRAGEDY.” Batman must race against time to discover the identity of a murderer and capture him in order to convince a disillusioned surgeon not to burn his notes for a new medical technique.

+ LikeComment
Ryan reviewed Detective Comics #480 Jan 8, 2026
7.5

Poor Gork

Detective Comics #480

By: Dennis O'Neil, Murphy Anderson
Released: Nov 1, 1978

“THE PERFECT FIGHTING MACHINE.” A criminal employs Dr. Moon to transform a flabby, unloved man into a “perfect fighting machine” called the Gork, and sends him against an ailing Batman.

+ LikeComment
Ryan rated Detective Comics #479 Jan 8, 2026
7.0

Detective Comics #479

By: Len Wein, Rick Buckler
Released: Sep 6, 1978

“IF A MAN BE MADE OF CLAY...” Preston Payne will go to any lengths to regain his humanity. Can the Dark Knight put a stop to this monster’s reign of terror before more innocent lives are lost or will he too become a victim of the new Clayface? Plus, “TRUE HEROES NEVER SAY DIE!” Hawkman and Hawkwoman return from Thanagar only to find that ...

+ LikeComment
Ryan rated Detective Comics #478 Jan 8, 2026
7.0

Detective Comics #478

By: Len Wein, Marshall Rogers
Released: Jul 5, 1978

“THE COMING OF…CLAYFACE III!” Preston Payne uses blood from Matt Hagen, the second Clayface, to try to change the effects of hypopituitarism on his appearance…but the "cure" causes Payne's flesh to melt like wax. When Batman interferes with Payne's theft of the components necessary to reverse his condition, he may become Clayface's next vic...

+ LikeComment
Ryan rated Detective Comics #477 Jan 8, 2026
6.5

Detective Comics #477

By: Len Wein, Neal Adams
Released: May 3, 1978

“THE HOUSE THAT HAUNTED BATMAN!” Batman checks up on Rupert Thorne, who now occupies a padded cell at Arkham Asylum. Batman is concerned as to why Thorne gave away all his plans and revealed his information, clearing Batman’s name in the process, and a clearly deranged Thorne explains that he was forced by the ghost of Hugo Strange, a man he ...

+ LikeComment
Ryan rated Detective Comics #408 Jan 8, 2026
6.5

Detective Comics #408

By: Frank Robbins, Neal Adams
Released: Feb 3, 1971

Robin goes missing and Batman finds a house that wasn't there yesterday; strange things happen around Batman until he meets the owner of the house.

+ LikeComment
Ryan reviewed Detective Comics #476 Jan 8, 2026
10

Worth the hype

Detective Comics #476

By: Steve Englehart, Marshall Rogers
Released: Mar 1, 1978

The Joker's big fish story concludes! Batman and Commissioner Gordon race across Gotham City, trying to stay one step of the Joker as his insane scheme to copyright his Joker Fish leads to more mayhem! "The Laughing Fish" part 2.

+ LikeComment
Ryan reviewed Detective Comics #475 Jan 8, 2026
10

The amount of story they were able to fit into 16 pages is crazy impressive

Detective Comics #475

By: Steve Englehart, Marshall Rogers
Released: Feb 1, 1978

"The Laughing Fish" part 1; one of the Clown Prince of Crime's most infamous tales begins here! Across Gotham City, fish begin appearing with the Joker's trademark smile--which the madman literally attempts to trademark!

+ LikeComment
Ryan reviewed Detective Comics #474 Jan 8, 2026
9.5

A part of me wants to say that what Englehart and Rogers did here was more impressive than actually creating Deadshot. Love when creators throw back to some decades old story and it turns out great. Huge W for continuity🙏. Deadshot’s costume seems so ahead of its time. Ive read a decent amount of comics from the 70s and can’t remember off the top of my head something like this. The scenes b more

Detective Comics #474

By: Steve Englehart, Marshall Rogers
Released: Dec 7, 1977

Deadshot escapes from prison and goes after the Dark Knight!

+ LikeComment
Ryan rated Detective Comics #473 Jan 8, 2026
8.0

Detective Comics #473

By: Steve Englehart, Marshall Rogers
Released: Nov 2, 1977

Batman and Robin are outlawed by the city council but continue to operate to foil a grand theft by the Penguin.

+ LikeComment
Ryan rated Detective Comics #472 Jan 8, 2026
8.5

Detective Comics #472

By: Steve Englehart, Marshall Rogers
Released: Sep 7, 1977

Robin manages to rescue Alfred and Bruce Wayne from Hugo Strange's clutches.

+ LikeComment
Ryan reviewed Detective Comics #471 Jan 8, 2026
8.0

Shocking last page. Ive probably read at least 100 instances of Batman getting knocked out or captured and never once do the bad guys ever unmask him, intrigued to what Englehart does with this

Detective Comics #471

By: Steve Englehart, Marshall Rogers
Released: Aug 3, 1977

Bruce Wayne goes to the "sanitarium" of a Dr. Todhunter to seek treatment for his radiation burns.

+ LikeComment
Ryan rated Detective Comics #470 Jan 8, 2026
7.0

Detective Comics #470

By: Steve Englehart, Walt Simonson
Released: Jun 1, 1977

“THE MASTER PLAN OF DR. PHOSPHORUS!” Batman confronts Dr. Phosphorus at the new Gotham City offshore nuclear power plant.

+ LikeComment
Ryan rated Detective Comics #469 Jan 8, 2026
8.0

Detective Comics #469

By: Steve Englehart, Walt Simonson
Released: May 4, 1977

“…BY DEATH’S EERIE LIGHT!” When Alfred collapses, Batman discovers many more people are mysteriously becoming sick. The Dark Knight realizes that the Gotham City water supply has been contaminated, so he goes to the Gotham Reservoir and finds the person responsible for the contamination: Dr. Phosphorus.

+ LikeComment
Ryan rated Batman #286 Jan 8, 2026
6.5

Batman #286

By: Dennis O'Neil, Irv Novick

+ LikeComment
Ryan reviewed Detective Comics #457 Jan 7, 2026
10

This was incredible. O’Neil delivered such a powerful story and only needed like 10 pages

Detective Comics #457

By: Dennis O'Neil, Dick Giordano
Released: Mar 3, 1976

“THERE IS NO HOPE IN CRIME ALLEY!” Every night on this date, Batman abandons all other crimes and missions and secretly heads to visit Leslie Thompkins. En route, Batman stops a car-radio theft and two muggings. When one of the muggers pulls a gun on him in Crime Alley, Batman loses his temper and knocks the mugger silly while having a flashbac...

+ LikeComment
Ryan rated Batman #268 Jan 7, 2026
7.0

Batman #268

By: Dennis O'Neil, Irv Novick
Released: Oct 1, 1975

A trio of oil company partners are murdered and it's up to Batman and Robin to stop their killer: Shriek.

+ LikeComment
Ryan rated Detective Comics #451 Jan 7, 2026
5.0

Detective Comics #451

By: Dennis O'Neil, Ernie Chan
Released: Sep 3, 1975

“THE BATMAN’S BURDEN!” Bruce Wayne, Cumming Streeter and Molly Post are at a resort on San Lorenzo island for charity events. Bruce departs shortly before Batman arrives and harasses Baldy Amber. Molly intervenes, disgusted by Batman’s rough manner. Batman pushes her away, angering a table of Navy sailors on leave. After a fight, Batman cha...

+ LikeComment
Ryan rated Batman #266 Jan 7, 2026
6.5

Batman #266

By: Dennis O'Neil, Irv Novick

+ LikeComment
Ryan rated Batman #264 Jan 7, 2026
5.5

Batman #264

By: Dennis O'Neil, Ernie Chan

+ LikeComment
Ryan rated Batman #263 Jan 7, 2026
6.0

Batman #263

By: Dennis O'Neil, Ernie Chan

+ LikeComment
Ryan rated Batman #262 Jan 7, 2026
7.5

Batman #262

By: Dennis O'Neil, Ernie Chan

+ LikeComment
Ryan rated Batman #261 Jan 7, 2026
7.5

Batman #261

By: Dennis O'Neil, Irv Novick

+ LikeComment
Ryan rated Batman #260 Jan 7, 2026
9.0

Batman #260

By: Dennis O'Neil, Irv Novick

+ LikeComment
Ryan rated Batman #259 Jan 7, 2026
7.5

Batman #259

By: Dennis O'Neil, Irv Novick

+ LikeComment
Ryan reviewed Batman #258 Jan 7, 2026
7.5

Loved the ending but there was a lot of uncharacteristically weak writing. Harris’ random suicide and Robin ditching Batman stand out

Batman #258

By: Dennis O'Neil, Irv Novick

+ LikeComment
Ryan rated Batman #257 Jan 7, 2026
8.5

Batman #257

By: Dennis O'Neil, Irv Novick

+ LikeComment
Ryan rated Batman #256 Jan 7, 2026
6.5

Batman #256

By: Dennis O'Neil, Irv Novick
Released: May 29, 1974

Catwoman goes to the circus...and you won't believe what she finds there! Please note: These are vintage scans.

+ LikeComment

Reviews for the Week of...

January

December

More