Batman #105 is an expertly crafted call-to-action that challenges us to look beyond the use of force and focus on the compassionate ways in which we can make the world a better place. And it accomplishes this with a genuine love for what the world can be. Read Full Review

The finale of the fantastic "Ghost-Stories" arc lands with emotional depth and beautiful artwork in Batman #105 from #DCComics @JamestheFourth @CarloPagulayan @DannyMiki_ @Christian_Duce @MyZombies @ClaytonCowles Read Full Review

Despite not having any developments as huge as the last few runs"yet"it actually feels like one of the most ambitious recent runs for the sheer number of significant new characters it's introduced. Read Full Review

All of the artists bring some great imagery to the issue. Everything flows well visually and there are some great character related moments that make the issue definitely worth reading. Read Full Review

Harley vs. Clownhunter. Batman vs. Ghost-Maker. This fight may not be what you were expecting, but it has huge ramifications for the ever-expanding Bat-Lore. Read Full Review

I don't think Ghost-Maker has had enough time in the new-character oven, but the end of his first story makes for an enjoyable and unexpected meal. Read Full Review

As far as Batman comics go, James Tynion IV has added so many new ideas in such a short span we should all be grateful for what he's accomplished. The number of new characters he's added only enriches the Batman property and Batman #105 continues that trend. As Steve Orlando pointed out on the AIPT Comics podcast, James Tynion IV's Batman run is clearly one of the best series of the year. Read Full Review

Tynion wraps this arc is a surprising way given the earlier tone. Itll require a second reading to see if this shift works, but its an interesting direction for Tynion take that Im curious to see if it pays off. Tynion hasnt been afraid to go against expectations and has done a good job world building so early in his Batman book. Read Full Review

In the end, Batman #105 is a worthy conclusion of the Ghost-Maker's debut arc. It makes me interested enough in him to want to see him again. Even if the issue's ending's strangely sudden, and a little empty, the strength of the climax makes up for it. Read Full Review

Batman #105 is not a brutal triple threat between the Bat and his two newest enemies, but instead a clash of ideas between three uncomfortable allies. This low-key conclusion makes for an appealing palette cleanser after the epic start of Tynion IV's run, delivering solid character development for the key players yet still maintaining tension. Post-Future State, it remains to be seen just how well this new and very reluctant member of the Bat-Family will fit in" Read Full Review

Batman #105 sets up an interesting dynamic by the end of the issue but like the arcs before doesn't quite satisfy. It again feels like a piece of a bigger puzzle. And due to that, it's not all that satisfying. These aren't the classic days where Batman's adventures were confined to some issues that you could enjoy on their own. Instead, this is just part of a bigger story whose arcs don't feel like they quite stand on their own. Read Full Review

Batman #105 ended James Tynion's first year on the series on a strong note. There is a lot of groundwork laid out that has potential to turn into several intriguing storylines in the future. Harley Quinn's was a particular standout with her speech being something fans will most remember from this story arc. Read Full Review

The Batman creative team brings this story arc in for a satisfying ending and one that I'm very happy with. While there are some issues that I have with it, overall most of the story lines in this story arc were brought to a nice conclusion (or jumping off point for the future) and the ending is great. There is some really good art in this issue as well. I wouldn't say it was an amazing issue or anything, but at least I wasn't bored and I would consider this issue to be worth the price. Read Full Review

When all is said and done, Batman #105 delivers an end to its storyline. While it has a great high point through Harley, it doesnt quite manage to stick to the final landing. Well have to wait till after Future Stateto see if the following stories can help strengthen this narratives ending Read Full Review

While well illustrated and a great scene with Harley Quinn, this conclusion to the first Ghost-Maker arc falls flat. Read Full Review

I was as bored as can be as I hit the final pages of this book. Let's hope for something better in 2021! Read Full Review

For all of the ideas that James Tynion IV brings to Gotham as he overstuffs it with flashy new characters, the real disappointment of his Batman run ultimately comes down to two things: an over-reliance on hype that is enver really delivered upon and a lack of Batman. Read Full Review

This isn't Batman. And what sucks, is we're stuck with at least another year to two years of this crap. Read Full Review

I’m reading these late because I digital sale wait, but damn did I love this ending. The art on the arc was the most inconsistent of Tynion’s run but the story was fantastic and it was emotionally resonant in a way Batman rarely is for me. I’m really sad he doesn’t have much time left on his Batman run as I think Tynion could have pulled off his five year plan and left us with one of my favorite Batman long-form stories. Ah well, I’m happy that he’s found personal fulfilment with his creator own work and substack - I’m just bummed that as a mainstream superhero a fan, that his fingerprint will be missing from this sphere.

" I'm gonna try to save as many people as i tried to hurt, back in the day. I want to be a better version of me."
- HARLEY QUINN

The ending was much different than I thought it would be. I finally started to care about Ghost-Maker and I am glad he is just not gone. I do like how Bruce acts here, how some people can be saved without puncing or beating someone. By just talking to them. It is the side of Batman we don't get to see enough IMO.

I didn't enjoy this event but I liked this final part.

BATMAN #105

Publisher: DC Comics @dccomics
Writer: James Tynion IV @jamesthefourth
Artist: Carlos Pagulayan @thecarlopagulayan
Danny Miki @koimando
Alvaro Martinez @alvaromartinezbueno_comic
Christian Duce @ducechristian
Colorist: David Baron @myzombies
Letterer: Clayton Cowles
Cover: Francesco Mattina @francescomattinaart
Jorge Jimenez @jorge_jimenez_art
Tomeu Morey

Batman and Ghost Maker comes to terms with their past and agrees to work together to save Gotham using Ghost Makers resources while Clown Hunter spares Harleys life who he blames for the death of his parents.

Wrapping up this arc before future State takes over, I’m excited for the the new statues quo for the series which Ghost Maker and Clown Hunter looks to have a prominent role with me speculating that they could have a Batman and Robin relationship down the line.

Rating: ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ (4/5)
Reviewed by: @djflores00 of The Comic Book Club of Instagram
Follow: @the_comic_book_club on Instagram for more reviews! more

This was a step-up following the previous issue. If you read my review for Issue 104, you’d know that my biggest issue with it was the art. This time around, the art feels cleaner and more consistent. However, I still maintain the stance that we don’t need multiple artists on one issue. I do think that this works when two stories are being told in two different times, but it should not be the common occurrence it is here. Speaking more about the story, I like the dynamic between Batman and Ghost-Maker. I think having Ghost-Maker in Gotham presents the opportunity for some interesting stories. Overall, a solid issue as DC heads into Future State.

I actually liked this alot more than I thought I would. First off, new year, new Batman. No longer has his toys, now he has to go it alone. Dealing with the remnants of Joker War, Clown Hunter now is stalking and killing those responsible for the Joker War, and also HQ for being partially responsible for his parents' death. Some dude named Ghost-maker comes into town to turn Batman more ruthless in his crime-fighting, arguing that empathy is a weakness.

The first 4 issues of the arc were pretty good, nothing super special, but had a clear direction, clear themes it was based on, and gradually built up for the last issue. But the last issue was rushed, however, I felt it rushed in a good way. A totally unexpected ending that came out surprisingly nice. I liked it alot, I think this is Tynion's best arc on Batman yet. The art is inconsistent though, many artists are sharing duties, and it ruins the momentum that Tynion is laying out here. Overall, a nice thematic arc, introduces a new character, develops more onto Clownhunter, and sets a new Batman for future issues. Two thumbs up. more

Mediocre arc.
-Dialogue dragged on sometimes
-Action was unsatisfying
-Dichotomy between Batman and Ghost-Maker was good
-Clownhunter was handled ok
-Batfamily parts were totally unnecessary
-Bruce's training times are almost always enjoyable to ​me.
-Harley Quinn stole the spotlight again. It's fine but it gets repetitive.

Okay I’m just saying that if Batman and Ghost-Maker kissed right now it would not be out of character and would fit perfectly.

This issue serves as a microcosm for Tynion's run: some interesting ideas buried beneath inconsistent pacing and characterisation.

The honeymoon period following the final issue of Tom King's atrocious run is over.

Here we go again. All Tynion seems to be doing is making a name for himself by introducing lame new characters in each of his stories. I thought he was doing well until halfway through the Joker War, but now all he seems to want to do is build a new cast. I knew all along Ghost maker was going to stay after this. If they want a sword swinging assassin to work with Batman then bring back Azrael. If they want a teenage vigilante who goes too far, bring back Anarky. And if they want Joker to have a pain-in-the-ass groupie, turn Harley bad again.
This was another bad conclusion to what seemed to start as a decent story. There was no showdown. Just "Join me." "Okay." and that's it, with some stupid dialogue, the end. That was the worst ending to a comic in the past year, second only to Superman #28. What pointless unlikable character are you introducing next, Tynion? And how long till you realize Ghost Maker is a lame sidekick and you get rid of him? I don't look forward to finding out. Either I see some improvement in Batman after "Future state" or I guess It'll be time to drop it again for the first time since Rebirth began. Frankly these stories aren't worth $4 an issue lately. more

There were some ok parts but for the most part it felt uninspired. It felt to easy for ghost maker to just stop fighting. I like the concept but not well as well done as it could have been.

I don't care about Clownhunter. Unfortunately, he's not going away. The stuff with Ghost-Maker was fine I guess. The ending was unexpected, and probably a little lackluster, but... It's hard to be upset when no matter how it turns out, you're not going to care. The art needs to be more consistent. I'd much rather have one of these artists doing the entire issue than all four of them working in tandem.

Not bad but it does not drop into mediocrity

I hope the changes that they promised are satisfactory, I am not going to be incredible as Marvel is doing with a decent I am well served but I do not predict much they will repeat the thing about Jason's dog in Nightwing and apparently the boring relationship of DickBarb again and it is not that he finds the couple, but it is very flawed, however putting in Zucco can add some interesting drama to that series.

On the other hand Batman: Urban Legends seems to be going in a good direction by the writer Matthew Rosenberg (who I would like to take on Red Hood but they gave Grifter) and the not inconsiderable Chip Zdarsky who will take the part of Red Hood aims That will be 6 good numbers if DC does not put his hand. I get the impression that perhaps they are consciously restructuring the characters this time, reducing the number of comics and perhaps improving the quality. more

god the dialogue

The art is decent in this book but the story is very lacking. Batman and two characters no one cares about. Blah blah blah blah...Everyone decides to be friends and Batman decides that he can team up with a murderer. Anyway you slice it Batman should be trying to incarcerate both Clown Hunter and Ghost Hunter not to mention Harley Quinn. DC needs to clean house with its writing division and remove "Edge Lords" like Snyder, King, and Tynion from writing the Batman books.

This issue is just dumb. Nothing happens. Bao, I mean Clownhunter tries to kill Harley but can't because of the power of love. Harley says sure I killed a lot of people and destroyed your life, but oppsie and I absolutely deserve to walk free because I'm a victim, and you're a victim and those dozens of people you brutally killed using psychotic methods totally had it coming.

Shadowkiller or Ghostslaughter or whatever, maintains caring about people will get Bruce killed. He says it hasn't so far. But caring about people Bruce's way sure has gotten a lot of other people killed. I am talking about thousands. Thanks to DC's love of body counts, letting the Joker live means thousands of innoncent people die every year because of Batman. I don't think that's the message DC wants to give, but that's what they're doing.

The action is stupid. I mean just stupid. Clownkiller, who hasn't hestitated to kill nameless victims, has a sword over Harley's neck. He just holds it there giving Bruce time to literally break his bonds, grab a batarang from his belt that Ghoststabber left on his body while tying him up. Bruce is able to throw the batarang to Harley, she catches it and then gets into a defensive position and talks about the healing power of forgiveness. Clownpiethrower breaks down and everybody hugs and it's cake for everyone.

All this action has to take time, yet Clownboy just holds the the sword over Harley's neck.

Even Ghost boy says he did everything he did to prove a point to Bruce. Which is what the Joker did in The Dark Knight. Bruce says I need help, I am getting older and don't have billions and Alfred is gone and Catwoman left me and my pickup truck has a flat and my dog died. So I could use help just don't kill anyone. Apparently, torture and planting evidence and crippling people is OK, just don't kill.

This issue is bad for so many reasons. Pacing is SOOO SSLLOOWW. Characters act out of character. A kid who has KILLED dozens brutally just changes. That's not the way things work. Harley is not nuts. She just shrugs off stuff and is sane. That's not Harley. Ghostkisser really just wants something and agrees to work with Bruce. Bruce really lets mass murderers off the hook with a hug. He says he needs help despite the fact that he's got more allies than ever. What with Spoiler and Cass as Batgirls (an ideal I really like - see I can be positive and enthusiastic), a couple of Robins, Nightwing, Huntress, Oracle and maybe Catwoman and her crew.

Why does Bruce need one more ally. He talks about reduced resources, but I don't see it. He says he doesn't have allies in government, but the Commish is still his fried.

This issue is saying things that aren't true and I really dislike all these mass murderers getting left off the hook. I am for rehabilitation, but murder is something else. Prison is also for punishment and these killers have been left off the hook.

The art was nice, but the action was nothing.

Or I could be wrong. more

+ Like • Comments (2)

• Likes (3)

• Goughie
• RKS
• SenpaifenixJäger

SenpaifenixJäger - Dec 16, 2020

Oh dear I have laughed so much at your witty criticism, I'll be honest, since DC has been making garbage for a while I reached my limit, now I usually read Marvel, I just stop by to see the criticism to know if it is worth wasting time reading or not a comic. Thanks for not overvaluing the series in such a nice way and with this I get an idea that it is a number to kill someone from boredom, thank you very much I'll skip it for today.

Quinn - Dec 16, 2020

Thanks. I always feel humor can sell my point than serious talk. But man this run bothers me. And I know that all these “great” changes will not last. That’s something, but it all amounts to nothing. So frustrating. Gla you liked my review.

Sign in to comment

Just bad. None of it makes any sense. Clownhunter is just a poor retread of Damian. Ghost Maker goes from being violently against the very concept of Batman to being his partner in 5 pages. Made worse by the “I don’t have a butler anymore” line