Madison Butler's Comic Reviews

Reviewer For: Graphic Policy Reviews: 37
9.0Avg. Review Rating

8
Lumberjanes #23

Feb 18, 2016

It's hard to tell where this arc will fall in terms of the collected editions. The adventures of the Lumberjanes and Seafarin Karen have already covered three issues, but the delay in trade release means that the collected storymay not be released until next year. Despite this, the individual issues continue to be worth picking up for their awesome art, adventure, and wit.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Lumberjanes #24

Mar 16, 2016

Overall, Lumberjanes #24 brought this arc to a satisfying close just in time for the series two-year anniversary. The Lumberjanes will return next month with an oversized Lumberjanes #25 to celebrate two years of camp friendships and shenanigans.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
Welcome Back #5

Feb 10, 2016

Because the necessary exposition is out of the way, Welcome Back #5 stands much better on its own than its predecessors. Since it was originally meant to be a limited series, it will be interesting to see where and who the story and characters of Welcome Back will be next.

View Issue       View Full Review
7.8
Welcome Back #6

Mar 19, 2016

Sebela and Roe are a strong team, andWe(l)come Back continues to amass intrigue. It does, however, leave Tessa and Mali with backs against the wall at all turns, begging the question of what could possibly come next.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Welcome Back #7

Apr 20, 2016

Overall, the issue is one of the strongest of the series so far. This issue introduces some new characters to the mix, gives the story a clear direction, and is an absolute must-read as part of the series.

View Issue       View Full Review
9.5
Welcome Back #8

May 25, 2016

Overall, this issue was a well-crafted end to a wonderful series, and leaves only one question: Will there be a deluxe trade available for preorder?

View Issue       View Full Review
7.9
Nancy Drew And The Hardy Boys: The Big Lie #1

Mar 8, 2017

The first issue of the comic wasnt perfect, but showed a lot of promise. Mystery fans, fans of the original series, and fans of Hope Larson and Brittney Williamss Goldie Vance will likely enjoy Nancy Drew and The Hardy Boys for its vintage charm, amped-up drama, and superb art.

View Issue       View Full Review
8.5
Nancy Drew And The Hardy Boys: The Big Lie #2

Apr 12, 2017

Nancy Drew and The Hardy Boys could have easily been a grim and dark reboot of an older property, but the art and colors keep it from ever approaching the Too Gritty mark. The series is an entertaining read, with plenty of nods to the source material that are fun Easter eggs for familiar readers.

View Issue       View Full Review
8.3
Wolf #6

Feb 24, 2016

This issue largely functions for clarification of the narrative, but its very much enjoyable. Between the art, Anitas wry narration and development as a character, and the banter between the characters, the story doesn't feel like it's at a standstill in Wolf #6. It is certainly heading in a new direction, and though its only slowly becoming clearer what that direction is, Wolf will surely keep readers guessing.

View Issue       View Full Review
8.5
Shutter #19

Mar 9, 2016

Shutter‘s art is wonderfully consistent, and del Duca is a talented artist and a credit to the comic industry. The story is regaining momentum, but there's no clear hint as to where it will go, something that Keating has done–and continues to do–well.

View Issue       View Full Review
8.5
Shutter #20

Apr 13, 2016

Once again, writer Joe Keatinge leaves readers with no clue as to where the story will go next. It is clear that a conflict with Prospero is drawing closer, but the back of issue #20 teases “the final three” in reference to the last of thesiblings Kate doesn't know. Other characters like Cassius and Chris Kristopher Sr. have been noticeably absent from the narrative, building a sense of intrigue regarding their whereabouts. Despite all the answersShutter has given, it largely remains a mystery.

View Issue       View Full Review
8.7
Cry Havoc #2

Feb 25, 2016

All in all, the team on this book works extremely well in terms of art and writing. The idea of a threefold narrative colored by different people is a concept that could come off as gimmicky if done poorly, but this comic is not done poorly. Its engaging and fresh in both its writing and structure, and its definitely worth a read.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Cry Havoc #3

Mar 23, 2016

Spurriers inclusion of writers notes in the backmatter is both interesting and educational. They contain little hints about future events, but largely provide information about turns of phrase and situational history that are relevant, but wouldnt necessarily have a place in the story. Overall, the complexly woven narrative, use of color, and inclusion of mythology continue to make Cry Havoc an interesting read.

View Issue       View Full Review
8.5
Cry Havoc #4

Apr 20, 2016

Cry Havoc is still a fun and engaging read four issues in, with solid pacing that reveals enough to both move the story forward and to keep readers feeling like theyre not waiting forever. That said, the endgame largely remains a mystery, as does the fates of many of the characters.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Nowhere Men #8

Feb 24, 2016

If the last issue of Nowhere Men felt like the calm before the storm, #8 seemed to ripple the waters a bit, and the comic continues to excite.

View Issue       View Full Review
8.5
Nowhere Men #9

Mar 24, 2016

While people looking to read Nowhere Men purely for science will be disappointed, the comic continues to be an enjoyable read for its art and themes of humanity. Stephenson builds tension in the waiting, leaving much room to wonder what the endgame will be.

View Issue       View Full Review
9.5
Nowhere Men #10

Jun 1, 2016

Overall, this is another well done issue from a fantastic creative team. It is both thought-provoking and entertaining, and will make readers glad its publishing break is over.

View Issue       View Full Review
8.8
Oxymoron: The Loveliest Nightmare #1

Feb 3, 2016

Cormack does a great job of bringing every vicious detail of the story into reality. Oxymoron himself is creepy and sinister, with a terrifying and omnipresent grin that may take clown phobias to a new level. Cormacks dynamic illustrations will haunt readers indefinitely–or at least until the comic returns with a new and equally twisted arc.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Lady Killer 2 #1

Aug 4, 2016

Jolle Jones's art is the star of the story. The characters are expressive and messy, beautiful and occasionally sleazy. Lady Killer featured ink splattered pages, and while Lady Killer 2 #1 featured the same ink-splotched pages, the overall art and style suggests that Josie is fully in control and more organized than she's ever been. Joness use of heavy inks and Michelle Madsens poppy colors create an amazing contrast between tone and action: The art is brightest when Josie's narrative is dark, just as the inverse is true and the tone of the story upbeat when Josie is brutally stabbing victims. The overall effect is a story that's as delightful to look at as it is to read.

View Issue       View Full Review
8.4
Elasticator #1

Mar 30, 2016

So far, its unclear what Mikeys powers are. The brief moment in which Mikey gets in a fight isnt him dressed as a superhero, even though hes been beaten quite badly by the time hes arrested. The story is pretty well-paced, mostly focused on exhibition but with enough forward progress that it sets the gears in motion for the larger story.

View Issue       View Full Review
8.3
Elasticator #2

Apr 6, 2016

Elasticators second issue was another strong effort. The narrative does get a little confusing when navigating time in the story, but the story builds intrigue throughout the issue. Its well worth reading for the fast-paced dialogue and action.

View Issue       View Full Review
9.8
Elasticator #3

May 25, 2016

The Elasticator team has created a book with depth, great characters, and themes that get more compelling with each chapter. As the intrigue heightens, Elasticator is a comic that deserves its spot on your pull list.

View Issue       View Full Review
10
Elasticator #4

Jun 29, 2016

Elasticator is the perfect comic for geeks interested in, well, geeky things and politics. While this issue focuses less on the politics than its predecessors, no hero would be complete without an origin story and Elasticator, as usual, delivers.

View Issue       View Full Review
9.2
Elasticator #5

Aug 31, 2016

With elements that work so well together, Elasticator will be dearly missed after it ends with the next issue.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Monstress #4

Mar 16, 2016

Both visually and story-wise, Monstress continues to be one of Images most unique publications. The next two issues will be released monthly, after the short break between Monstress #3 and #4.

View Issue       View Full Review
10
Monstress #5

Apr 13, 2016

As usual, Monstress utilizes every bit of space on its pages to weave an increasingly complex narrative. As usual, though, the story is absolutely worth reading and deserving of the time it takes to understand the narrative.

View Issue       View Full Review
10
Monstress #6

May 25, 2016

The story is an incredibly huge undertaking, and Liu and Takeda keep readers guessing as to where it will go next. If it hasn'talreadyclaimed a spot on your pull list,Monstress is absolutely deserving of it.

View Issue       View Full Review
10
Monstress #7

Oct 13, 2016

The colors emphasize the detail and set the mood. Monstress is often serious in tone and deals with dark themes, but the comic itself is rarely visually dark. Dynamic, layered colors build up and add to the magic of the series. The amount of thought put into the colors and detail make Monstress an especially gorgeous fantasy epic that will stand the test of time.

View Issue       View Full Review
9.5
Goldie Vance #2

May 18, 2016

Overall, the second issue is just as solid as the first. With any luck, the series will be extended, because Goldie is a character youll want to read about for a long time.

View Issue       View Full Review
10
Goldie Vance #3

Jun 8, 2016

With a fantastic creative team and a smart, diverse group of characters, Goldie Vance is a comic appropriate for all ages and one that, luckily for readers, will be around for a while.

View Issue       View Full Review
10
Goldie Vance #4

Jul 14, 2016

Goldie Vance is the perfect series for all readers. Readers of all ages will likely enjoy Goldie's tenacity, stubborn curiosity, and determination to do the right thing, and the puzzling and at times otherworldly whodunit is a sure attention-grabber.

View Issue       View Full Review
10
Goldie Vance #5

Sep 8, 2016

Theteam's enthusiasm for the book is obvious, and the plot and characters are written, drawn, and colored with great care. The second arc has perhaps started better than the first, and while we don't yet know where the story will go, it is guaranteed that it will be fun and full of surprises.

View Issue       View Full Review
10
The Fix #2

May 11, 2016

The Fix hasn't lost any of its hilarity as it delves deeper into the story, and is absolutely worth a pull list spot. If you didn't get a chance last month, both issues #1 and #2 are worth checking out–and the #1 second printing variant now features none other than the heroic Pretzels.

View Issue       View Full Review
10
The Fix #3

Jun 8, 2016

he Fix #3 ends with something of a cliffhanger that suggests Roy and Mac may be in over their heads, and while this isn't a new concept, it also suggests that their problems might be bigger than expected. Spencer and Lieber are a talented team (as indicated by the comic going into second and third reprintings) and The Fix continues to earn its spot as a regular read.

View Issue       View Full Review
9.6
The Fix #4

Jul 6, 2016

Together, these elements form a well-constructed comic well worth reading for its story, humor, and art.

View Issue       View Full Review
10
Long Lost #2

Jan 6, 2018

The first two issues are compelling in their establishment of the tense relationship between Piper and Frances, the girls mysterious past, and their even more mysterious future. The emotional and atmospheric tone of the comic helps to create a haunting, intriguing story that leave me hungry and excited for the moment when the plot comes crashing together.

View Issue       View Full Review
10
Long Lost #3

Jan 31, 2018

Long Lost #1 and #2 took time to establish layers of emotion and plot, giving readers complicated characters to root for and a story that unfurls in unexpected ways each issue. Every issue asks more questions than it answers, but it also creates momentum, but the third advances the plot in a way that adds motion as well as depth. Long Lost #3 is another compelling issue in a series full of emotion and mystery.

View Issue       View Full Review

Reviews for the Week of...

November

October

More