Thanks to Jimmy Palmiotti and Justin Gray, this series has provided consistent quality and quantity month after month. The book is priced right, excellently written and illustrated in a way that makes you feel the time period and setting. And yes, the second story and overall length of the book makes a big difference - especially when there are so many $4 books that aren't even worth $2 - this one outshines a good majority of the books sitting on the racks. All-Star Western continues to be one of the main books I look forward to reading and reviewing each month. Read Full Review

By far the strongest issue we've had so far on this series, which just goes to show there's room for an old genre to grow, after all. Read Full Review

All-Star Western isn't your usual western yarn and that's what I like about it. It's really a super-hero book that happens to take place in the Old West. This title is a real gem of the New DC. Read Full Review

Who would have thought that 1800"s Gotham would be so interesting? Read Full Review

Like I said, although it was a bit confusing at times; the story is really good overall and I have really been enjoying this series. Although I do feel as if this issue could have been better organized, I like that we are getting a chance to see Jonah Hex interact with a variety of different characters, and we are exploring many untouched regions of the DCU. I am still very interested in seeing what the relationship between Hex and the upcoming Court of Owls story arc will be, because that wasn't something that was brought up in this issue. Good issue, not a great jumping on point. I recommend getting issue #7 if you are just jumping into ALL-STAR WESTERN. Read Full Review

All-Star Western is doing well for itself at the moment. The only question is whether the imminent Night of the Owls crossover will derail the plot or enhance it further. Read Full Review

Unlike Red Hood and the Outlaws, this issue doesn't explicitly tie in with Night of the Owls. In fact, the only way I can meaningfully see it tying in with Night of the Owls is that the group they're trying to infiltrate will end up being part of the Court. Of course, Hex is in New Orleans right now so unless the Owls are all over the US or later moved to Gotham, it seems like it may be a bit of a stretch. However, I'm not too bothered because I had fun with this issue. In fact, I'm currently debating whether to add it to my pull list or just collect the trades. Either way, while this isn't the perfect issue for jumping on to the book, it's not a bad one either. Read Full Review