9.5

IGN - Daniel Crown Jan 23, 2008

On one hand, I'm eagerly anticipating Giant-Sized Astonishing X-Men #1, but there is also a part of me that doesn't want this series to end. To me it represents that rare level of quality- the perfect combination of great art and storytelling- that helps me retain faith in the future of superhero comics. I tip my cap to both of its creators as they head into their new projects, of which I can only hope will be of the same golden standard. Read Full Review
6.0

Comics Bulletin - Ray Tate Jan 26, 2008

I still have zero enthusiasm for this Astonishing X-Men story and its characters. The conclusion certainly made me sit up and take notice, possibly for all the wrong reasons. Read Full Review
6.0

The Weekly Crisis - Kirk Warren Jan 23, 2008

Like I said, Whedon just moves some pieces around the board despite having set up his big conclusion set up last issue, making this just a bunch of redundant fluff as we wait for the actual main event to start whenever he decides to write the final script. Read Full Review
2.0

Weekly Comic Book Review - J. Montes Jan 25, 2008

Oh, Cassaday's artwork is lovely as expected. Read Full Review