I really liked this! Better than the first issue in my opinion. Loved the exploration of Logan and Scott. Art was gorgeous too.

An intriguing way to set up Jean's inevitable return from the dead. The writing and story were decent, but the art was fantastic.

Wow, really great issue. The pages comparing Dick and Bruce's interactions with Alfred were especially powerful. Definitely made me tear up a bit.

I love Immortal X-Men so much and will miss it terribly when it's over.

The editor who looked at this issue must have been high cause there were a few glaring typos scattered throughout. Otherwise, this was decent. A little long and plodding, but it's Kieron Gillen so he finds a way to make it entertaining reading.

Ugh...man, Immortal X-Men is a brutal, devastating series...but it's also a bloody fantastic one as well.

I don't think I'll ever get tired of the politics of Immortal X-Men. The quiet council has been one of the most compelling aspects of the Krakoan era to me and a big part of what has separated it from every other X-era to date. I will be extremely sad to say goodbye to Krakoa when Fall of X hits... but I will always be immensely grateful that we got these stories in the first place. Thank you Jonathan Hickman for your brilliant, brilliant mind, and to all of these other writers for fleshing out his vision and carrying the torch since his departure. more

Incredible issue. The tension was off the charts.

Really well written. Loeb's script is sharp and grounded, and he's got a great voice for Batman and Comissioner Gordon in particular. Even Catwoman, who I find very few writers are able to write well, is a show-stealer in almost every scene she's in.

I don't know why everyone is giving this such a low score. I thought it was fantastic. Sure it retreads some stuff we've already seen, but honestly it's been so long since I read it that I'd forgotten most of it, so I appreciated the reminder, especially since it's about to become relevant to the current events. This issue was extremely well written and the art was beautiful.

This was a great start. Loeb and Sale are a terrific team and this looks like it will be another excellent read. I really like Loeb's voice for Batman.

Man, the scene between Storm and Xavier was so good.

A great recap and a nice setup for the series.

Great story. Really enjoyed this. I get why it's considered one of the all-time greatest Batman comics.

Goes out with a fizzle. Definitely Remender's weakest work. Jet Black flipped back to the dark side as easily as she flipped to the light side, the deaths of Ian and Sharon are undone, and Zola gets away without having really done anything. Literally the only thing that this series can really be said to have accomplished is make Captain America old.

Pretty underwhelming.