Bugger off Gabe Hernandez.

sue me, but i like slott voice for superman and i like this title

>For me< Mark waid can write superman forever.

It's a bit strange seeing Morazzo's art with Superman; it looks like All-Star's, but with a higher degree of strangeness. I liked it and I'm curious, since I don't know how it will end. Regarding the characters, Lex and Bruce are very good; I thought Clark was okay but a bit over-the-top in the narration. Lois caught my attention the most; she's an alternate version, so we'll see how she develops. Overall, I liked it. more

It’s amazing! I love this alternative view of Superman’s world and the idea of the kryptonite spectrum blew my mind. I didn’t expected less from the Ice Cream Man team. Can’t wait for the next issue.

A truly dark, experimental and unsettling Superman comic. I am here for it. The excellence of Ice Cream Man in a DC context. The potential for storytelling is almost ludicrous. I am so pleased this is a thing.

Love this. Don't understand the hate. Captain America, a man caught between two eras - Chip understands this beautifully.

His Cap is already better than his Batman, thank goodness.

Just wonderful.

I'm sorry but Wonder Woman beating this (which I don't believe was even nominated) and Absolute Batman for the new series Eisner is a nonsense.

What a beautiful series. Just wow.

A blast. Joe's Spider-man is just fun.

With Waid guiding the ship, multiversal shenanigans are fun again. I think Marc working within Waid's parameters pulled some solid work out of him. I smiled whilst reading, thanks for that DC. The hatred from the Snyderverse folks online is utterly exhausting so the fun of this was appreciated.

10.

A generational comic book spectical.

I will only say this once. Gabe Hernandez is right.

Loeb is one of my all time favourite DC writers.

This is a disaster. The character work is full of contradictions. It's place in continuity is a mind f***. Jeph, what has happened to you?

A 10 for those that cannot get their brains around the fact this is a different Batman. If you want normal Batman and get upset at the notion of a variant, please - spare us your redundant commentary and just don't read it.

This is the perfect comic for 2025. A working class Batman, he fights for the people and stands up to the rich. A mirror pointed at today's society. The rich getting richer, the poor poorer. A gross over simplification but you know the deal. He is defined, not by his wealth and social status, but by his will to help others

"Oh but that's too heavy handed and political! My conservative mind can't handle social commentary because said commentary doesn't align with my beliefs! I can't enjoy anything that deviates from my core values!"

And what next?

"Oh, they changed Matches Mallone!" Like that character is so utterly sacred and can't be different. They did Matches dirty!" Give me strength.

'Edgelord Batman'. Bloody hell, is this a Fox News message board? "Oh everything he says is so extreme and on the nose!" Conservative speak for "I get upset when politics I don't agree with are espoused." Despite the cold hard fact that superheroes are an inherently liberal ideal.

"Ohhh,too much dialogue! Not enough action!" If it was the other way about, they'd say there wasn't enough dialogue - and point out that it's needed as it's a new universe.

This is a new Batman universe and it is still being defined. As such, exposition is required. Is this not obvious? I'd understand the criticism if it was Tom King levels of exposition, this is literally nowhere near that.

Scott Snyders supposed 'shortcomings' have netted him the no 1 comic book in the industry. This series has people excited about comics again. But no - forget that and let's just go back to the same formula we've seen a million times. Let's not try to evolve or innovate.



more

Absolute Batman was robbed. This has to be the most over rated comic this year. I love it as well, just nowhere near as much as everyone else. It's easily, my least favourite .

When you want to get a movie audience to buy your comic, this is what you want to do. Superman Treasury 2025 has it all - love for the character, an inspiring story, excellent art and all the glory and grandeur a superhero book should have. Just awesome!

This was a blast after watching the superman 2025 movie. I love the art and coloring