It's certainly a book that will delight X-Men fans with its extensive character studies and its focus on inter-character relationships all over the X-Men franchise, but it's hard to imagine those dropping in for the sake of a tie-in will be entertained due to the focus on X-Men intrapolitics. It does answer the question of why Wolverine was willing to fight his friends, but there's a distinct lack of "Avengers Vs. X-Men" that in the end is likely to put non-regular readers off. Read Full Review

An interesting possibility for some good drama that doesn't reach its full potential. Read Full Review

Overall this is a great title. Unfortunately, until Bachalo is gone for good, I feel the title will never reach the greatness that it is fully capable of. Read Full Review

I can't recommend this one - it's just marking time while things actually happen in AvX. Read Full Review

Despite some flaws, this issue is another consistent one. The ending is poor, and the art can be difficult, but at heart, this issue expands on the Avengers Vs. X-Men crossover to give some insight into Wolverine and his fellow teachers viewpoints on the conflict, plus some little teasers of some other plots that will continue to bubble below the surface. I'd have bumped this issue up above its predecessor, but those few niggling flaws drag it back down a little, unfortunately. Hopefully these will be ironed out by next issue. Read Full Review

A serious issue and a mildly interesting tie-in. The art is fine but feels unfinished, the story has much more dialogue than action, and ultimately it shine most for the parts that aren't related to the event. Read Full Review

Scott Summers & Logan, two of the most stubborn X-Men have a serious discussion mutant to mutant as some mutants from the school join the fight to save Hope, but which side will they choose? Written by Jason Aaron (Scalped) & illustrated by Chris Bachalo (The Witching Hour). From Marvel Comics. Read Full Review

Dialogue-8/10
Art-1.5/10
Plot-10/10
Total-6.5/10