Andy MacDonald Comic Reviews

Current Series: 1 Total Series: 56 Issues: 61 Critic Reviews: 361 User Reviews: 626
7.5Avg. Issue Rating
7.3Avg. User Rating
+ Creator Watch List

N/A
Bulls of Beacon Hill #5 0 reviews
May 24, 2023
N/A
GWAR: In The Duoverse of Absurdity OGN 0 reviews
Dec 7, 2022
5.4
Wolverine: Infinity Watch #4 4 reviews
May 22, 2019
5.5
Justice League of America (2017) #10 13 reviews
Jul 12, 2017
5.6
Wolverine: Infinity Watch #5 5 reviews
Jun 19, 2019
5.7
Justice League of America (2017) #6 17 reviews
May 10, 2017
6.0
Bulls of Beacon Hill #1 1 reviews
Jan 25, 2023
6.0
Bulls of Beacon Hill #2 1 reviews
Feb 22, 2023
6.0
Image! 30th Anthology #10 1 reviews
Feb 15, 2023
6.0
Miss America 70th Anniversary Special #1 3 reviews
Jun 10, 2009
6.1
Justice League of America (2017) #5 17 reviews
Apr 26, 2017
6.2
Acts of Evil: She-Hulk Annual #1 6 reviews
Aug 28, 2019
6.3
Justice League of America (2017) #11 13 reviews
Jul 26, 2017
6.5
The Terminator: 2029 #1 2 reviews
Mar 31, 2010
6.6
Detective Comics (2016) #942 11 reviews
Oct 12, 2016
6.8
Wolverine: Infinity Watch #1 7 reviews
Feb 20, 2019
6.8
Wolverine: Infinity Watch #3 3 reviews
Apr 17, 2019
7.0
Infinity Wars (2018): Fallen Guardian #1 2 reviews
Dec 19, 2018
7.0
The Terminator: 1984 #1 1 reviews
Sep 29, 2010
7.1
Green Lantern (2021) #5 10 reviews
Aug 4, 2021
7.1
Multiple Man (2018) #1 15 reviews
Jun 27, 2018
7.1
Teen Titans: Earth One #2 6 reviews
Aug 10, 2016
7.2
2020 Machine Man #1 8 reviews
Feb 19, 2020
7.3
Adventures of Bio Boy #1 3 reviews
Nov 30, -0001
7.3
My Date With Monsters #3 2 reviews
Jan 19, 2022
7.4
Multiple Man (2018) #3 7 reviews
Aug 15, 2018
7.5
2020 Machine Man #2 5 reviews
Mar 18, 2020
7.5
Batman: The Brave and the Bold (2023) #15 4 reviews
Jul 24, 2024
7.5
Batman: The Brave and the Bold (2023) #16 2 reviews
Aug 28, 2024
7.5
I Breathed a Body #4 4 reviews
Apr 28, 2021
7.5
Multiple Man (2018) #2 7 reviews
Jul 25, 2018
7.5
Wolverine: Infinity Watch #2 4 reviews
Mar 20, 2019
7.6
Doctor Strange (2018) Annual #1 8 reviews
Oct 30, 2019
7.7
Multiple Man (2018) #5 6 reviews
Oct 31, 2018
7.7
My Date With Monsters #1 5 reviews
Nov 10, 2021
7.8
Justice League of America (2017): The Atom Rebirth #1 25 reviews
Jan 4, 2017
7.8
My Date With Monsters #2 2 reviews
Dec 15, 2021
7.9
DC's Terrors Through Time (2022) #1 7 reviews
Oct 12, 2022
7.9
Detective Comics (2016) #941 15 reviews
Sep 28, 2016
7.9
Rogue Planet #1 15 reviews
May 27, 2020
7.9
Wonder Woman (2016) #775 8 reviews
Jul 14, 2021
8.0
Batman: The Brave and the Bold (2023) #17 4 reviews
Sep 25, 2024
8.0
Bulls of Beacon Hill #3 1 reviews
Mar 29, 2023
8.0
Bulls of Beacon Hill #4 1 reviews
Apr 26, 2023
8.0
I Breathed a Body #2 5 reviews
Feb 24, 2021
8.0
Image! 30th Anthology #11 1 reviews
Mar 15, 2023
8.0
Rogue Planet #2 8 reviews
Jun 24, 2020
8.0
Wonder Woman (2016) #774 10 reviews
Jun 23, 2021
8.2
I Breathed a Body #3 5 reviews
Mar 31, 2021
8.2
Multiple Man (2018) #4 7 reviews
Sep 19, 2018
8.2
Punisher War Journal (2006) #26 2 reviews
Dec 31, 2008
8.2
Rogue Planet #5 4 reviews
Sep 30, 2020
8.4
Doctor Strange (2023) #4 7 reviews
Jun 14, 2023
8.4
Wonder Woman (2016) Annual: 2021 6 reviews
Dec 1, 2021
8.5
Rogue Planet #3 6 reviews
Jul 29, 2020
8.6
I Breathed a Body #1 11 reviews
Jan 20, 2021
8.8
Loki (2019) #5 2 reviews
Nov 20, 2019
9.1
I Breathed a Body #5 3 reviews
May 26, 2021
9.7
My Date With Monsters #4 1 reviews
Feb 23, 2022
9.7
My Date With Monsters #5 1 reviews
Mar 30, 2022
10
Rogue Planet #4 1 reviews
Aug 26, 2020

Reviews for the Week of...

November

October

More