Frankly, the only reason this issue didn't get a perfect 10 was the ham-fisted and unnecessary Guardians cameo. I really hope they have some sort of role in the plot of this arc, because if it's what it seems (a meaningless appearance to help remind us that they've got a movie coming out) it's the only thing that mars this fantastic issue. Read Full Review

For my money's worth, Silver Surfer #4 is an excellent issue that I really recommend. Read Full Review

The Bottom Line: In balancing the mundane with the cosmic, this issue shows how the Silver Surfer works best– when he's put in situations that both highlight his strangeness and his humanity. There's also plenty of humor and suspense, thanks to both the script and the art, keeping things exciting, even with such a gratuitous and nearly pointless appearance with the Guardians of Galaxy. Read Full Review

The Guardians of the Galaxy make a random, pointless guest appearance at the start of this issue. It's abominable. I felt dirty reading the scene. Fortunately, Marvel isn't relying on just their forced comic appearances to sell the movie. And also fortunately, the rest of the comic is pretty awesome. Read Full Review

Silver Surfer #4 is absolutely enchanting, with some lovely touches of character and art, a shocking moment that makes perfect sense (OF COURSE he's heard of Star Wars, he has cosmic awareness!) and continues the streak of Surfer excellence. Read Full Review

Snarling couches, Wizard of Oz references, seafood bisque -- if Silver Surfer goes any further off the beaten path we'll have to send in a rescue team for awesomeness extraction Read Full Review

A great series for new and old fans of Silver Surfer to enjoy. Read Full Review

Slott and the Allreds are doing something really special in Silver Surfer, and issue #4 is a great example of how crazy comics can be when done well. There really are no limits in this medium, and Slott and Allred are really showing that with this title. I highly recommend giving this one a shot (you can even pick up and start with issue #4) just to soak in some brilliant art and some bold storytelling. Read Full Review

Dan Slott and Mike Allred's SILVER SURFER isn't your typical comic. They are pumping in some humor, mystery, and suspense while allowing us to see the Surfer in a slightly different fashion. For a character that's been around as long as he has, it's a nice change of pace. Slott is known for injecting his humor into titles. It might feel like a little too much at times but can you really complain over having a smile put on your face? Mike Allred art and Laura Allred's colors are something I never get enough of. There's also a mystery that's building and wait until you see that last page. What the heck is going on? I can't wait for the next issue. Read Full Review

This issue of Silver Surfer places Dawn back at her inn, but something is different. Youd think people would have a bigger reaction to her being in SPACE, right?! One panel however shows a quick glimpse, notifying the reader that something is going onand the Surfer is going to have to stick around until its been figured out. Read Full Review

The reader's mileage will vary depending on how much he or she enjoyed the retro vibe of both the script and the visuals. The gradual introduction of occult forces into Anchor Bay in "Silver Surfer" #4 is the highlight of its efficient exposition for the beginning of another adventure. Read Full Review

Silver Surfer has been one of Marvel's ambitious creative gambles that has more than paid off during its debut arc. That said, even great titles disappoint sometimes. Silver Surfer #4 is a beautiful-looking comic that is peppered with a few engaging character moments, yet as a whole, it lags a bit. While not unreadable, I don't see much in issue four that I could give to a new reader of the Surfer to get them to come back next month, aside from the promise of more jokes and a possible Defenders reunion. Silver Surfer is a book that is more than worth a spot on your pull list, but issue four might not be the best jumping on point unless you are a Guardians of the Galaxy completist. They say you can't go home again and for the Silver Surfer, that may be more true than he ever cared to realize. Time will tell if that makes a good story or not. Read Full Review

And on attempting to leave our hero finds himself trapped inside the barrier long since removed by Galactus meaning the most interesting aspect not toyed with in Slott's version of the character (his limitless ability to travel across all of space) has been removed along with his dignity and nobility. Kill me now. Read Full Review

Would be a 10 if it wasn’t for the Guardians. I have no idea why they were in this issue, completely unnecessary. I love how everything in Silver Surfer 4 is hauntingly off: the fisherman being swallowed up by tentacles, the Greenwood Inn furniture growing teeth, the bisque growing a hand, and Silver Surfer’s nap. The return of the barrier was pretty crazy too