JSA #16

9.1

Critic Rating

2 Reviews
8.1

User Rating

7 Reviews
Writer Jeff Lemire
Artist Gavin Guidry
Cover Price $3.99

As our heroes converge on Starco in Gotham City, the villain pulling all the strings is finally revealed!

Reviews (2) User Reviews (7) Rate / Write A Review

CRITIC REVIEWS

Back to Top
  • 9.5

    Geek Dad - Ray Goldfield

    Feb 04, 2026

    This story is a big-scale threat enough to justify bringing all these heroes together, but it's also a great opportunity to show us what drives each of them and give a spotlight to some heroes who have been dead and out of focus for decades. Read Full Review

  • 8.6

    Fanlight Zone - Ken M.

    Feb 04, 2026

    Many secrets are finally revealed as "Year One moves onward. Lemire balances out the drama with solid action. Guidry & Guerrero throw some great looks into the big twists and turns that challenge each hero. "Year One has been a timeless trip that everyone should get a ticket for. Check it out. Read Full Review

USER REVIEWS

Back to Top
  • 7.0

    BatSledge

    Feb 09, 2026

    The story continues but I feel like there are very few answers or revelations taking place to help us understand what's going on and why. We do get a reveal of the villain behind it all, but it lands with a thud. There's no dramatic tension, there are a lot of characters and story threads in motion, and through it all, I feel very little. This comes as quite a surprise considering how much I love Lemire's Absolute Flash, which is so very different.

  • 7.0

    fzanca

    Feb 12, 2026

    This already feels like it's dragging. Lemire has the talent of drawing out stories until they become zombies dragging their lifeless corpses along the concrete. I'm not really interested in this interation of the JSA. I would have preferred to read about the younger members, rather than going back to year one. This should have been a quick 3 to 4 issue arc. And why is Hippolyta here? Doesn't that destroy WW lore? If she had all of these friends in "man's world" why would she be apprehensive about sending Diana years later. It's stipulated quite clearly that no one had gone to "man's world." So, I don't like that at all. If they were going to break canon, it should have been Diana, not Hipolyta as this could have been set around WWII. If th more

  • 10

    RJ

    Feb 04, 2026

  • 9.0

    Nicetrylaoche

    Feb 05, 2026

  • 8.5

    daspidaboy

    Feb 09, 2026

  • 8.0

    ZachPort123

    Feb 07, 2026

  • 7.5

    COREMARK

    Feb 08, 2026

Reviews for the Week of...

February

January

28 21