A dream that actually feels like a dream. So few writers really know how to do that. (Inception, I love you but nothing there is even a tiny bit dream logic.) The only issue I have with this is reverting to calling Mary's alter ego Mary Marvel. DC's been trying to get rid of that for ages.

Clumsy and overstuffed.

Still fun but padded.

Anyone remember Lady in the Lake? A Philip Marlowe story shot from the PoV of Marlowe? What's that? You've never heard of it? Maybe that's because it's a silly gimmick. It certainly was here, great art in service of a rather bland gimmick and yet another dull and pedantic Tom Taylor story. This comic's gone from DC's best to its least exciting in the space of about a year.

A confusing bore. For those of us who haven't been reading what's been up with Kara...Karen...Peggy?...it would have been nice to have something explain her latest status quo. But this isn't the Power Girl I remember from Johns's JSA series. She's anything but assertive, anything but powerful. And this was just dull enough that I stopped in the middle and realized I never finished it. I have no desire to keep going. more

Solid first issue by someone who gets the rhythms of comic book writing pretty fast. Though we all know that John Henry will be wearing the armor a lot more than he plans.

Love it just for Garak, Tom Paris at the wheel, and Data talking to Spot. Silly at times, but just keeps hitting all the really cool Star Trek notes. (Note to Lanzing and Kelly: you need to find a way to use characters from Prodigy before everyone forgets they exist.)

Great art. But otherwise flavorless mush, with only three characters with any personality (Nightwing, Wally, and Cyborg, and hey, all of them have their own books), far too many instances of the Titans telling us they will do things differently, and oh good Evil Waller is in the wings. Taylor has no feel for making the Titans interesting, though I am starting to think I only liked them on the old cartoon. more

With the time hopping put aside, the story is a lot more coherent, but I don't really know how these characters align with the last JSA comics from before Flashpoint. What happened to the third Dr. Midnight? Just who is Power Girl now? I am a bit lost even if I like the story (and love the art).

Wacky heartfelt fun in the right key of Trek. Plus Data is your new DM.

I read this two hours ago and it's fading from memory already. This version of Conner never pops, and the story is interesting only in fits and starts. The "preview" for an Alan Scott comic that will never be looks great and reads like we got lucky it was aborted.

Waid throws a lot of good ideas against the wall, but we seems to have lost the thread along the way. Wasn't this about Bruce Wayne being accused of murder? Very silver agey, for good and for ill.

Solid conclusion to a solid comic, though whether we actually see more of most of Young Justice Society is up in the air.

As suspenseful as a menu, with flat characterizations for most of the Titans, and of course the nonsensical notion of an eight year old girl being trained to be a warrior. Can we get back to Bludhaven? And if we do, can we get back to giving something challenging for Nightwing to do?

A solid first issue drawing on the best Cyborg stories from the comics and from TV but working to stand on its own. The art leaves a bit to be desired, but this feels like the sort of story Cy should have been part of a long time ago.

All six issues dropped on the DC app. Readable enough, but inconsistent character portrayals, the jarring addition of Victoria Kord, and a generally simplistic story make it nothing special. And it's just really, really hard to imagine a city in the state of Texas happily allowing a ship of aliens to stay around when things are inhospitable to other human being from other nations. Overall, it reads like a smiley happy YA comic. more

I want more of this. More Joe, more old school Spidey, and more PAD. Get well soon, dude!

Fun if a bit lightweight, and it feels like Waid would have preferred to write the character as he was in 1995. Plus Waid gets it wrong: Solomon was both wise and smart. But overall, the vibe is strong and it's clear the Waid/Mora team knows what they are doing once again.

Solid first issue that goes a long way to acknowledging how outdated Hal is, while also making him the best at what he does. It's a pity that DC still insists on making Hal the one GL with a series, but that doesn't mean it can't be good. Jury is still out on the John Stewart backup.

At last, a hero I can relate to! He is also still masking! (First overt reference in any DC book to the pandemic?)

A promising start by an accomplished talent, and nice that a new book can launch without having a guest appearance by a big name hero.

Very good first issue that leaves me wanting more, and it's really interesting how little this actually needs to be in the DCU. Though given Ram V's knowledge of the DCU, I expect him to have fun with it.

The stuff with the mob families is a bit obtuse, but the main thread is fascinating and thoughtful and Greg is clearly applying the skills he acquired writing Young Justice to this, since you just couldn't be this complex in a cartoon in 1995.

Never seen Lower Decks, but kind of love that a character from that is here and being played seriously.

Adams does a great job of hearkening back to some unfulfilled plotlines from the Johns era while still making this his own book. It remains a pity that DC is cutting this run short.

Reasonably entertaining but I bet I forget it in an hour.

Nostalgia not just for the event but for how comics were once written. And it doesn't add up to much. The first story - the only one that isn't just a flashback - has far too much of Jurgens's often clumsy dialogue and pacing (though it also has his grasp of Superman and his art). The Ordway and Stern stories are okay but add little to the original story. Only the Simonson/Bogdanove story really resonates, with some of the best art Bogdanove has done in ages and a reminder why Steel is such an important character. more

Tepid stuff cover to cover. A rather poorly defined Connor, and a rather bland cast of new characters. The action is okay, but otherwise this is forgettable. Not bad, just forgettable.

Ironically, the preview of the never-to-be-published Kid Flash comic does more in eight pages to get my interest than Superboy's done in two full issues.

i feel like I missed something between the issues, and it does get murky. But this is the Data I remember from the 80s, and I love that chat between Data and Scotty and "wait, MY B'Elanna?"

What is with these generic covers lately? Then again, the Titans continue to feel pretty generic. But this issue just doesn't hold together. Everything seems too pat. Show of hands here: who thinks Dick is actually tempted by Neron? And is it really wise to: a) teach a little girl combat; or b) think she will learn anything useful that quickly.

The back-up's pretty good but is it worth the extra dollar? more