BatSledge's Profile

Joined: Nov 27, 2023

Recent Activity

BatSledge reviewed Absolute Superman #11 Sep 4, 2025
10

The last few issues have built up to this perfect chapter, wherein the art and writing come together to tell a harrowing tale of violence and torture that, through it all, shows the incredible resilience of the Absolute Man of Steel and his allies. As the action now shifts to Kansas, I can’t wait to see where things go from here, and in the meantime, I’m going to have nightmares about Braniac more

Absolute Superman #11

By: Jason Aaron, Carmine Di Giandomenico
Released: Sep 3, 2025

For five years, he’s been on the run, hounded across our planet, and treatedlike a criminal…yet his only crime was being born somewhere else. NowSuperman’s rage threatens to engulf the world at the urging of Ra’s al Ghul.And the only ones who can save the day…are Kal-El’s dead parents.

+ LikeComment
BatSledge reviewed JSA #11 Sep 3, 2025
7.0

I feel like Lemire is more in his Animal Man-style comfort zone writing Absolute Flash versus this book. He seems to have difficulty here with pacing, transitions and a giant cast of characters. It’s still good, but it’s not compelling in the way Johns’ first two JSA books were (I won’t bring up his last run). This arc is also going on way too long but I’m hopeful for an exciting wrap-u more

JSA #11

By: Jeff Lemire, Diego Olortegui
Released: Sep 3, 2025

The Injustice Society has the JSA on the ropes, and Wotan’s grand plan ofreleasing the Unnamed Ones is one step closer to reality. But they forgotone thing: The JSA is not just a team—it’s a family!

+ LikeComment
BatSledge liked this:
Martin reviewed Batman #1 Sep 3, 2025
8.0

I don’t like the constant renumbering of comics back to issue one … so I was already suspicious of Batman #1 even before I bought it, that being said I liked it. The main drawback is that it fails as a first issue - no explanation as to why Gordon is a 60 year old beat cop, or how Vandal Savage is the new police commissioner. Also it’s clear that Alfred is dead and only appearing in Bruce’ more

Batman #1

By: Matt Fraction, Jorge Jimenez
Released: Sep 3, 2025

A new day dawns for the Dark Knight Detective as Eisner Award-winningwriter Matt Fraction (Hawkeye, Superman’s Pal Jimmy Olsen) joins forces withsuperstar artist Jorge Jiménez (Batman, Summer of Superman Special) for anunforgettable new era of Batman!The best superhero in comics gets a brand-new first issue to kick off this newera that will test...

+ LikeComment
BatSledge commented on this:
motorik reviewed Batman #1 Sep 2, 2025
9.0

Loving the art from the off. Very vibrant. Pops, if you will. Nice to open a new run with a beloved character from the off and tapping in to precious nostalgia. I am enjoying beat cop Gordon!

Things escalate very quickly and some kind of creature is terrorizing Gotham (how original! I jest).

This Batman doesn't suffer fools . Our first central mystery appears to relate to more

Batman #1

By: Matt Fraction, Jorge Jimenez
Released: Sep 3, 2025

A new day dawns for the Dark Knight Detective as Eisner Award-winningwriter Matt Fraction (Hawkeye, Superman’s Pal Jimmy Olsen) joins forces withsuperstar artist Jorge Jiménez (Batman, Summer of Superman Special) for anunforgettable new era of Batman!The best superhero in comics gets a brand-new first issue to kick off this newera that will test...

+ LikeComments (8)
George - Sep 3, 2025

The meta approach is very well done. We may not be getting a deconstruction of Batman, but we will get a story about if a man can change. Especially if that man is a fictional character that can’t really change.

BatSledge - Sep 3, 2025

You touched on all the key highlights here that stood out for me, plus I also loved the coloring in this issue. A key part of the artwork.

BatSledge liked this:
daspidaboy reviewed Batman #1 Sep 3, 2025
9.0

It seems that ever since Grant Morrison and Scott Snyder finished their Batman runs, every writer starts off strong but in the end falls flat. Tom King's run started off strong with his first arcs (The I am Trilogy) but then falls flat at City of Bane. I am one of the minority who personally enjoys James Tynion IV's Batman run, but I think it is very shallow. Joshua Williamson's filler run was not more

Batman #1

By: Matt Fraction, Jorge Jimenez
Released: Sep 3, 2025

A new day dawns for the Dark Knight Detective as Eisner Award-winningwriter Matt Fraction (Hawkeye, Superman’s Pal Jimmy Olsen) joins forces withsuperstar artist Jorge Jiménez (Batman, Summer of Superman Special) for anunforgettable new era of Batman!The best superhero in comics gets a brand-new first issue to kick off this newera that will test...

+ LikeComments (2)
George - Sep 3, 2025

This issues reminded me a lot of Morrison’s first issue of Batman.

Criminology. - Sep 5, 2025

I think Snyder also had a weak finish

BatSledge liked this:
George reviewed Batman #1 Sep 3, 2025
9.0

Close to perfect first issue.

Batman #1

By: Matt Fraction, Jorge Jimenez
Released: Sep 3, 2025

A new day dawns for the Dark Knight Detective as Eisner Award-winningwriter Matt Fraction (Hawkeye, Superman’s Pal Jimmy Olsen) joins forces withsuperstar artist Jorge Jiménez (Batman, Summer of Superman Special) for anunforgettable new era of Batman!The best superhero in comics gets a brand-new first issue to kick off this newera that will test...

+ LikeComments (1)
motorik - Sep 3, 2025

Agreed!

BatSledge reviewed Batman #1 Sep 3, 2025
8.5

It’s hard to judge based on just one issue, but Fraction’s first Batman outing shines through in a way that we haven’t seen on the main Bat-book in many years. He begins putting down a strong foundation consisting of an interesting supporting cast, a rather exciting new take on the city itself, a new look at an old villain, and a somewhat more thoughtful, humane and inciteful first person n more

Batman #1

By: Matt Fraction, Jorge Jimenez
Released: Sep 3, 2025

A new day dawns for the Dark Knight Detective as Eisner Award-winningwriter Matt Fraction (Hawkeye, Superman’s Pal Jimmy Olsen) joins forces withsuperstar artist Jorge Jiménez (Batman, Summer of Superman Special) for anunforgettable new era of Batman!The best superhero in comics gets a brand-new first issue to kick off this newera that will test...

+ LikeComment
BatSledge added Batman (2025) to their pull list Sep 3, 2025

Batman (2025)

A new day dawns for the Dark Knight Detective as Eisner Award-winningwriter Matt Fraction (Hawkeye, Superman’s Pal Jimmy Olsen) joins forces withsuperstar artist Jorge Jiménez (Batman, Summer of Superman Special) for anunforgettable new era of Batman!The best superhero in comics gets a brand-new first issue to kick off this newera that will test...

+ LikeComment
BatSledge reviewed Justice League Unlimited #10 Aug 29, 2025
9.0

HINT: If you read this week’s issue of SUPERMAN, issue 29, and then read this issue of JUSTICE LEAGUE, you’ll find it’s a one-two punch from Waid, Williamson and Mora that throws Superman and the JL into the next great Crisis that’s stemming from Darkseid, his Omega Energy, and his Absolute Legion! I’m rather surprised that DC has under-marketed this event for a change, instead of slapp more

Justice League Unlimited #10

By: Mark Waid, Dan Mora
Released: Aug 27, 2025

The Quantum Quorum of time-traveler refugees has issued its warning tothe Justice League: Apokolips is coming. But just as Jor-El's cries fell on thedeaf ears of Krypton, will the people of Earth be prepared to take drasticsteps to save their world? It all comes to a head as the chaos continues, andone Leaguer is put to the ultimate test!

+ LikeComments (2)
motorik - Sep 1, 2025

Hi mate thank you for highlighting this. I'll be reading Williams Superman run. Do you recommend going back a few volumes? Cheers

BatSledge - Sep 2, 2025

I think you can start at the beginning of Williamson’s SUPERMAN run, which launched back in 2023, issue 1. Most of the issues are very good and are a lot of fun, and in particular, his characterization of Luthor is compelling! The current storyline with the Absolute Legion started in issue 28 from July, another good jumping-on point that hit stands as the movie was released.

BatSledge reviewed Absolute Wonder Woman #11 Aug 29, 2025
8.5

Another winning chapter that brings us everything we love about Absolute Diana, both past and present, in ways that far outshine her characterization in her regular monthly DCU title by Tom King. This title has been stellar for almost a full-year so far. Kudos to this creative team as they wrap up the maze storyline next month.

Absolute Wonder Woman #11

By: Kelly Thompson, Hayden Sherman
Released: Aug 27, 2025

The balance of power inside the maze is tilting with Diana’s presence, but itmay just tilt into full-blown chaos. Chaos in an underground maze prison…that’s bad, right?

+ LikeComment
BatSledge reviewed Superman #29 Aug 29, 2025
9.0

The plot really does thicken, and escalates the stakes, with this issue. Has a bit of a “Yesterday’s Enterprise “ feel going for it, too. With the cliffhanger ending, this feels like it has the makings of the next big DCU crisis, one that will also pull in the Absolute universe! I’m very excited to see what happens next. Williamson and Mora once again prove to be an unbeatable team!

Superman #29

By: Joshua Williamson, Dan Mora
Released: Aug 27, 2025

Superman and an impossible ally search the future for the lost Legion ofSuper-Heroes! What happened to it, and can it help in the battle againstDarkseid’s Absolute Legion?

+ LikeComments (1)
motorik - Sep 1, 2025

Yesterday's Enterprise, beautiful comparison my friend!

10

The first arc ends on a perfect cliffhanging note, following a showdown between good and evil that plays out on multiple fronts. The people of the city, the Martian, John, his wife and his son are all waging a war against evil in this finale, and not everyone escapes unscathed. I’m pissed that we have to wait until December for the series to resume!!

Absolute Martian Manhunter #6

By: Deniz Camp, Javier Rodriguez
Released: Aug 27, 2025

Ideas explode like atom bombs, minds melt, and colors clash in the darknessbehind the eyes of every person on the planet. It’s Green Martian versusWhite Martian, John Jones versus madness itself, as he fights to save hisfamily—and the world.

+ LikeComment
BatSledge reviewed Detective Comics #1100 Aug 20, 2025
9.0

The Taylor and Rucka stories were absolutely sensational both with art and writing! I liked the other stories quite a bit as well, considering I’m not a big fan of Watters or Tamaki. I was a bit underwhelmed by this anniversary issue compared to previous milestone centennial issues, where you’d often find additional pin-ups by great artists as well as an occasional essay or two. Still, a real more

Detective Comics #1100

By: Tom Taylor, Mikel Janin
Released: Aug 20, 2025

In March 1937, a comic book was published that changed the world as weknow it. Now, 1,099 issues later, some of comics’ top talents have gatheredto celebrate the comic that birthed a legend!Tom Taylor and Mikel Janín join forces once again to tell a heartfelt andaction-packed story of Batman rescuing a young boy’s best friend. GregRucka and Á...

+ LikeComment
BatSledge reviewed Absolute Flash #6 Aug 20, 2025
9.0

This issue was a fantastic rebound from the clunky art and storytelling of the previous Heat Wave issue. We get an intriguing origin for the Absolute Rogues that improves upon the classic DCU group, and still poses exciting details yet to come. Additionally, there’s new shades presented regarding Wally’s dad: he’s not quite the monster we were led to believe, and he too experiences betraya more

Absolute Flash #6

By: Jeff Lemire, Nick Robles
Released: Aug 20, 2025

Just who are the mysterious Rogues chasing after Wally West, and how did they join Project Olympus?

+ LikeComment
BatSledge reviewed Absolute Batman #11 Aug 20, 2025
10

This saga continues to defy expectations both in the story and the artwork. I think this issue takes Bane’s 1993 origin story and expands and improves upon it in fresh new ways, while advancing the main story in scary and exciting ways as well. All of this leads to a shocking cliffhanger in the last 2 pages. This is Snyder’s magnum opus!

Absolute Batman #11

By: Scott Snyder, Clay Mann
Released: Aug 20, 2025

Learn the origin of Bane! What drives the muscle-bound behemoth, and how did he arrive in Gotham?

+ LikeComments (1)
motorik - Aug 21, 2025

Magnum Opus. Exactly.

BatSledge reviewed Absolute Superman #10 Aug 8, 2025
9.0

This storyline continues to dazzle and surprise the reader, not only with the great character work being done here, but also the big reveal on the final page, which I expect nobody saw coming!

Absolute Superman #10

By: Jason Aaron, Rafa Sandoval
Released: Aug 6, 2025

Superman’s true enemy stands revealed. The notorious Ra’s al Ghul, lord ofLazarus Corp, murderer of millions, has plans for the Last Son of Krypton.Will Kal-El’s rage unleash the dark power of Superman: Son of the Demon?

+ LikeComment
BatSledge rated JSA #10 Aug 8, 2025
7.5

JSA #10

By: Jeff Lemire, Rafael de Latorre
Released: Aug 6, 2025

What secrets lie within Blackhawk Island? Can the JSA uncover them before the Injustice Society burns the island and its mysteries with it?

+ LikeComment
BatSledge reviewed Absolute Green Lantern #5 Aug 8, 2025
9.0

After 3 consecutive issues where barely anything happened to move the present-day storyline forward, we finally get progress and forward momentum this issue, and quite exciting momentum at that. A nice rebound for the series, and hopefully a sign of things to come.

Absolute Green Lantern #5

By: Al Ewing, Jahnoy Lindsay
Released: Aug 6, 2025

The remains of Evergreen are scavenged for clues as to what happenedto this quaint small town. Meanwhile, Jo faces down the hulking threatof Hal Jordan!

+ LikeComment
BatSledge reviewed Titans Annual: 2025 Aug 1, 2025
8.5

Gorgeous looking book with exquisite writing. Potential Eisner Award nominee here.

Titans Annual: 2025

By: Phil Jimenez
Released: Jul 30, 2025

Multiple Eisner Award-winning superstar artist and storyteller Phil Jimenez (Wonder Woman: Historia) makes his grand return to another fan-favorite Wonder Woman in this oversized annual story! Donna Troy reflects on the many loves and lives that shaped her as she cuts a trail through New York City to meet her estranged father for the very first tim...

+ LikeComment
8.0

Improves upon the previous issue in the narrative, but the art is wildly inconsistent.

New History of the DC Universe #2

By: Mark Waid, Brad Walker
Released: Jul 23, 2025

The DC Universe as we know it begins to take shape as a mysterious ship crash-lands in Smallville, and years later, Superman makes his debut. Meanwhile, inGotham City, Batman emerges from the shadows to clean its crime-ridden streets,and after years of isolation from Man’s World, Wonder Woman leaves the paradiseof Themyscira for modern society. A...

+ LikeComment
BatSledge rated Superman #28 Jul 28, 2025
8.0

Superman #28

By: Joshua Williamson, Dan Mora
Released: Jul 23, 2025

Since the start of All In, Darkseid’s Legion has stalked the DC Universe. Andnow they finally attack Superman! What is this Legion’s deadly mission andhow does it kick off the next phase of All In?!Don't miss out on this crucial issue that sets up a massive event forSuperman and the DC Universe!

+ LikeComment
8.0

Justice League Unlimited #9

By: Mark Waid, Dan Mora
Released: Jul 23, 2025

In the aftermath of the devastating events of We Are Yesterday, the Justice Leagueis reeling from the Legion of Doom’s wrathful rampage! But no time to rest for theprotectors of our planet, as the secrets unlocked during their time-crossed duel havebrought our heroes face-to-face with a mysterious Quantum Quorum, who has reasonto fear that all of...

+ LikeComment
BatSledge reviewed Green Lantern #25 Jul 28, 2025
6.5

The whole Starbreaker saga has been largely and inexplicably ignored for the past several issues. The attempt at a jump-start here is fairly successful but still too decompressed to make it exciting. Additionally, I am not enjoying the constant cutting back and forth between storylines. It’s good but should be so much better. The art continues to be excellent, however.

Green Lantern #25

By: Jeremy Adams, Xermanico
Released: Jul 23, 2025

The Green Lantern Corps makes a mad dash to Gemworld, hoping to finda particular gem that will light the new Central Power Batteries! But ithas to beat Starbreaker and his minions to do it, all while Ellie uncoversa secret buried inside Keli’s mind and an old friend returns to Oa!

+ LikeComment
BatSledge reviewed Batman #161 Jul 28, 2025
3.5

This story gets worse with each chapter and is a colossal disappointment by all involved except maybe the colorist and the letterer. As others have pointed out, there are massive contradictions with recent continuity, most of the Bat-family is out of character from recent portrayals, and Batman himself in this issue is completely ineffectual. Nothing he does here matters. Robin saves him and then more

Batman #161

By: Jeph Loeb, Jim Lee
Released: Jul 23, 2025

Batman’s battle with Hush takes a dark turn when Damian (Robin) and Bane team up!

+ LikeComment
BatSledge reviewed Green Arrow #26 Jul 28, 2025
8.0

This storyline is a huge improvement over the previous one, despite the writer’s ongoing penchant for decompressed storytelling.

Green Arrow #26

By: Chris Condon, Montos
Released: Jul 23, 2025

Shocked by the mysterious and nefarious attack on Arsenal, Green Arrow enliststhe help of Detective Benítez to uncover clues as to who Star City's dangerous andcold-blooded new archer is. Meanwhile, Lian rejoins the fray and discovers hardtruths and dark secrets about her father's past as Green Arrow's once-upon-a-timesidekick, Speedy.

+ LikeComment
BatSledge reviewed Detective Comics #1099 Jul 18, 2025
8.0

Lots to enjoy in this wrap-up to the Elixir storyline, especially the fun chemistry between this goofy and unlikely trio. However, the ending is a bit weird and anticlimactic with the reveal of the criminal mastermind, along with some loose ends that aren’t fully resolved. Would have liked to know why Ra’s got involved with these goons.

Detective Comics #1099

By: Tom Taylor, Lee Garbett
Released: Jul 16, 2025

Stranded far from home, Batman, Harvey Bullock, and the Penguin must form ashaky alliance to bring down the age-old immortality cult known only as Elixir. Butas tensions rise among this unlikely trio, it becomes increasingly doubtful that thisalliance is possible…or that the Dark Knight will ever make it back to Gotham City.

+ LikeComment
BatSledge reviewed Batman & Robin: Year One #9 Jul 18, 2025
8.5

Both this issue and the previous one are the best chapters yet. Waid provides a clever twist this issue that I was half-expecting, but not in the way he delivered it. The emergence of Two-Face as a series villain is also a highlight for me. Alfred steals the issue with a perfect, heart-tugging scene. I’m eager to see how Waid wraps things up in the next three issues!

Batman & Robin: Year One #9

By: Mark Waid, Chris Samnee
Released: Jul 16, 2025

The gangs of Gotham enact their plan to take back their city from the General!Meanwhile, something’s distracting Robin in the field—but is there anythingBatman can do about it?

+ LikeComment
BatSledge liked this:
motorik reviewed Batman & Robin: Year One #9 Jul 16, 2025
10

Waid's modern masterpiece.

What a beautifully written Alfred. They really must reverse his death in the main series. His lack of presence in mainline Batman is felt each passing year.

Batman & Robin: Year One #9

By: Mark Waid, Chris Samnee
Released: Jul 16, 2025

The gangs of Gotham enact their plan to take back their city from the General!Meanwhile, something’s distracting Robin in the field—but is there anythingBatman can do about it?

BatSledge liked this:
George reviewed Batman & Robin: Year One #9 Jul 16, 2025
9.5

This book is so great! With a great twist for the final act.

Batman & Robin: Year One #9

By: Mark Waid, Chris Samnee
Released: Jul 16, 2025

The gangs of Gotham enact their plan to take back their city from the General!Meanwhile, something’s distracting Robin in the field—but is there anythingBatman can do about it?

+ LikeComment
7.5

Wad pulled off a tricky stunt with this issue: a Bizarro story that is fairly coherent and sensible, and even scary at times. I’m usually not a fan of the Bizarro characters so I had initially approached the issue with trepidation, but thanks to Waid’s script and the gorgeous artwork, I was pleasantly surprised.

Batman / Superman: World's Finest #41

By: Mark Waid, Adrian Gutierrez
Released: Jul 16, 2025

Up is down, left is right, and red is green—but danger is still danger as Batmanand Superman awaken on Bizarro World with no idea how they got there—or whythey’re being hunted by one of the most dangerous beings in the universe! Even ifthey survive, can they find their way home from a backward planet in time to savetheir friends from danger?

+ LikeComment

Reviews for the Week of...

September

August

More