Morbid as all get out. Lord Death Man had Evil Deadpool written all over him. Other than that -and it was a lot, plenty of whacky fun. And good art effort.

Really enjoyed much of this. Makes all those mini series ALMOST worth while now.

As far as long overdue relaunches go this was absolutely... a... uhm... long overdue relaunch. Nothing bad but nothing really notable and that Doom backp was very disagreeable.

I give it a 7.8 so I'll be generous and round up. More so for the eclectic DCUmystics appearances than having a clear understanding of this magical threat that WW feels compelled to spearhead the solution for. And there were a couple nice images with an otherwise decent art effort.

Nothing wow-worthy but a solid read.

I am still super worried that the payoff/reveal of the canonical impact of this will be a disconsolately creative choice. But it's impossible to disagree with the high ratings this issue deserves in itself at face value. Skirting around Scott's dumb suicide decision still bothers me. But at least it was finally noted as a storypoint here.

Comics: The Gathering - Charles Martin's comments nail the problems with this.

It was a solid and positive conclusion. Peter's sacrifices show Spidey at his best.

I don't like the art that much. Or the contrived way for Son of Odin to call in the Valkyrior.

This was content packed - with GOOD content and dangler followups.

Big 'death' scene. Big last page cameo. Big ship on self-destruct. Big props for this ish.

That good. Shocked by the lower average rating.

That good. Just need to clear up The Terrifics connection contradiction. And the art was mostly good but some of the panels were too rushed compared to the good.

An odd way to end the run. Danglers left to the next creative team. The disconnect from the canon and Big #800 was a bit disappointing. Still, in itself it was a real fun and heartwarming one-shot micro-story. And as far as retcons go this was NOT typically offputting for it.

Run of the mill conclusion to a 2-parter but much better than part 1 was. There was good art and a feel good ending. The Reaper was more entertaining than the superparanoia the plotpitch was trying to dump on Harley. Good-bye Frank and June, have a good life but don't come back.

Frustrated now. This had so many GOOD elements to it and WOULD'VE gotten top marks if it was an early on issue BUT it ain't and we really don't know what we're really reading yet. I'm starting to dread the fact if this all proves to be "not really real" Also, here's hoping the final issue #12 isn't a force infodump to explain it all (belatedly) after 1 year publishing.

Generally boring. Dumb numbering.

Not very entertaining riddles or tie-in motivation.

It was fun. Art was strong. Couple new characters, an origin twist and a conclusion to be must see resolved that has me interested. No connection to The Terrifics is a real turn off though.

This was good drama building with using 2 A-List DCU characters in Slade and Talia. NIT: The censoring of the curse words is a bit jarring failingly trying to figure out what word could possibly fit with that number of letters.

Not to bad. A bit overwhelming because it feels so rushed for a grand endeavor. Gar and Vril had good moments.

8 for art. 7.5 What-Iffery story at best.

Agree with blurb of ComicBook.com - Christian Hoffer. But his rating is too low 'cuz this average Spider-tale was not bad and better than other books, out this week, if the equally average art was not better.

Premise wasn't executed well enough.

Boring. Art hurts it more. Tying in Cube makes it worse.

I find myself not wanting to argue with Weird Science - Jim Werner's sentiments. But this insta..ment is still better than other books this week so going to give it a better rating.

This continues to be a fun run. Jase bests Pengy. Arti makes headway helping Biz. Only the 2 simple stories but the outcomes were worth it. And somebody had sex with Ma Gunn?!

The daughter in danger angle is interesting but the setup/battle to get there felt too lopsided and/or contrived to get there. June, Croc, and Deady will probably end up fine sooner than later. And poor Harley didn't have any worthwhile lines.

Pretty standard conclusion. Nothing bad per se. The ONLY reason Bullseye lost was cuz it was OML's book so that felt a bit trope-y.