I haven’t loved the vampire stuff much, but I really liked this issue. Some of the full panels on this were awesome.

Fast paced when the Riddler mind games mixed in. I enjoyed it.

The first pages of the issue are good.. Batman solving the puzzles and trying to get to the riddler as fast as possible is just amazing, I think the plot goes from more to less when Batman leaves the riddle as "silly", this "plot twist" is very bland and cheap, and the sudden change of personality and goals of the riddle feels unnatural and rushed.. However, the last page of the comic poses an unexpected (Excellent, by the way) plot twist 
and turns the zero interest I had in the outcome into an impatience and excitement to see the end of this arc.
more

Very interesting twist on the backstory

The “critics” rating this above 9 should be questioned. To each their own, but if you think this book is a 9+ you have to rate everything amazingly.

The book is fine, a better installment for this 8 deaths run that’s just a holdover until the new permanent team. For what this arc is doing, it’s doing a fine job.

Solid blend of action and drama.

Another issue where Peter barely says anything, but yet, still another amazing (ultimate even) issue.

Oh,please stop with the over-the-top hyperbole. A few months ago we had "the most shattering event in the last 50 years" (paraphrasing)- the death of whatshername. Now this is "the most brutal fight in Marvel's history?" Not even in the top 50. And the issue ends virtually identical to where it started. Large panels, filler chase scenes. Bo-ring.

Just a big action scene with some horrendous JR art. But at least it was fun.

Wells delivers an intense enough fight to distract from the fact that the plot doesn't progress, but JRJR stumbles after a couple of stronger issues. The idea of #59's cover being a continuation of the cliffhanger is fun, but unfortunately the actual cover is terrible

Not as good as it was hyped up to be, but still a good action issue.

Great read, I can feel the build.

Where was this the rest of the run?

In response to Nick Lowe’s letter responses, there are a LOT of us who have not enjoyed this run, I don’t believe that’s as “bold” of a take as you believe.

I doing typically like these big events but this has been good

Giving it an extra 0.5 for the art in the back story. Wow. The emotion they captured in the faces was phenomenal.

The primary story was really good, too, but the props to the back story art was needed.

Fun book, the line on the last page would’ve been better if vultures were actually birds of prey.

Good read

More like a 7.75, im rounding up. I’m a Kaine fan, so I’m excited he’s playing a prominent role here. There’s enough mystery here to get me to pick up the second issue.

It was entertaining but nothing really happened to advance the story.