Melkor's Profile

Joined: Feb 01, 2017

Recent Activity

Melkor rated Nightwing #104 Jan 17, 2019
7.5

Nightwing #104

By: Scott Beatty, Scott McDaniel
Released: Feb 23, 2005

The newly christened Nightwing hits the streets for the first time! But it'll take a night of crime-fighting against Gotham''s worst--including the Joker--to win Batgirl over. Plus, Nightwing's first encounter with the new Robin: Jason Todd! "Nightwing: Year One" part 4.

+ LikeComment
Melkor rated Nightwing #103 Jan 17, 2019
7.5

Nightwing #103

By: Scott Beatty, Scott McDaniel
Released: Feb 9, 2005

Dick Grayson has been fired from being Robin and has struck out on his own, directionless. But Dick's about to receive a visit from Deadman! And what connection does the body-hopping hero have to the circus where Dick grew up? "Nightwing: Year One" part 3.

+ LikeComment
Melkor rated Nightwing #102 Jan 12, 2019
8.0

Nightwing #102

By: Scott Beatty, Scott McDaniel
Released: Jan 26, 2005

After being fired by Batman, the former Robin seeks direction and understanding under the bright lights of Metropolis. But the Man of Steel may not have time to help Dick after a team of mad bombers threatens to blow up his city! "Nightwing: Year One" part 2, guest-starring Superman.

+ LikeComment
Melkor rated Nightwing #101 Jan 12, 2019
8.0

Nightwing #101

By: Scott Beatty, Scott McDaniel
Released: Jan 12, 2005

"Nightwing: Year One" part 1! Before Dick Grayson can get on with life, he must look back at his early years, starting with his last caper as the Dark Knight's partner Robin, the Boy Wonder!

+ LikeComment
Melkor rated Reborn Collected Jan 12, 2019
7.0

Reborn Collected

By: Mark Millar, Jonathan Glapion

The MILLAR-CAPULLO smash-hit, sell-out REBORN is here. Where do you go when you die? Not heaven or hell--somewhere else. Somewhere you have to fight to survive. Somewhere the people from the past are waiting for you--the good and the bad.
  
Superstar creators MARK MILLAR and GREG CAPULLO join forces to create the sci-fi story of the year,...

+ LikeComment
Melkor reviewed Reborn #6 Jan 12, 2019
7.0

Overrated

Reborn #6

By: Mark Millar, Greg Capullo
Released: Jun 7, 2017

MINI-SERIES FINALE! The big finale of the smash-hit MILLAR-CAPULLO series REBORN is here. The action-packed climax sees Bonnie taking revenge on past enemies and finding her husband Harry, with Big Tom and Roy-Boy by her side.

+ LikeComment
Melkor rated Reborn #5 Jan 12, 2019
8.0

Reborn #5

By: Mark Millar, Greg Capullo
Released: Mar 22, 2017

MILLAR-CAPULLO's epic, sell-out sci-fi fantasy story continues. On Bonnie's intrepid trek to find her dead husband, Roy-Boy has finally picked up Harry's scent. Will the couple reunite, or does the message scrawled in blood spell further danger?

+ LikeComment
Melkor rated Reborn #4 Jan 6, 2019
7.0

Reborn #4

By: Mark Millar, Greg Capullo
Released: Jan 25, 2017

MILLAR & CAPULLO's epic sci-fi fantasy story continues. Bonnie and Tom are chained and dragged to Black Wish Mountain, where they are confronted by a vengeful figure from the past. Will they escape to find Harry, or be turned over to Lord Golgotha?

+ LikeComment
Melkor rated Reborn #3 Jan 6, 2019
8.0

Reborn #3

By: Mark Millar, Greg Capullo
Released: Dec 14, 2016

MILLAR & CAPULLO's epic sci-fi fantasy story continues. Bonnie is captured by Dark Lands gangsters during her quest to find her missing husband-gangsters who will deliver her to evil General Frost and his boss, Lord Golgotha. But just as all hope seems lost, Bonnie's warrior powers start kicking in.

+ LikeComment
Melkor rated Reborn #2 Jan 6, 2019
7.5

Reborn #2

By: Mark Millar, Greg Capullo
Released: Nov 16, 2016

MILLAR and CAPULLO's epic sci-fi fantasy story continues. After her death, Bonnie is reborn in Adystria and has a sword thrust into her hand. As the evils within the Dark Lands get stronger, she is Adystria's only hope: their savior.

+ LikeComment
Melkor rated Reborn #1 Jan 6, 2019
7.5

Reborn #1

By: Mark Millar, Greg Capullo
Released: Oct 12, 2016

MARK MILLAR & GREG CAPULLO join forces to create the smash hit sci-fi / fantasy story of the year: REBORN. Where do you go when you die? Not heaven or hell; somewhere else. Somewhere you have to fight to survive. Somewhere the people from the past are waiting for you-the good and the bad.

+ LikeComment
Melkor reviewed Batman #54 Jan 3, 2019
1.0

Terrible, like all the time

Batman #54

By: Tom King, Matt Wagner
Released: Sep 5, 2018

Dick Grayson-the original Robin-gets to spend some quality time fighting crime with his mentor for the first time since Batman popped the question to Catwoman. It's a walk down memory lane as Bruce Wayne helps Dick get over the loss of his high-flying acrobat parents, which in turn led to his crime-fighting career. Guest artist Matt Wagner (Mage, T...

+ LikeComment
Melkor liked this:
daddyT reviewed Batman #54 Sep 5, 2018
1.0

wow. terrible art and no story. a complete and utter waste of pages.

my "baseline" score for a book is 6, if it doesn't do anything to draw me in or push me away. a fluff/filler issue. etc.

starting from the 6, the 1 rating comes because:

-1 because: the art was distractingly bad.
-1 because there was too much stupid humor.
-2 because: an ugh storyl more

Batman #54

By: Tom King, Matt Wagner
Released: Sep 5, 2018

Dick Grayson-the original Robin-gets to spend some quality time fighting crime with his mentor for the first time since Batman popped the question to Catwoman. It's a walk down memory lane as Bruce Wayne helps Dick get over the loss of his high-flying acrobat parents, which in turn led to his crime-fighting career. Guest artist Matt Wagner (Mage, T...

+ LikeComment
Melkor rated Batman #53 Jan 1, 2019
6.5

Batman #53

By: Tom King, Lee Weeks
Released: Aug 15, 2018

"Cold Days" continues! The jury in the Mr. Freeze trial is hopelessly deadlocked because one man won't vote guilty-and that man is Bruce Wayne. Freeze's defense is that Batman used excessive force, making his arrest illegal, and Bruce is the one man who actually knows for sure what went down between Batman and his ice-cold nemesis. And if Bruce is ...

+ LikeComment
Melkor reviewed Batman #52 Jan 1, 2019
6.5

Art is good. But it's so nonsense.

Batman #52

By: Tom King, Lee Weeks
Released: Aug 1, 2018

"Cold Days" continues! The jury in the Mr. Freeze trial is hopelessly deadlocked because one man won't vote guilty-and that man is Bruce Wayne. Freeze's defense is that Batman used excessive force, making his arrest illegal, and Bruce is the one man who actually knows for sure what went down between Batman and his ice-cold nemesis. And if Bruce is ...

+ LikeComment
Melkor reviewed Doomsday Clock #8 Jan 1, 2019
10

AMAZİNG ISSUE!

Doomsday Clock #8

By: Geoff Johns, Gary Frank
Released: Dec 5, 2018

The critical and commercial hit series by Geoff Johns and Gary Frank continues following the shocking revelations of last issue. As the truth behind Dr. Manhattan's actions against the DC Universe are revealed, Ozymandias turns to the only being who can stop him: Superman.

+ LikeComment
Melkor rated Doomsday Clock #7 Oct 21, 2018
9.0

Doomsday Clock #7

By: Geoff Johns, Gary Frank
Released: Sep 26, 2018

The critically acclaimed team of writer Geoff Johns and artist Gary Frank continue the groundbreaking miniseries bringing the world of WATCHMEN to DC. In this chapter, the truth behind Dr. Manhattan's curiosity with the DC Universe is revealed as the planet teeters on the edge of the Super-War.

+ LikeComment
9.0

Sandman Vol. 4: Season Of Mists

By: Neil Gaiman, Mike Dringenberg

NEW YORK TIMES bestselling author Neil Gaiman's transcendent series SANDMAN is often hailed as the definitive Vertigo title and one of the finest achievements in graphic storytelling. Gaiman created an unforgettable tale of the forces that exist beyond life and death by weaving ancient mythology, folklore and fairy tales with his own distinct narra...

+ LikeComment
Melkor rated Sandman #28 Sep 11, 2018
9.0

Sandman #28

By: Neil Gaiman, Mike Dringenberg

The ''Season of Mist'' finale circles back around to what kick-started the acclaimed story in the first place: Morpheus's lost love, whom he vanquished to Hell long ago. As the rest of the players slink back to their roles in the universe, all remain changed--but none more so than Hell's new rulers.

+ LikeComment
Melkor rated Sandman #25 Sep 11, 2018
9.0

Sandman #25

By: Neil Gaiman, Matt Wagner

With Hell now closed for business, the dead are rising all over the world, and this stand-alone issue focuses on one boy's lone fight against a boarding school full of evil spirits. Features art by fan-favorite illustrator Matt Wagner (Grendel)!

+ LikeComment
Melkor rated Sandman #27 Sep 11, 2018
10

Sandman #27

By: Neil Gaiman, Kelley Jones

In this penultimate issue of the ''Season of Mist'' storyline, the decision concerning Hell's new ownership falls to an unlikely heir while Morpheus attends to an unruly guest in his realm.

+ LikeComment
Melkor rated Sandman #26 Sep 11, 2018
10

Sandman #26

By: Neil Gaiman, Kelley Jones

Morpheus meets with the visitors who have come to claim the key to Hell. Some threaten his existence, some offer trade, and others hope to bribe the Dream King with items and info he's been chasing for untold time. But who can bear the responsibility?

+ LikeComment
Melkor rated Sandman #24 Sep 11, 2018
9.0

Sandman #24

By: Neil Gaiman, Kelley Jones

Returning home to his realm of The Dreaming with the Key to Hell in his possession, Morpheus finds himself approached by gods, deities and entities from across the whole of existence, all of whom hope to lay their hands on the former realm of the damned for one purpose or another...

+ LikeComment
Melkor rated Sandman #23 Sep 9, 2018
10

Sandman #23

By: Neil Gaiman, Kelley Jones

The last thing Morpheus expects upon his return to Hell is an open gate and a vacant kingdom. And yet, that's exactly what he finds as Lucifer explains he's decided to give up the kingdom of the damned and hands over the keys to the Dream King. But is this a gift--or a curse?

+ LikeComment
Melkor rated Sandman #22 Sep 9, 2018
8.5

Sandman #22

By: Neil Gaiman, Kelley Jones

Two years ago, Morpheus embarrassed Lucifer in front of the Morningstar's subjects and he swore vengeance on the Dream King. Now, in chapter 1 of the acclaimed "Season of Mists," Morpheus prepares for his return to Hell... on a mission to free a former lover he vanquished there thousands of years ago.

+ LikeComment
Melkor rated Sandman #21 Sep 9, 2018
8.5

Sandman #21

By: Neil Gaiman, Mike Dringenberg

In this prologue issue to the acclaimed "Season of Mists" storyline, Destiny learns of drastic changes on the horizon within existence and calls a meeting of his family, the Endless. But the gathering turns ugly, setting the stage for a tumultuous road ahead for the eternal family.

+ LikeComment
Melkor reviewed Batman #51 Jul 30, 2018
2.0

F@#>! Off King. It was like 12 Angry Man. C'mon be creative you jerk

Batman #51

By: Tom King, Lee Weeks
Released: Jul 18, 2018

The honeymoon's over for Bruce Wayne as Gotham City's most prominent citizen gets selected for jury duty in a chilling court case involving Mr. Freeze! Freeze claims the charges should be dismissed because Batman used excessive force; cue the outrage and media circus. While doing his civic duty, Wayne's forced to take a hard look at the Dark Knight...

+ LikeComment
Melkor rated Doomsday Clock #6 Jul 27, 2018
9.0

Doomsday Clock #6

By: Geoff Johns, Gary Frank
Released: Jul 25, 2018

The critically acclaimed super star team of writer Geoff Johns and artist Gary Frank continue this groundbreaking event as the Mime and the Marionette take center stage in DOOMSDAY CLOCK #6.  

+ LikeComment
Melkor rated Green Lantern Annual #1 Jul 21, 2018
10

Green Lantern Annual #1

By: Geoff Johns, Ethan Van Sciver
Released: Aug 29, 2012

The conclusion of THE REVENGE OF BLACK HAND! Everything changes here! EVERYTHING!

+ LikeComment
Melkor rated Green Lantern #13 Jul 20, 2018
8.0

Green Lantern #13

By: Geoff Johns, Doug Mahnke
Released: Oct 3, 2012

Rise of the Third Army! Earths new Green Lantern battles The Justice League! Meanwhile, The Guardians begin their final step in the destruction of the Lanterns by releasing the first of the Third Army soldiers!

+ LikeComment

Reviews for the Week of...

January

December

More