Amy Ziegfeld's Comic Reviews

Reviewer For: Comicosity Reviews: 80
8.4Avg. Review Rating

5
Dastardly And Muttley #1

Sep 6, 2017

There's potential here. It's an amusing premise and it could go somewhere fun in future issues, but this first issue has almost nothing to recommend it except for fun art and exposition that will set up future, hopefully better issues.

View Issue       View Full Review
6
Gold Key Alliance #1

Apr 6, 2016

It's difficult to recommend this comic. Even if the series subsequently becomes far more engaging, the content in this issue is deeply inessential. The art, while interesting, isn't good enough to make it worth a look on its own, and the writing has nothing new to say, nor does it find an interesting way to say it. There's promise here, and the potential for a fine comics story, but that potential is unrealized in this first issue.

View Issue       View Full Review
6.5
House of Penance #1

Apr 13, 2016

There is a lot of promise here. The art is striking and unique, unlike anything else on the shelves today, and I'm genuinely curious to see where the story goes. The atmosphere is macabre and foreboding and gives a real sense of the weirdness of the Mystery House and its eccentric owner. That said, this issue's problems can't be overlooked. The writing gets lazy in unfortunate ways, and that really hurts the story. Moreover, its treatment of American Indians is difficult to excuse. It's got a lot going for it, but be cognizant of its issues before diving in.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
Hal Jordan And The Green Lantern Corps: Rebirth #1

Jul 13, 2016

All of that said, while there's a lot of good stuff in this comic, it's somewhat limited by the fact that it's a preface and a bridge. It explains previous stories and promises new stories, but it's not an especially interesting story in and of itself. Hal Jordan and the Green Lantern Corps: Rebirth is well-executed, but ultimately inessential.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
The Fall and Rise of Captain Atom #3

Mar 1, 2017

All in all, The Fall and Rise of Captain Atom #3 is a beautiful comic to look at in which not enough happens. Hopefully future issues will pick up the pace, or at least give us a better exploration of Captain Atom as a character.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
Trinity (2016) #12

Aug 16, 2017

Trinity #12 is an entertaining beginning to a new story, but is hampered by the slightness of the premise and the jarring inconsistency with previous issues. The art is a highlight, and almost worth the price of admission on its own.

View Issue       View Full Review
7.5
Hal Jordan And The Green Lantern Corps #1

Jul 27, 2016

While I find the backslide in Sinestro's direction a bit disappointing, I did quite enjoy this book. Hal Jordan and the Green Lantern Corps #1 showed plenty of promise going forward, and a delightful glimmer of optimism at the very end. I'm excited to see what comes next.

View Issue       View Full Review
6
Hal Jordan And The Green Lantern Corps #2

Aug 10, 2016

Hal Jordan and the Green Lantern Corps #2 is a lovely-looking comic without much to say. This book has all the potential in the world to become a great space epic, but for now potential is all it has.

View Issue       View Full Review
8.5
Hal Jordan And The Green Lantern Corps #4

Sep 14, 2016

Hal Jordan And The Green Lantern Corps #4 builds tension as it barrels toward the conclusion of the first arc and it gives some great character moments for both Sinestro and Guy Gardner. This book really feels like it's finding its rhythm.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
Hal Jordan And The Green Lantern Corps #18

Apr 12, 2017

This issue is a promising start for the next story arc, even if it's not necessarily a great issue on its own. It will probably be worth reading eventually, but for now it's all promise and no payoff.

View Issue       View Full Review
6.5
Aquaman (2016) #18

Mar 1, 2017

Aquaman #18 is a good enough comic if you've been reading Aquaman. It wraps up the Warhead plot cul-de-sac in a decently satisfying way and ushers us to the next plot point. It nonetheless feels a bit thematically confused, a problem that has plagued the entire Rebirth Aquaman series.

View Issue       View Full Review
8.5
Aquaman (2016) #26

Jul 19, 2017

Aquaman #26 is a gorgeous book with an intriguing plot that puts Arthur in his ideal millieu, as a rebel outcast fighting a corrupt Atlantean state. It depicts a weird and wonderful Atlantis that entices the reader into wanting to learn more about its mysterious depths.

View Issue       View Full Review
7.5
Midnight of the Soul #1

Jun 9, 2016

Midnight of the Soul has a lot of promise. It's a well-told, if somewhat shopworn, noir tale of violence and masculinity. Hopefully it will hop the tracks and do something unexpected in future issues, but in the meantime it's a creditable entry in the genre.

View Issue       View Full Review
7.5
Wonder Woman (2016) #31

Sep 28, 2017

Wonder Woman #31 is a decent start to what will hopefully be an entertaining arc. It's not especially original and doesn't distinguish itself much thus far, but the execution is solid and there's potential for something interesting here.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Green Lanterns #1

Jun 15, 2016

Green Lanterns #1 is a solid start to the series. It's an invigorating, if slightly rough-around-the-edges, return to form for the title and holds a lot of promise for the future.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
Green Lanterns #6

Sep 14, 2016

In total, Green Lanterns #6 is a perfectly serviceable end to the series' first arc. It establishes a good dynamic between Simon and Jessica going forward, has some nice character moments, and sets up the next arc well.

View Issue       View Full Review
8.5
Green Lanterns #7

Sep 21, 2016

Green Lanterns #7 is a fun character study and a welcome breather amidst all the galactic action. The pace is brisk and the dialogue snappy. It comes highly recommended for fans of Jessica or Simon.

View Issue       View Full Review
6.5
Green Lanterns #8

Oct 5, 2016

This is a fun transitional issue, but it's marred by persistent writing problems and inconsistent art that prevent it from rising to anything more than a trifle.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Green Lanterns #10

Nov 2, 2016

As the second arc of Green Lanterns begins in earnest, this title is really picking up momentum. This is a fantastic issue all-around and a great read for any Green Lantern fan.

View Issue       View Full Review
8.5
Green Lanterns #11

Nov 16, 2016

Green Lanterns is a good book that keeps getting better. Humphries is exploring some interesting themes and the book looks gorgeous.

View Issue       View Full Review
6.5
Green Lanterns #12

Dec 7, 2016

Even when the narrative's spinning in circles, Green Lanterns is always a gorgeous book to look at. This isn't a bad issue, per se, but it felt like too much of a repetition of the last issue.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Green Lanterns #18

Mar 1, 2017

Green Lanterns #18 is a great issue of a great comic. It's a well-told story that serves as an intriguing bridge to the next arc, and the art is some of the best I've seen in a good while.

View Issue       View Full Review
7.5
Green Lanterns #34

Nov 1, 2017

Green Lanterns #34 has its rough patches, but it's a promising start to the next era of the title.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Green Lanterns #38

Jan 3, 2018

Despite some issues with the pacing, this is a fine middle issue for this arc. It features some stunning visuals and excellent characterization to make a story that is highly entertaining, if mildly confusing.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Cursed Comics Cavalcade #1

Oct 10, 2018

All told, Cursed Comics Cavalcade #1 is a gorgeous exhibition of some of DC's top talent telling a variety of fun, spooky stories with their star characters. There's nothing life-changing in here, but it's a solid collection and well worth your time.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Death of Hawkman #2

Nov 2, 2016

Death of Hawkman #2 significantly picks up the pace compared to the first issue and promises an interesting series going forward. While a tad clich, the story is well-told with superb art.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Doomsday Clock #2

Dec 27, 2017

Ultimately, Doomsday Clock is an entertaining comic that sets up some interesting-enough mysteries (albeit Johnsian Why is this like this? mysteries, e.g. Who is the new Rorschach? What's up with the Superman Theory? Why does Ozymandias need Marionette and the Mime?). It's well-made, even if it falls short of its seeming aspirations.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Justice League of America (2017): The Atom Rebirth #1

Jan 4, 2017

Overall, Justice League of America: The Atom Rebirth is a better-than-average Rebirth special that accomplishes its main goal of laying the ground work for the Atom's future adventures in the pages of Justice League of America.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Man-Eaters #1

Sep 26, 2018

Man-Eaters #1 is a fine start. It's an interesting world with a compelling main character. With a first issue as exposition-heavy as this one, though, it remains to be seen how well the elements of the plot will gel once the story gets into full swing. On the whole, though, I'm inclined to grant the benefit of the doubt while waiting, with some excitement, for future issues.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Red Hood and the Outlaws (2016) #2

Sep 14, 2016

Red Hood and the Outlaws #2 is an exciting, if a tad clich, extended fight scene that showcases some of the best sequential art on the market today.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
The Immortal Men #1

Apr 11, 2018

Immortal Men #1 is an interesting start to a series, but it's very much only the beginning. Whether the story ultimately goes to new or exciting places or introduces us to engaging characters remains to be seen.

View Issue       View Full Review
8.5
Supergirl (2016) #1

Sep 7, 2016

The first official issue of the reborn Supergirl series is a great opener. It gives us nice character moments that are worth the price of admission by themselves, while setting up a story with a lot of potential.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Supergirl (2016) #2

Oct 12, 2016

Supergirl #2 is another fine issue in the series. Cat Grant steals the show, but there's a lot of interesting stuff set up between Supergirl and Cyborg Superman, and the art throughout is vibrant and fun.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Supergirl (2016) #8

Apr 12, 2017

Supergirl #8 crosses over with three other storylines while serving as a wholly satisfying story in itself. It's deft and fun and maintains the tone of the rest of the series even as it ties up loose ends from other comics.

View Issue       View Full Review
7.5
Supergirl (2016) #26

Jan 16, 2019

Supergirl #26 is a fun and endearing comic that, aside from my idiosyncratic issues with continuity, is a delight from start to finish.

View Issue       View Full Review
8.5
Adventures of the Super Sons #1

Aug 1, 2018

All told, Adventures of the Super Sons #1 is a delight. It's a fun, well-made comic that entertains even as it's made to hover in an odd limbo with respect to continuity.

View Issue       View Full Review
8.5
Batgirl and the Birds of Prey #3

Oct 12, 2016

Batgirl and the Birds of Prey #3 is great serial story telling and a lovely-looking book, to boot.

View Issue       View Full Review
8.5
Euthanauts #1

Jul 18, 2018

Euthanauts #1 is a promising start to a news series, with interesting mysteries that can, at times, veer into confusion. But it's gorgeous throughout and well worth a read.

View Issue       View Full Review
8.5
Go-Bots (2018) #1

Nov 21, 2018

Go-Bots #1 is a rollicking, exuberrant throw-back, a perfect simulation of a child's tale as put together by a master craftsman. It's a unique product of a single auteur and worth a look for that alone, but also entertains and enthralls on its own merits.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Hawkman (2018) #4

Sep 12, 2018

Hawkman #4 is a gorgeous book, in keeping with the formula established by the previous three issues, and is a fun, brisk read that serves as a new reader's tour through Hawkman's history.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Hawkman (2018) #8

Jan 16, 2019

Hawkman #8 is a joy to read, and a sterling example of how continuity can be integrated into a superhero comic without making it intimidating and repellan to new readers. The art is top-notch, and the ongoing story captivating.

View Issue       View Full Review
8.5
Martian Manhunter (2018) #1

Dec 5, 2018

Martian Manhunter #1 is a promising start. It presents a geuinely weird and alien Mars and an interesting mystery on Earth. With a little more development, this feels like a story that could make J'onn J'onnz a breakout character.

View Issue       View Full Review
8.5
Mera: Queen of Atlantis #3

Apr 25, 2018

Mera: Queen of Atlantis #3 puts an interesting twist on its story. It's well drawn and compels the reader to want to find out where the story will go next as the series unfolds.

View Issue       View Full Review
8.5
Nightwing (2016) #21

May 17, 2017

Nightwing #21 is a great one-off story that is both a satisfying read by itself and does a great job re-establishing a forgotten friendship.

View Issue       View Full Review
8.5
Suicide Squad (2016) #10

Jan 25, 2017

Suicide Squad #10 is a well-told done-in-one story spinning out of the denouement of Justice League vs. Suicide Squad. It builds on the event by telling a character-focused story that deepens our understanding of Amanda Waller.

View Issue       View Full Review
8.5
The Brave and the Bold: Batman and Wonder Woman #2

Mar 21, 2018

Brave and the Bold #2 is a gorgeous book, and the story it tells is enthralling, but it's somewhat held back by feeling like it's just a small slice of a singular, larger story and doesn't quite satisfy as a storytelling unit on its own.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Cover (2018) #1

Sep 5, 2018

Cover #1 is, nonetheless, a singular experience, unlike anything else on the stands now, and well worth the effort to seek out. It has a fascinatingly introspective quality as it weaves its themes through multiple avenues and does breathtaking things with its diverse art styles and striking use of color.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
DC / Hanna-Barbera: Green Lantern/Huckleberry Hound #1

Oct 31, 2018

Green Lantern/Huckleberry Hound Special #1 is another excellent, and unexpected, cartoon crossover from DC, a powerful lesson on history and power in a brightly-colored, entertaining package.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
DC Nation (2018) #0

May 2, 2018

In all, DC Nation #0 is a gorgeous book, showcasing three highly distinct but equally sumptuous art styles. Its three stories each preview what's to come in the next few months from DC Comics and, to greater or lesser degrees, entice the reader to learn more.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Dark Nights: Metal #1

Aug 16, 2017

DC Metal is an excellent start to what promises to be a fun event. It's unpretentious in its earnest love for the comic book universe it gleefully expands upon and skillfully weaves together old concepts and new ideas into a seamless, exciting whole.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Electric Warriors #1

Nov 14, 2018

Electric Warriors #1 is unlike anything else out there. It's weird and experimental and beautiful and engaging. If the story line feels a bit familiar, the execution of it is unique and fulfilling. Well worth the effort to seek out.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Justice League (2016) #34

Dec 6, 2017

Justice League #34 is a great Justice League comic, in general. It's also a great jumping-on point if you haven't been keeping up on Justice League. Priest and Woods tell a story that's wholly satisfying on its own, while also promising an interesting larger story to come.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Justice League (2016) #41

Mar 21, 2018

Justice League #41 continues Priests excellent run on the title, bringing in big themes and handling them skillfully. It's well worth a read.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Justice League vs. Suicide Squad #3

Jan 4, 2017

Justice League vs. Suicide Squad #3 is a great continuation of the larger event, progressing the story, and giving some great character moments while introducing some new twists.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Kamandi Challenge #1

Jan 25, 2017

This issue was a lot of fun and I really enjoyed it. It's entirely unlike anything else on the stands right now, and for that it should be commended. Moreover, you can be guaranteed that every single issue of this comic will give you a lot of action and storytelling for your purchase. It's a quirky book, the seams are definitely exposed, and whether it will make a satisfying story in total is yet to be seen, but for now this issue is a great time.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Mystik U #1

Nov 29, 2017

Mystik U #1 is a great first-issue for a charming, young adult-oriented miniseries that also has deep ties to the history of the DC Universe, going back to Action Comics #1. It lays the groundwork for the rest of the series while serving as a fulfilling self-contained story in its own right. Highly recommended.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Mystik U #2

Jan 31, 2018

Mystik U #2 is a great coming-of-age story for readers of all ages, with an authentic voice that never feels condescending. The art complements and enhances that story, and makes this book something truly special.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
New Superman #16

Oct 11, 2017

New Super-Man remains one of the most interesting superhero comics being published today, a fascinating take on heroism the likes of which we haven't really seen before. Every issue is a delight, and this one is no different.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Red Hood and the Outlaws: Rebirth #1

Jul 27, 2016

Red Hood and the Outlaws: Rebirth has been the biggest surprise of the relaunch for me. I was genuinely not expecting to enjoy it as much as I did, and, for the first time in ages, I'm excited about Jason Todd. It's entirely possible that this book will lose me in the future, but for now, I am on board. Red Hood and the Outlaws: Rebirth is a genuinely great comic.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Satellite Falling #1

May 12, 2016

First issues are difficult. They not only have to set up the story, and the characters, and the world, they also have to act as a sales pitch for the series as a whole. Satellite Falling #1 does an admirable job on all accounts. The story is intriguing, the characters nuanced, the world engrossing, and it offers the promise of a fantastic science fiction tale to come. Satellite Falling #1 is both an auspicious start and a fantastic read in and of itself.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Sixpack & Dogwelder: Hard-Travelin' Heroz #1

Aug 24, 2016

Six Pack And Dog Welder feels like the comic that the slacker kids in high school would make if they were supremely witty and had access to an incredible artist and colorist. It takes what should be broad, one-note characters and finds new angles and humor while also stealthily imbuing them humanity and poignancy. This is a book that will make you care about a man who welds dogs to peoples' faces.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
The Man of Steel (2018) #2

Jun 6, 2018

Man of Steel #2 is well-illustrated and action-packed, yet still finds time for down-to-Earth character moments that build the universe and instill confidence that the Man of Tomorrow is in good hands.

View Issue       View Full Review
9.5
Batman (2016) #6

Sep 7, 2016

In the meantime, Batman #6 was one of the most powerful comic books I've read this year. It's a poignant capstone on the I Am Gotham storyline, lays the groundwork for future stories, and serves as an emotional standalone tale of grief.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Batman (2016) #7

Sep 21, 2016

Batman #7 is a great start to what looks to be a fun crossover. The creative team did their homework and have produced a love letter to monster media that manages to stay true to its Bat roots.

View Issue       View Full Review
10
Batman (2016) #11

Nov 16, 2016

King and Janin deliver an amazing issue of Batman, and a fantastic Suicide Squad story, to boot. King delivers long-form storytelling while still infusing every individual issue with meaning. This is a fantastic comic.

View Issue       View Full Review
9.5
Batman (2016) #19

Mar 15, 2017

Batman #19 is a great example of the work that King and his art teams have done with Batman post-Rebirth. It takes familiar themes and concepts and approaches them in novel ways, and never misses an opportunity to elevate the subject matter and give the reader something to think about.

View Issue       View Full Review
10
Batman (2016) #24

Jun 7, 2017

Batman #24 is the perfect capstone on the first year of King's already amazing Rebirth run on Batman. It has an emotional honesty rarely seen in superhero comics and manages a twist ending that is both surprising and the most natural thing in the world.

View Issue       View Full Review
8.5
Batman (2016) #33

Oct 18, 2017

Batman #33 is a fine start to the next arc of Batman and ends on a revelation that leaves the reader excited to see what happens next. It's great serial storytelling, providing character moments while also being a compelling read.

View Issue       View Full Review
9.5
Batgirl (2016) #5

Nov 23, 2016

Batgirl #5 is a fitting end to an auspicious first arc.

View Issue       View Full Review
9.5
Catwoman (2018) #1

Jul 4, 2018

Catwoman #1 is a masterpiece first issue, stunning to look at and engaging to read. It's a great start to a promising new series.

View Issue       View Full Review
9.5
Dark Days: The Casting #1

Jul 12, 2017

Dark Days: The Casting is a bombastic, effervescent introduction to the Metal event. It is deeply ensconced in continuity but, rather than presenting these connections as a barrier to be surmounted, it offers them as an opportunity to explore and come to love this universe as much as the creators do. It entices and offers the promise of exciting stories to come.

View Issue       View Full Review
9.5
Die #1

Dec 5, 2018

Die #1 is a practically perfect first issue to one of the most promising new series to launch this year.

View Issue       View Full Review
9.5
Justice League: No Justice #1

May 9, 2018

Justice League: No Justice #1 is the best there is at what it does, delivering epic, large-scale widescreen super-hero action in beautiful style. How much you enjoy it is entirely dependent on whether there's at least part of you that still thinks that what it does can be very nice.

View Issue       View Full Review
9.5
Plastic Man (2018) #1

Jun 13, 2018

Plastic Man #1 does an excellent job not only of starting out a new miniseries but also re-establishing Plastic Man in the post-Rebirth DC Universe. It perfectly nails Eel O'Brian's voice and is a joy to read.

View Issue       View Full Review
9.5
Shade, the Changing Girl #4

Jan 4, 2017

Shade, the Changing Girl continues to impress with its fourth issue. The writing is poetic, the art evocative, and to top it off the second feature is fantastic.

View Issue       View Full Review
9.5
The Seeds #1

Aug 1, 2018

The Seeds #1 is a gripping start to what promises to be an excellent science fiction miniseries. The striking art and convincing characters pull you along and draw you in to a world that's hauntingly, melancholically familiar.

View Issue       View Full Review
9.5
Omega Men #11

May 1, 2016

It's a shame this comic is ending with the next issue; I would have loved to see what other stories King and Bagenda could tell with this cast of characters. With all of the Omega Men converging on the Citadel's Viceroy, it's clear there is to be no pat solution to the war in Vega. But when the Omega Men inevitably come into conflict with each other, who will win out? I don't think I've ever had less idea of what's going to happen in the final issue of a series, and I can't wait to find out.

View Issue       View Full Review
10
Omega Men #12

May 28, 2016

I hesitate to call Omega Men a perfect comic, if only because I hate to think of art as something that is perfectable. With that said, Omega Men is as close to a flawless comic as I have read since I first began reading comics, and this last issue brings the series to, if not necessarily a satisfying conclusion, then one that is wholely in keeping with everything that came before it.

View Issue       View Full Review
10
DC / Looney Tunes: Batman/Elmer Fudd #1

Jun 28, 2017

Batman/Fudd is a wildly imaginative cross-over and one of the best hard-boiled detective stories in years. It comes strongly recommended.

View Issue       View Full Review
10
Transformers: More Than Meets The Eye - Revolution #1

Dec 8, 2016

Transformers: More Than Meets the Eye: Revolution #1 is a fantastic, well-plotted, hilarious send-up of the type of corporate event that spawned it, and simultaneously serves as a kind of defense of the genre. Highly recommended, whether you've been reading Revolution or not.

View Issue       View Full Review

Reviews for the Week of...

November

October

More