This Week's Reviews
Top Comics
Trades
Publishers
Marvel
DC
Image
Dark Horse
IDW
Boom!
Dynamite
Mad Cave
See Full List
Sign In
Louise Simonson Comic Reviews
7.3
Critic Reviews
218
8.0
User Reviews
650
+ Creator Watch List
Current Series:
1
Total Series:
43
Issues:
333
View By:
Series
Series Rating
Issue Rating
Release Date
Critic
User
Current Comic Book Series
N/A
N/A
Superman: The Wedding Album – 30th Anniversary Special #1
All Comic Book Series
N/A
N/A
Action Comics #701
8.9
8.7
Action Comics #1000
N/A
8.2
Adventures of Superman (1987)
5 issues
show
N/A
N/A
Adventures of Superman Annual #3
August 14, 1991
N/A
8.2
Adventures of Superman #500
May 26, 1993
N/A
N/A
Adventures of Superman #568
April 28, 1999
N/A
N/A
Adventures of Superman #569
May 26, 1999
N/A
N/A
Adventures of Superman #571
August 4, 1999
N/A
7.2
Amazing Spider-Man Annual #19
8.0
7.5
Cartoon Network Super Secret Crisis War
5 issues
show
7.6
7.5
Cartoon Network Super Secret Crisis War #1
June 25, 2014
8.5
7.0
Cartoon Network Super Secret Crisis War #2
July 30, 2014
7.7
7.0
Cartoon Network Super Secret Crisis War #3
August 27, 2014
8.0
N/A
Cartoon Network Super Secret Crisis War #4
September 24, 2014
8.0
8.5
Cartoon Network Super Secret Crisis War #5
October 29, 2014
9.0
8.0
Catwoman: Soulstealer OGN
6.0
N/A
Chaos War: X-Men
2 issues
show
5.0
N/A
Chaos War: X-Men #1
December 29, 2010
7.0
N/A
Chaos War: X-Men #2
January 26, 2011
5.2
6.5
Convergence: Superman: Man of Steel
2 issues
show
6.5
7.0
Convergence: Superman: Man of Steel #1
April 15, 2015
4.0
6.0
Convergence: Superman: Man of Steel #2
May 13, 2015
N/A
7.7
Daredevil #238
N/A
N/A
Detective Comics
4 issues
show
N/A
N/A
Detective Comics Annual #4
August 21, 1991
N/A
N/A
Detective Comics #635
July 3, 1991
N/A
N/A
Detective Comics #636
July 24, 1991
N/A
N/A
Detective Comics #637
August 28, 1991
8.1
8.1
Faith #5
N/A
N/A
Galactus the Devourer (1999)
6 issues
show
N/A
N/A
Galactus the Devourer #1
July 21, 1999
N/A
N/A
Galactus the Devourer #2
August 18, 1999
N/A
N/A
Galactus the Devourer #3
September 15, 1999
N/A
N/A
Galactus the Devourer #4
October 20, 1999
N/A
N/A
Galactus the Devourer #5
November 24, 1999
N/A
N/A
Galactus the Devourer #6
December 15, 1999
N/A
7.2
Havok and Wolverine: Meltdown (1988)
4 issues
show
N/A
7.0
Havok and Wolverine: Meltdown #1
November 8, 1988
N/A
7.5
Havok and Wolverine: Meltdown #2
December 13, 1988
N/A
N/A
Havok and Wolverine: Meltdown #3
January 10, 1989
N/A
N/A
Havok and Wolverine: Meltdown #4
June 13, 1989
8.0
8.2
Jean Grey (2023)
4 issues
show
8.3
8.5
Jean Grey #1
August 23, 2023
8.1
8.3
Jean Grey #2
September 27, 2023
7.4
7.8
Jean Grey #3
October 25, 2023
8.2
8.1
Jean Grey #4
November 15, 2023
N/A
N/A
Legion of Super-Heroes #94
7.0
6.8
Marvel Adventures: Super Heroes (2008)
2 issues
show
8.0
8.5
Marvel Adventures: Super Heroes #7
January 14, 2009
6.0
5.0
Marvel Adventures: Super Heroes #11
May 13, 2009
N/A
N/A
Marvel Super Special #38
N/A
7.4
Marvel Team-Up (1972)
2 issues
show
N/A
7.0
Marvel Team-Up #149
N/A
7.8
Marvel Team-Up #150
9.9
8.6
New Mutants (1983)
44 issues
show
N/A
8.0
New Mutants Annual #4
N/A
N/A
New Mutants Annual #5
N/A
8.8
New Mutants Annual #6
N/A
8.5
New Mutants #55
September 9, 1987
9.8
8.8
New Mutants #56
October 28, 1987
N/A
8.0
New Mutants #57
November 25, 1987
N/A
7.5
New Mutants #58
December 30, 1987
N/A
7.8
New Mutants #59
January 27, 1988
N/A
8.6
New Mutants #60
March 2, 1988
N/A
8.3
New Mutants #61
March 30, 1988
N/A
8.0
New Mutants #62
N/A
8.8
New Mutants #63
10
8.8
New Mutants #64
N/A
8.5
New Mutants #65
N/A
8.5
New Mutants #66
N/A
8.2
New Mutants #67
N/A
7.8
New Mutants #68
N/A
8.0
New Mutants #69
N/A
8.2
New Mutants #70
N/A
8.2
New Mutants #71
January 4, 1989
N/A
8.3
New Mutants #72
February 8, 1989
N/A
8.5
New Mutants #73
March 8, 1989
N/A
9.5
New Mutants #74
N/A
8.2
New Mutants #75
N/A
9.5
New Mutants #76
N/A
9.0
New Mutants #77
N/A
9.5
New Mutants #78
N/A
9.5
New Mutants #79
N/A
10
New Mutants #80
N/A
9.5
New Mutants #82
N/A
9.5
New Mutants #83
N/A
9.0
New Mutants #84
N/A
10
New Mutants #85
N/A
9.0
New Mutants #86
February 7, 1990
N/A
7.2
New Mutants #87
March 7, 1990
N/A
9.5
New Mutants #88
April 11, 1990
N/A
9.0
New Mutants #89
May 9, 1990
N/A
8.0
New Mutants #90
June 6, 1990
N/A
9.0
New Mutants #91
July 11, 1990
N/A
8.5
New Mutants #93
September 5, 1990
N/A
7.5
New Mutants #94
October 10, 1990
N/A
8.3
New Mutants #95
October 31, 1990
N/A
8.3
New Mutants #96
November 28, 1990
N/A
8.3
New Mutants #97
December 26, 1990
N/A
N/A
New Teen Titans (1984)
5 issues
show
N/A
N/A
New Teen Titans Annual #10
April 20, 1994
N/A
N/A
New Teen Titans #87
May 6, 1992
N/A
N/A
New Teen Titans #94
December 30, 1992
N/A
N/A
New Teen Titans #95
January 13, 1993
N/A
N/A
New Teen Titans #96
February 10, 1993
N/A
7.3
Power Pack (1984)
36 issues
show
N/A
8.3
Power Pack #1
May 1, 1984
N/A
8.5
Power Pack #2
May 29, 1984
N/A
8.3
Power Pack #3
July 3, 1984
N/A
8.5
Power Pack #4
N/A
7.5
Power Pack #5
N/A
8.0
Power Pack #6
N/A
7.0
Power Pack #7
N/A
7.5
Power Pack #8
N/A
7.0
Power Pack #10
N/A
7.0
Power Pack #11
March 5, 1985
N/A
7.0
Power Pack #12
April 2, 1985
N/A
6.5
Power Pack #13
N/A
7.0
Power Pack #14
N/A
7.5
Power Pack #15
N/A
7.0
Power Pack #16
N/A
7.5
Power Pack #17
N/A
6.8
Power Pack #18
N/A
7.0
Power Pack #19
N/A
7.5
Power Pack #20
N/A
7.5
Power Pack #22
N/A
7.5
Power Pack #23
N/A
7.5
Power Pack #24
N/A
7.5
Power Pack #25
N/A
7.5
Power Pack #26
N/A
7.0
Power Pack #27
N/A
7.0
Power Pack #28
N/A
7.0
Power Pack #29
N/A
6.5
Power Pack #30
N/A
7.0
Power Pack #31
N/A
7.0
Power Pack #32
N/A
7.0
Power Pack #33
N/A
7.0
Power Pack #35
N/A
7.0
Power Pack #37
N/A
7.0
Power Pack #39
N/A
N/A
Power Pack #40
N/A
7.0
Power Pack #41
7.6
7.2
Power Pack: Grow Up #1
5.8
6.0
Power Pack: Into the Storm (2024)
5 issues
show
6.8
7.2
Power Pack: Into the Storm #1
January 24, 2024
6.0
5.0
Power Pack: Into the Storm #2
February 28, 2024
4.0
6.5
Power Pack: Into the Storm #3
March 13, 2024
6.0
5.0
Power Pack: Into the Storm #4
April 3, 2024
6.0
6.0
Power Pack: Into the Storm #5
May 1, 2024
N/A
N/A
Sensational She-Hulk (1989)
2 issues
show
N/A
N/A
Sensational She-Hulk #29
May 7, 1991
N/A
N/A
Sensational She-Hulk #30
June 4, 1991
8.6
8.1
Spider-Man / Superman #1
N/A
N/A
Steel (1994)
27 issues
show
N/A
N/A
Steel #0
August 3, 1994
N/A
N/A
Steel #1
January 26, 1994
N/A
N/A
Steel #2
February 23, 1994
N/A
N/A
Steel #3
March 30, 1994
N/A
N/A
Steel #4
April 27, 1994
N/A
N/A
Steel #5
June 1, 1994
N/A
N/A
Steel #6
June 29, 1994
N/A
N/A
Steel #7
August 31, 1994
N/A
N/A
Steel #8
August 3, 1994
N/A
N/A
Steel #9
October 26, 1994
N/A
N/A
Steel #10
November 30, 1994
N/A
N/A
Steel #11
December 28, 1994
N/A
N/A
Steel #12
February 1, 1995
N/A
N/A
Steel #13
March 1, 1995
N/A
N/A
Steel #14
March 29, 1995
N/A
N/A
Steel #15
April 26, 1995
N/A
N/A
Steel #16
May 31, 1995
N/A
N/A
Steel #21
November 1, 1995
N/A
N/A
Steel #22
November 29, 1995
N/A
N/A
Steel #23
December 27, 1995
N/A
N/A
Steel #24
January 31, 1996
N/A
N/A
Steel #25
February 28, 1996
N/A
N/A
Steel #26
May 1, 1996
N/A
N/A
Steel #27
May 29, 1996
N/A
N/A
Steel #29
July 31, 1996
N/A
N/A
Steel #30
August 28, 1996
N/A
N/A
Steel #31
September 25, 1996
6.8
N/A
Super Secret Crisis War: Johnny Bravo #1
6.9
N/A
Super Secret Crisis War: The Grim Adventures of Billy and Mandy #1
8.0
N/A
Super-Secret Crisis War: Cow and Chicken One-Shot #1
8.6
N/A
Super-Secret Crisis War: Fosters Home for Imaginary Friends #1
N/A
7.6
Superman: The Man of Steel (1991)
83 issues
show
N/A
6.5
Superman: The Man of Steel #0
August 17, 1994
N/A
9.0
Superman: The Man of Steel #1
May 15, 1991
N/A
N/A
Superman: The Man of Steel #2
June 12, 1991
N/A
N/A
Superman: The Man of Steel #3
July 17, 1991
N/A
N/A
Superman: The Man of Steel #4
August 14, 1991
N/A
N/A
Superman: The Man of Steel #5
September 11, 1991
N/A
N/A
Superman: The Man of Steel #6
October 16, 1991
N/A
N/A
Superman: The Man of Steel #7
December 25, 1991
N/A
N/A
Superman: The Man of Steel #8
January 29, 1992
N/A
8.8
Superman: The Man of Steel #9
January 15, 1992
N/A
7.5
Superman: The Man of Steel #10
February 5, 1992
N/A
9.0
Superman: The Man of Steel #11
April 29, 1992
N/A
8.5
Superman: The Man of Steel #12
May 27, 1992
N/A
N/A
Superman: The Man of Steel #13
May 13, 1992
N/A
N/A
Superman: The Man of Steel #14
June 17, 1992
N/A
N/A
Superman: The Man of Steel #15
July 15, 1992
N/A
N/A
Superman: The Man of Steel #16
N/A
7.0
Superman: The Man of Steel #17
October 28, 1992
N/A
6.4
Superman: The Man of Steel #18
November 25, 1992
N/A
7.2
Superman: The Man of Steel #19
N/A
8.6
Superman: The Man of Steel #20
N/A
8.2
Superman: The Man of Steel #21
N/A
6.6
Superman: The Man of Steel #22
N/A
7.9
Superman: The Man of Steel #23
N/A
7.6
Superman: The Man of Steel #24
N/A
7.3
Superman: The Man of Steel #25
N/A
6.5
Superman: The Man of Steel #26
N/A
7.0
Superman: The Man of Steel #27
N/A
7.5
Superman: The Man of Steel #28
N/A
7.5
Superman: The Man of Steel #29
N/A
N/A
Superman: The Man of Steel #30
N/A
N/A
Superman: The Man of Steel #31
N/A
8.2
Superman: The Man of Steel #32
N/A
N/A
Superman: The Man of Steel #33
N/A
N/A
Superman: The Man of Steel #34
N/A
N/A
Superman: The Man of Steel #35
N/A
N/A
Superman: The Man of Steel #36
N/A
N/A
Superman: The Man of Steel #37
July 13, 1994
N/A
6.0
Superman: The Man of Steel #38
N/A
N/A
Superman: The Man of Steel #39
October 5, 1994
N/A
N/A
Superman: The Man of Steel #40
November 9, 1994
N/A
N/A
Superman: The Man of Steel #41
December 7, 1994
N/A
N/A
Superman: The Man of Steel #42
January 11, 1995
N/A
N/A
Superman: The Man of Steel #43
February 8, 1995
N/A
N/A
Superman: The Man of Steel #44
May 10, 1995
N/A
N/A
Superman: The Man of Steel #45
April 5, 1995
N/A
N/A
Superman: The Man of Steel #46
May 3, 1995
N/A
N/A
Superman: The Man of Steel #47
June 7, 1995
N/A
N/A
Superman: The Man of Steel #48
July 5, 1995
N/A
N/A
Superman: The Man of Steel #49
August 2, 1995
N/A
N/A
Superman: The Man of Steel #50
September 6, 1995
N/A
N/A
Superman: The Man of Steel #51
October 4, 1995
N/A
N/A
Superman: The Man of Steel #52
November 8, 1995
N/A
N/A
Superman: The Man of Steel #53
December 20, 1995
N/A
N/A
Superman: The Man of Steel #54
January 17, 1996
N/A
N/A
Superman: The Man of Steel #55
February 21, 1996
N/A
8.0
Superman: The Man of Steel #56
March 27, 1996
N/A
N/A
Superman: The Man of Steel #59
June 26, 1996
N/A
N/A
Superman: The Man of Steel #60
July 24, 1996
N/A
N/A
Superman: The Man of Steel #61
August 28, 1996
N/A
N/A
Superman: The Man of Steel #62
September 25, 1996
N/A
7.5
Superman: The Man of Steel #63
October 30, 1996
N/A
N/A
Superman: The Man of Steel #64
November 27, 1996
N/A
N/A
Superman: The Man of Steel #65
January 1, 1997
N/A
7.5
Superman: The Man of Steel #66
February 5, 1997
N/A
N/A
Superman: The Man of Steel #67
March 5, 1997
N/A
N/A
Superman: The Man of Steel #68
April 9, 1997
N/A
N/A
Superman: The Man of Steel #69
May 7, 1997
N/A
N/A
Superman: The Man of Steel #70
June 4, 1997
N/A
N/A
Superman: The Man of Steel #71
July 2, 1997
N/A
N/A
Superman: The Man of Steel #72
August 6, 1997
N/A
N/A
Superman: The Man of Steel #73
September 3, 1997
N/A
N/A
Superman: The Man of Steel #74
October 8, 1997
N/A
7.0
Superman: The Man of Steel #75
November 5, 1997
N/A
N/A
Superman: The Man of Steel #76
December 3, 1997
N/A
N/A
Superman: The Man of Steel #77
January 21, 1998
N/A
N/A
Superman: The Man of Steel #78
February 18, 1998
N/A
N/A
Superman: The Man of Steel #79
March 18, 1998
N/A
N/A
Superman: The Man of Steel #80
April 22, 1998
N/A
8.0
Superman: The Man of Steel #81
May 27, 1998
N/A
N/A
Superman: The Man of Steel #82
June 24, 1998
N/A
N/A
Superman: The Man of Steel #83
July 22, 1998
N/A
N/A
Superman: The Man of Steel #86
December 16, 1998
N/A
N/A
Superman: The Man of Tomorrow (1995)
4 issues
show
N/A
N/A
Superman: The Man of Tomorrow #11
August 12, 1998
N/A
N/A
Superman: The Man of Tomorrow #12
November 18, 1998
N/A
N/A
Superman: The Man of Tomorrow #13
February 24, 1999
N/A
N/A
Superman: The Man of Tomorrow #14
June 9, 1999
N/A
N/A
Superman: The Wedding Album – 30th Anniversary Special #1
9.4
8.7
The Death of Superman 30th Anniversary Special #1
N/A
7.7
Web of Spider-Man (1985)
3 issues
show
N/A
8.3
Web of Spider-Man #1
N/A
7.7
Web of Spider-Man #2
N/A
7.0
Web of Spider-Man #3
7.9
6.0
Wonder Woman: 1984 #1
8.4
6.0
Wonder Woman: Agent of Peace #8
8.2
10
Wonder Woman: Warbringer OGN
N/A
8.6
X-Factor (1986)
58 issues
show
N/A
8.5
X-Factor Annual #3
N/A
8.5
X-Factor Annual #5
May 15, 1990
N/A
8.2
X-Factor #6
N/A
8.2
X-Factor #7
N/A
8.5
X-Factor #8
N/A
8.0
X-Factor #9
N/A
8.2
X-Factor #10
November 12, 1986
N/A
8.0
X-Factor #11
December 10, 1986
N/A
8.0
X-Factor #12
N/A
9.0
X-Factor #13
N/A
8.5
X-Factor #14
N/A
8.2
X-Factor #15
N/A
8.2
X-Factor #16
N/A
8.2
X-Factor #17
N/A
8.8
X-Factor #18
June 24, 1987
N/A
8.5
X-Factor #19
July 29, 1987
N/A
8.0
X-Factor #20
August 26, 1987
N/A
8.8
X-Factor #21
September 30, 1987
N/A
8.8
X-Factor #22
October 28, 1987
N/A
9.0
X-Factor #23
November 25, 1987
N/A
8.2
X-Factor #24
December 30, 1987
N/A
7.8
X-Factor #25
January 27, 1988
N/A
7.8
X-Factor #26
February 24, 1988
N/A
8.8
X-Factor #27
N/A
8.2
X-Factor #28
N/A
8.0
X-Factor #29
N/A
8.5
X-Factor #30
N/A
8.2
X-Factor #31
N/A
8.5
X-Factor #32
N/A
8.2
X-Factor #33
October 12, 1988
N/A
8.5
X-Factor #34
November 9, 1988
N/A
8.2
X-Factor #35
December 7, 1988
N/A
7.9
X-Factor #36
January 11, 1989
N/A
8.2
X-Factor #37
February 8, 1989
N/A
8.2
X-Factor #38
March 8, 1989
N/A
8.5
X-Factor #39
April 5, 1989
N/A
9.0
X-Factor #41
N/A
9.0
X-Factor #42
N/A
9.5
X-Factor #43
N/A
9.5
X-Factor #44
N/A
9.0
X-Factor #45
N/A
9.0
X-Factor #46
N/A
9.0
X-Factor #48
N/A
9.0
X-Factor #49
N/A
9.5
X-Factor #50
N/A
8.5
X-Factor #51
N/A
9.0
X-Factor #52
N/A
9.0
X-Factor #53
N/A
9.5
X-Factor #54
N/A
9.0
X-Factor #56
N/A
9.0
X-Factor #57
N/A
8.5
X-Factor #58
N/A
9.0
X-Factor #59
N/A
8.3
X-Factor #60
October 31, 1990
N/A
8.7
X-Factor #61
November 28, 1990
N/A
8.7
X-Factor #62
December 26, 1990
N/A
8.5
X-Factor #63
N/A
8.5
X-Factor #64
5.7
N/A
X-Factor Forever
3 issues
show
8.0
N/A
X-Factor Forever #1
March 17, 2010
5.0
N/A
X-Factor Forever #2
April 14, 2010
4.0
N/A
X-Factor Forever #3
May 12, 2010
6.3
6.9
X-Men: Gold #1
6.5
6.8
X-Men: Legends (2021)
3 issues
show
7.1
7.4
X-Men: Legends #3
April 28, 2021
7.1
6.9
X-Men: Legends #4
June 23, 2021
5.3
6.0
X-Men: Legends #11
February 2, 2022
N/A
7.0
X-Terminators (1988)
4 issues
show
N/A
7.0
X-Terminators #1
June 21, 1988
N/A
7.0
X-Terminators #2
July 19, 1988
N/A
N/A
X-Terminators #3
August 16, 1988
N/A
N/A
X-Terminators #4
September 27, 1988
Reviews for the Week of...
October
28
21
14
7
September
30
2025 In Review:
Top Comic Series
Top Comic Issues
Top New Series
