Very well done story by King and even better art by Bilquis Evely and awesome colors by Matheus Lopes. It kept me invested the whole time and I will recommend this one to anyone I meet. The only thing I didn't like was the switcheroo at the end. It doesn't really work because life in prison for a genocidal maniac that savagely killed 10s of thousands and took part in the genocide of millions deserves death no less. more

Very much an enjoyable ride and I do like the narration boxes from king. The art is what makes this book hit all the right angles. No artists could recrate this world in this fashion. Hats off to Evely and Lopes!

Very good comic-booking!

Well done from Tom King and Bilquis Evely. I never thought I would enjoy a fantasy/sci-fi/drama Supergirl comic this much. This has many real life influences and is illustrated hauntingly and beautifully by Belquis Evely and Matheus Lopes.

Fantastic issue that hits hard and out of nowhere from King. So many life lessons thrown together in one issue. That last page showing Ruthye broken and lost in a massive world full of evil and injustice not comprehending how seemingly normal people commit genocide and get away with it. Bilquis Evely's stunning art makes this book shine and I can't stop staring at all the delirious colors from Matheus Lopes. more

I liked it and it kept my interest. Bilquis Evely is the star here with exquesite colors from Lopes.

Nice start with intriguing parts. Not sure why Supergirl is out getting trashed and want to see the background to justify that. The alien story girl and fantasy elements are great. Bilquis Evely is magnificent as an artist. Just beautiful especially the colors from Matheus Lopes. Let's see what King does here.

It works but barely and so many questions that I ultimately don't care enough to think about. Read it and forget it as soon as you close the book. At this point I'm consuming recycled material that looks amazing thanks to McGuiness on art who is outstanding!! Wells man what in the world was this?? 2 years of this is insane. I liked almost everything he wrote for Marvel since the late 2000s but this was a big miss. more

while I do like how spidey breaks free of the sins on who spidey is, the lead up and execution could have been better. It's not bad, but it feels hollow and empty.

The two-page spread is amazing. McGuinness once again showcases how good he is as an artist.

This arc, like this book has definitely been uneven. Not sure if this ending is deserved, but I'm satisfied with it. Interested to see what happens next.

As far as conclusions go for Zeb Wells, this is one of his better ones. The bouncing back and forth of the Goblin between Norman and Peter, Peter and Norman got really annoying and we could have seen an inner struggle for Peter longer than a single splash page but what we got was decent. Exploring more of those pivotal moments in Peter and Spider-Man's life being slowly poisoned or stripped away by the Goblin would have been more interesting and now it's just... gone. Poof. We're going to get more of a resolution soon I'm sure. Wells loves his epilogues instead of just giving us a fulfilling conclusion but with what we got here I don't hate any of it. more

It is just bad and stale and recycled over and over. Nothing new or exciting in this book. The art from Nauck and McGuiness is the only thing that delivered.

spider-man getting corrupted by sins 3 times in this run in 20 issues is getting pretty old and stale.

I'm more confused about this story than disappointed. Nothing here is bad, but it feels too overcrowded to be concluded in the next issue. There are so many characters here and this story tries to conclude so many plot threads that it hurts the pacing. I have more questions than anything.

The cliffhanger is not as exciting as it tries to be. This is the second time ASM issue ends with Peter getting sins and the third time (second time in this story) where ASM issue ends with Peter going Goblin. more

Art is great and holds the book up a lot for me. An ending we’ve already had a few issues ago? A questionable choice, which seems to be a theme of this entire run.

This is not great but passable as an ASM story but the art is phenomenal, I just wish the story matched it.

After the strong start, I wasn't ready for the tone to switch this much, or for anything really. It's a bit disappointing, but let's see where it goes next.

Also, how does the goo work again?

It's not bad and is fun but the bad Peter/Spidey tone feels off somehow. Still enjoyable read blending all the angles. McGuiness's art is beyond amazing. His panels, compositions, angles are all near perfect!

It was nice but the buildup to what happens here was off and I already forgot about many elements that happened way back so the issue didn't hit the moments like it should. Wells does well in certain twists to the story but where we came from was not fun and the story doesn't do enough to be great. The art from McGuiness is beyond amazing here. His art makes this issue enjoyable.

This truly feels like Steve Rogers stepped into battleworld or an alternative universe where he is shoehorned into a life full of exposition using him to build something I have no clue where it's going. Sure it reads nice and makes you think about life or death and having a choice or being thrust into action. Rogers is old school and he at least would have his own opinion based on his faith that is nowhere to be found.
Jesus Saiz delivers some really fantastic and clean artwork. It's very good and only enhances the story wherever that's headed. Hollingsworth colors are almost perfect. more

Jesus Saiz's fantastic art is the saving element here for a story that won't be remembered a few months from now. The way this arc just spent all the great will from the first arc baffles me. Not bad but this feels like the 3 or 4 filler episodes that don't matter in a 22 episodes season.

This heads back in some sort of direction but still a weird direction for a Cap story. Jesus Saiz helps a lot in delivering some nice art to help the story hit the notes Straczynski is going for but this is way off for me still.

Straczynski tries too hard to have Cap drop some heavy knowledge and quotes but just doesn't work well. Cap seems out of place in a story that should have Dr. Strange at least in the mix...weird. Magno is delivery some very detailed art but just seems off to me in places. I can't really put my finger on it.

This arc starts in a promising way but still not as intriguing as the past one. Magno's art is not bad but is off from his best. Plenty of detailed work but the figures and faces seem off to me.

Good ending albeit rushed but it delivers an enjoyable read with promise for a future event worth following. I have to give it up for Pepe Larraz and Marte Gracia they were fantastic on art and made this average story look beautiful.

This series moves way too fast and I am missing so much by not reading the tie-ins so it's not as enjoyable. Pepe Larraz is killing it on the art just fantastic stuff.