This is easily once of the best first issues I've read from Marvel yet, and it's no-brainer to recommend checking it out. Amazing cover, great characters, and a line in the sand you're not even sure which side you should be on – what a great start! Read Full Review

A great debut issue that plants lots of interesting seeds for future issues to reap. Read Full Review

Although it opens with a bang of gruesome aggression, Squadron Supreme doesn't solely rest on the (admittedly baffling) action sequences, as the nuances of each character are thoughtfully portrayed with subtlety and righteousness. Theyare the anti-binary of right and wrong. I believe in Squadron Supreme as the defenders of Earth, and as beings whobelieve they do what they do for a reason. Even if the choices they make aren'talways right. Read Full Review

I went in to the first issue with high expectations and the comic met them and more. A solid beginning that so far is the best “Avengers” title to date. Read Full Review

Robinsons reverence for the Golden Age and his appropriation of its elements should come as no surprise to those familiar with his body of work, particularly Justice Society of America and Earth-2. While hes still playing with DCs archetypes, such are set within Marvels multiverse, and if he can replicate for the House of Ideas the success he had at the Distinguished Competition, Squadron Supreme should prove among the best books to come out of All-New Marvel Now. Read Full Review

Wonderful art, smart writing and a fulfilling premise. Read Full Review

I like the idea behind this, it's fun to see a take on the Justice League that does manage to feel original if going over slightly familiar ground. I love the art" but" there are some issues: it felt too short, the whole thing was 19 pages long, and a page or two more for some exposition would have been really useful. I knew of these characters and I needed a little guidance, this is meant to be an issue #1 where complete newbies can join in. Still, I want to know what happens next and I'll give issue #2 a shot myself! Read Full Review

Squadron Supreme is a book teeming with potential: if built properly, the Squadron could be viewed as a legitimate threat to the Avengers, while making readers care about who these characters are. Given the teaser on the last page, though, it doesn't appear that Robinson is going to waste any time in getting to the Squadron versus Avengers conflict. While there is intrigue in seeing that fight, there are only so many times readers will care about this before it becomes old hat. Squadron Supreme is off to an okay start, but James Robinson, Leonard Kirk and Marvel need to be careful not to allow this team to fizzle out before they've told the compelling story that lives within this new series. Read Full Review

Robinson and Kirk assemble a strong and diverse multiversal roster that is capable of carrying a series in "Squadron Supreme" #1. Despite the wavering tone, it's a strong enough debut to bellwether the upcoming issues of the series. Read Full Review

This is an issue with a great sense of purpose, but one that doesn't fully sell the ongoing nature of the book. Read Full Review

Very leery of the writer working these story beats again, but good art and some interesting character moments make for a successful #1… Read Full Review

I get it, they're trying for a different tone - and they succeed there - but this isn't a team I have any interest in. Super-heroics in which the "heroes" kill and destroy at will? Read Full Review

Squadron Supreme is a tough book to have work narratively in an editor driven connected universe like Marvel's and sadly the team isn't up to the task. James Robinson is good, but he and the mandatory time-lapse don't give the reader time to understand the characters. Leonard Kirk shows great improvement in his craft with the help of Paul Neary and Frank Martin to ensure the book looks solid but sadly this series does not look like one that can last long given its non-new reader friendly approach and how it works against the box most superhero comics have written themselves in. Read Full Review

Overall, this was not the best start to a newSquadron Supreme title, but there's a decent enough concept that it may be worth coming back for a second issue. Do not expect this to be Marvel'sJustice League, but do look at it as its own thing: an updatedSquadron Supreme for the 21st century. Read Full Review

Unfortunately, both characters and big action set pieces fail to live up to any potential found within the script. Leonard Kirk's pencils appear inconsistent with Paul Neary providing varying levels of detail and refinement between individual scenes and pages. Much of the enormous battle falls flat, as neither the movement nor scale of what is occurring is realized. Even the composition of a few key moments fails to land with a big (previously spoiled) death rolling across the finish line, rather than racing. It's a disappointing display of a comic that has, if nothing else, potential. Read Full Review

The Squadron Supreme may have been heroes on their own respective worlds but here in this debut, they look and act more like the villains. Read Full Review

Fantastic intro issue. The Squadron Supreme, while not doing agreeable things, are an interesting and brutal team. I loved the fight scenes and the responses from the citizens and the original Human Torch. Can't wait for the next issue.

As a comic with the context of Jonathan Hickman's New Avengers run this issue was amazing and showed a different side to people trying to do the right thing. It wasn't just violence for shock value since I felt it had weight. You have to realize that Namor not only destroyed Dr. Spectrum's world but he went around with Thanos and the Black Order eradicating hundreds of earths so their reality could survive. It's very interesting to see these people who were affected by the incursions now fighting back. I can't wait to continue reading this title.

Crazy

Not the book I was hoping for, but I'll stick around to see what Robinson does with Jim Hammond.

I love the Squad, but this was done in bad taste. One long fight scene where one side dominates the other. At a certain point, I wondered "Is this it?"

"Want to see what happens next," with Hyperion crushing Namor's skull? Not particularly.

Namor's death feels like someone at Marvel asking "Hey, who else is related to the FF, so that we can crap on them?" and Robinson raised his hand and said "There's Namor, and I can have him killed in my book!" and that Marvel exec said "Do it!"

A depressing first issue which by it's very nature cannot have a long run. It relies om the gimmick of violence and shock. I wish we could get back to a more reasonable Squadron, as I used to enjoy them.

A cold, joyless and boring mess. I have no interest in any of these characters and have only been handed reasons to dislike them. As for Namor, I can't say that I ever liked the guy, but to give Marvel's first anti-hero such a half-assed fate with no weight to it is just a kick in the balls. Not to mention shrugging off the genocide of an entire city. I know James Robinson is capable of better than this and I expect more from the editors at Marvel as well. I know Marvel is throwing everything that they have at the wall right now to see what will stick, but the world would be better off if this comic had never existed.