This 100-page 4 chapter story is well worth finding, though I understand it is selling out at many stores. Hopefully it will get a second print or be added to some collection. It deserves to stay in print and available to fans who would like to read a really nice "behind the scenes" story about Clark Kent as he transitions to his more famous identity. I also appreciate that no attempt is made to shoehorn it into current DC continuity. It's a nice tale that stands on its own outside of the shackles of a continuity that changes fairly regularly anyway. This is highly recommended for all fans of the man behind the Superman. Read Full Review

Man and Superman feels a bit like Spider-Man: Into the Spider-Verse; it is not what you might expect at first glance, but it is a near-perfect interpretation of the story its creators set out to tell, and the minute you finish it, you want to pick it back up and "go back into the movie," so to speak. Read Full Review

This is a story that truly gets what makes Superman such a beloved character. It's sure to be praised as a masterpiece for many years to come. Read Full Review

Marv Wolfman has created something truly special here. As I stated in the beginning, these are the types of Superman stories I love. This is who the Man of Steel is. He is a Kansas farm-boy who happened to be born light years away. He is a good MAN who has the powers of a god. Wolfman gives us all of this and wraps a heartwarming story of transition, growth, emerging super-villains and emerging super-heroes around it. Meanwhile, the impeccable artwork of Claudio Castellini brings this tale to life. The artwork is classic and timeless. It is a book that radiates hope and goodness with its rendering of Clark Kent and Superman. In all, this is a superb piece of storytelling and a book that I highly recommend Read Full Review

This is my personal favorite standalone Superman story I've read in quite some time. Pick this one up to see one of the industry's best writers firing on all cylinders - and to hopefully encourage DC to take more chances with unpublished works! Read Full Review

It's impressive that this was written well over a decade ago because this Luthor very much feels like a villain of the moment. But as good as the supporting cast is, this is a story about Clark Kent becoming Superman, and realizing that he can carry these burdens on this back. And on that note, it's a definite win. Wolfman's dogged determination to make sure this sees the light of day has resulted in a great comic. Read Full Review

One of the finest Superman stories of all time. Read Full Review

Great story by Wolfman! This one is a very good read.

Marv Wolfman said, this is the best Superman story he has ever written. I can assure you, it is. Have you ever heard of a writer say this? I have not. That urged me to pick this one up so anyone who is even slightly interested in Superman should read this. This is not the typical origin story of baby Kal-El - kid Clark Kent who eventually becomes Superman and save lives from there. This is the crucial moment of Clark Kent's life, these decisions change him forever, he becomes the man the world would remember. Wolfman really understands Superman and... Lois Lane. I loved the art, it is by far the best in terms of detailing. Wolfman himself said, Claudio Castellini poured his heart and soul into this. Some of you may think this is an exaggeration of a review by a Superman fan, all you really gotta do is look for yourself. more

Minor spoilers: Clark's big 'Flying Man' story didn't work for me, because 1) did no one wonder How and IF Clark interviewed him? Wheres proof? Did he take a photo? No? Why not? And one paragraph of Supes explaining himself WITHOUT Clark asking where he's from, how he got his powers, etc., does NOzt a great reporter make. Also, when Clark destroyed those missile in his street clothes, why didn't The Flying Man' transform into The Naked Man?

Some aspects of the story ring false. To start, Clark can find gold at the bottom of the ocean. He would never need money. Also, his confidence is too low for a man superior to any other person on Earth.
Primitive story effort.
Great art.

Another origin story focussing on the first step of Clark as superman and as journalist.
It was not bad, but not what I looked for. With the Superman Earth One in the catalog, I even not understand why doing this version.

Cover - Could have be better than this, but I understand what they mean by doing this and the link. 1.5/2
Writing - It's really classic story. Appart the fact Clark screw up a lot at first nothing is new. 2/3
Arts - The arts is really good, but I find Lois not beautifull. In fact their is other femal character way more sexy than her in this. 3/3
Feeling - Not very interesting. 1/2

"We do what we do"

I wasn't planning on checking this one out, but I'm kinda glad I did.

It's nothing really groundbreaking or spectacular, just another retelling/reimaging of Clark's first days in Metropolis, but I'm a bit of a sucker for these type of stories.
The story feels a bit old-school and it checks every mark in the Superman box. He flies, he saves people, he writes, he gets on Luthor's bad side. Some of the marks are also a bit on the silly side. Things like super-inhaling through the nose to change the trajectory of a falling ball or using super-breath to literally push people out of the way of a speeding truck. Those are very Superman things, but I would be lying if I said I want more of them in contemporary books.

All in all, it was a fun reimaging. Marv Wolfman gives us a story with good dialogue that isn't "out of character" (something that folks love to point out these days) and the art gets the job done. more