Despite my personal gripe with the ranger scene and the assumed gripes new fans will have with the lack of introduction, THE MIGHTY CAPTAIN MARVEL #1 is a solid first issue. I'm happy that Marvel is continuing to have a woman write this title, as I believe the representation in that department is important, especially with a popular character like Carol. If this series can build upon Alpha Flight and continue to make it a relevant space team, I foresee a lot of potential in its relevancy within the Marvel Universe. Read Full Review

Overall, this is a minor issue with the book and it continues to be another "Marvel Now" book which takes the superhero stuff in its stride and then go one step further. Read Full Review

There's a real emergency going on, and one which can't be solved by punching villains or switching off the TV. We review The Mighty Captain Marvel #1. Read Full Review

Reading all this, if you are still with me, you might think that I didn't like this book, which isn't true. It's fine. But that's probably why I'm being picky – Captain Marvel is one of my favorite characters and I, like many members of the Carol Corps, have very high expectations for books with our girl. We need some strong stories so we don't lose momentum before her movie in 2018, and while I'm glad they are moving her away from Events and giving her a unique storyline, I'm not sure this particular issue is going to hook new readers. Read Full Review

Worth reading if you want to wash the taste of "Civil War II" out of your mouth, but not something that will sell you on the character if you haven't been impressed with previous offerings. Read Full Review

So, while I liked this book, and I plan on buying the next few to see where the story goes. I can't totally recommend this book if you already have a full slate of comics. Maybe pick it up when it hits trade paper and save yourself some money and room in your longbox. Read Full Review

This was an otherwise solid restart. All of the characters ring true and are a lot of fun, with Carol as the stable center. The art is down to Earth, which always helps ground such an outer space crew. It's just the various juggled plots that jumble a bit along the way. Read Full Review

It's a simple, if familiar, setup, and while this first issue won't bowl over any readers, it's a solidly constructed and character appropriate start. With artist Ramon Rosanas turning in a similarly strong debut, there's plenty of time for this title to become as mighty as its title promise. Read Full Review

At the end of the day, I plan on giving the book another shot. Probably two more shots, even. Stohl clearly has some incredible storytelling chops–they just arent on display for the entirety of this issue. Get away from the boring, conventional superheroics, and the creative team potentially has an all-timer on their hands. Read Full Review

The Mighty Captain Marvel #1 does the same thing as all the previous Captain Marvel comics, but it does it very well. It will be interesting to see where this alien refuges story goes, but it will be even more interesting to see Captain Marvel fly on her own without the burden of the endless baggage brought about by other writers and countless crossovers. Read Full Review

This is still a good read and I recommend picking it up. Hopefully in the next few issue the magic will return and this will continue to be a solid series. Read Full Review

I can't say this issue has enticed me to read further. The plot, the art: none of it screams must read. After CW II Captain Marvel has all the momentum needed to drive a series I'm just not sure this is the one. Read Full Review

Not quite a disaster but also not exactly a blockbuster, Mighty Captain Marvel #1 stands somewhere in the middle as a clumsy debut, but one that is still fun in its own way. Margaret Stohl, Ramon Rosanas, and Michael Garland throw a lot of stuff at the wall in this first issue and unfortunately not all of it sticks. That said, their love and respect for the Captain and her cast is there and that, at least, gives me hope that they can rise above their less than auspicious start. The world needs Carol Danvers and hopefully in later issues, this series can truly be called a mighty achievement. Read Full Review

This new volume of Captain Marvel glides right by Civil War II, attempting to move Carol Danvers' life in a more classic direction but not introducing anything noteworthy about the character. Read Full Review

It's just so hum drum and routine for Carol that you get tired of reading the same issues over and over again. The art of Rosanas and Garland is just as basic as Stone's story. I don't know it just feels like a deja vu with been here done that kind of thing.

Carol has a refugee crisis, a sinister bounty hunter, and a stupid TV show to deal with. I can't put thumbs up for this hot mess of a title yet. It'll be quite welcome to die-hard Carol Corps members, although I hope nobody gets so blinded with Carol love that they overlook the significant problems with this issue. I have a sliver of hope that it will shape up and get better.

Very dull and bland for a number one issue, hopefully it will pick up next issue.

I can applaud the good intentions of the writer, but Carol has been so bad for a couple of years now, and this book just continues that trend that I almost feel like Avengers 200 is a step up.