Matthew Sibley's Comic Reviews

Reviewer For: Newsarama Reviews: 369
7.5Avg. Review Rating

9
4 Kids Walk Into A Bank #4

May 16, 2017

If Rosenberg's Kingpin is focusing on how a figure of criminality looks to someone on the outside, 4 Kids Walk into a Bank occupies the inverse notion. This series is lived in and focuses on kids that should be on the outside, but find themselves on the precipice of falling in. The title may sound like the start of a joke, but this book's subject is no laughing matter. The kids might not have this in mind every step of the way, but that creates an oddball vibe that allows series like this from Black Mask to thrive, occupying a space of its own in the comics landscape.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
A.D.: After Death #1

Nov 28, 2016

It's an issue that I devoured and then went back through to comb over for additional details and clues and I can't wait to see what comes next, which is maybe the reason for the aforementioned flaw " that I don't have the rest of it in front of me to devour.

View Issue       View Full Review
6
Absolute Carnage (2019) #4

Oct 18, 2019

The overall craziness and pace of the story is one that struggles to fit into the page count from a writing perspective, even though Stegman his inkers JP Mayer and Jay Leisten, plus colorist Frank Martin pack in plenty of the grotesque.

View Issue       View Full Review
5
Action Comics (2016) #975

Mar 9, 2017

Detailing the back-up would spoil the big reveal so I'll avoid doing so, but Dini has a far bigger sandbox to play in, making for the more entertaining portion of this issue.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Action Comics (2016) #1006

Jan 7, 2019

With any luck, Sook and Anderson will be able to collaborate again later in the run, because their work in this issue (in addition to their previous two chapters) shows how strong they are with the various components that make-up the book's overall shape as well as the little things that serve to make it all the more memorable.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Age Of X-Man: X-Tremists #2

Mar 28, 2019

The greatest strength of Leah Williams' script is how much work she puts into complicating the viewpoints of the team and observing the ensuing fallout of the self-believed good guys. She really digs into this via Psylocke and Blob after they have a brief conversation about his romantic feelings towards her, and how that particular can of worms can't ever be sealed back up.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Alienated #1

Feb 18, 2020

Alienated's concept gives our three protagonists the ability to hear what often goes unspoken. There are hints at backstory already being seeded, with Samantha’s being the most notable in terms of already connecting to the other thematic elements of the book. While some will point to E.T. or Chronicle for comparison, the tale also recalls Buffy the Vampire Slayer’s “Earshot” episode, in which Buffy also became able to hear the thoughts of those around her at school and ended up preventing a tragedy that no one else could because it was coming from the mind of one of the quiet ones. That too stemmed from a sense of alienation, and the fact that this story appears to be going in a science-fiction direction shows how ripe the basic premise is, providing this cast of teenage an opportunity to find themselves and each other.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
All-New Guardians of the Galaxy Annual #1

Jun 29, 2017

It's fun in the same way the movies are and it's smart they made this an annual instead of a main series issue because it works better as an optional detour for those who want more of the characters, but disconnected from Duggan's larger story.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
All-New Wolverine #12

Sep 22, 2016

It's a refreshing change of pace for how often events and their tie-ins have heroes fight each other in lieu of talking. That said, Ig Guara still gets the chance to show off his skills, delivering a dynamic two-page spread, and the series' humour is still present when appropriate, resulting in a wonderful conclusion to this arc.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
All-Star Batman #10

May 10, 2017

This stands out because it feels different in an issue that otherwise feels surprisingly familiar, not solely because Snyder’s using one of his go-to narrative tools, but after the previous arc’s twisting of formal storytelling conventions, this brings us back down to earth with something that feels a more typical. Compared to the first arc, the narrative has a more solid foundation, but it doesn’t get the blood pumping like both of those have tried to. That said, based on the execution alone, All-Star Batman #10 will clearly appeal as a solid opener, but given the ambitions that have defined this title, I hope this arc will ramp up as we get deeper into the story.

View Issue       View Full Review
5
Analog #1

Apr 5, 2018

Narratively, there's a promise that there's more going on than initially presented, but the problem is that Analog's concept isn't fresh enough to engage from the jump.

View Issue       View Full Review
5
Angel (2019) #1

May 30, 2019

On a visual level, both aesthetic styles are strong and promising in establishing what the series will look like, it's just hard to get a read of the voice of the book with how long it takes for the story to kick in.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Aquaman (2016) #46

Mar 21, 2019

The sheer scale of it in turns earns the reverberations it causes throughout the ocean by issue's end, the way this tale appears to be expanding is a thrilling way to up the ante in an arc that's already of high quality and of its best issue yet.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Assassin Nation #1

Mar 14, 2019

Henderson's eclectic character design makes for building quite the expressive ensemble, a factor which helps when the bullets starts flying. Even in the middle of the frenzy, her cartooning persists as some of the best of the best, a wonderful fit for a book about exactly that.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Assassin Nation #4

Jun 20, 2019

Bullets begin to fly before the first page is over in this quip and violence-ridden bonanza, which means Rankin's still in danger, and thus Echidna couldn't have been trying to take him out.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Astonishing Ant-Man #13

Oct 20, 2016

The verdict is in "Astonishing Ant-Man #13 sticks the landing and provides a fitting send-off for Spencer and Rosanas' run on the title.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
Astonishing X-Men (2017) #1

Jul 24, 2017

Psychics are dying, and none of them saw it coming. Charles Soule andn Jim Cheung's Astonishing X-Men #1 gets right into the plot with a sense of brevity as Psylocke finds herself the target of an attack and brings together a makeshift team of Old Man Logan, Rogue, Gambit, Psylocke, Angel and M to help her deal with that.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Astonishing X-Men (2017) #2

Aug 17, 2017

Focusing on mining character relationships, this creative team cements Astonishing X-Men as one of the top-tier "ResurrXion" titles.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
Avengers (2016) #1

Nov 3, 2016

Mike Del Mundo really is a great artist, huh? And now he's been given a flagship book which ushers in a new time for the Avengers post teen-hero walkout, but doesn't necessarily play to his strengths.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Avengers (2016) #1.1

Nov 10, 2016

While the main Avengers title will hopefully be doing something new with Kang and time-travel, these .1 issues look like they'll be providing a classic feeling team updated for a modern reading experience.

View Issue       View Full Review
6
Avengers (2016) #675

Jan 12, 2018

It is primarily a set-up issue, but the various threads being established feel cohesive enough at this moment to suggest it'll hold together for now.

View Issue       View Full Review
4
Avengers (2018) #6

Aug 23, 2018

The far-reaching allusions don't mean anything yet, but promise this will all eventually build into something. Hopefully that something is more satisfying than this first arc, which never truly came together even after the team itself had gone through the requisite assembling.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Avengers: No Road Home #1

Feb 15, 2019

While this first issue, much like its predecessor's, exists to set up the various threads going forward, what No Road Home has over No Surrender's debut is that the spectacle doesn't overshadow these characters. Most exciting is the dynamic between Hulk and Hawkeye, though Vision's arc appears to have the most emotional potential, with the issue's reader-friendly approach and contextual backmatter making it clear where all these characters are at even if you haven't caught up with the team's previous tale.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Avengers: No Road Home #9

Apr 11, 2019

Under the collective pen of Al Ewing, Mark Waid and Jim Zub, their narrative shows no signs of slowing down from the fast pace that has characterised the series thus far, but all the more impressive is how it continues to keep things moving while still having moments of introspection throughout.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
Banjax #1

Jun 13, 2019

Some more character-focused beats of the book get rushed through so Grant can fit everything in, but as mentioned, it's a first issue, there's presumably time to flesh these out in a later one.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Batman (2016) #7

Sep 22, 2016

Steve Orlando does a great job bringing all of the stories together, even if some of the finer points are glossed over, and he certainly delivers when it comes to bombastic action. If this is any indication, every member of the Bat Family will have a chance to shine.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
Batman (2016) #8

Oct 7, 2016

Part 4 of the "Night of the Monster Men" crossover pits Batman and Batwoman against the monster-fied Nightwing and Gotham Girl in an issue that feels like more of the same.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Batman (2016) #10

Nov 3, 2016

Rather than repeat what came before in "Knightfall," Tom King manages to turn a reversal of events into a fist-pumping moment that is reminiscent of the hyper capable Batman of Grant Morrison, and continues the high octane streak this book has been on since issue 1.

View Issue       View Full Review
10
Batman (2016) #15

Jan 20, 2017

King's script allows the book to transcend the height reached by Gerard's art alone, moving through pillow talk, heart-pumping pages of adrenaline and true genius when the final pieces of the puzzle that is King's Catwoman click into place, it manages to land the necessary beats in an understated way - they register and stick with you without needing repeated reinforcement.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Batman (2016) #19

Mar 15, 2017

Comic books have a habit of repeating themselves if you stick around long enough. Batman and Bane have engaged in battles of wit and strength before. Both have been broken by the other. We’re about to be at the point of physical conflict again, but not in the same way that it’s played out before, because this isn’t about saving a city. King’s Batman already did that at the beginning of his run, and now what’s at stake instead is the personification of the city in Gotham Girl. It’s an intently personal confrontation that’s on the horizon. It’s two longtime foes headed on a collision course, not to save the world, but to save just one life. It’s an unstoppable force headed to an immovable object. With this information in mind, the question that remains is… which one will break first?

View Issue       View Full Review
4
Batman (2016) #21

Apr 24, 2017

For years, people have wondered, "what if the Watchmen did exist in the DC Universe," and while the overarching narrative of "Rebirth" first appeared to be tackling that head on, since then it seems to have been trying to coast on the multitude of hypothesis that stem from it, instead of actually expanding upon it. So while Batman #21 may be visceral and intense, because of those connections to the wider narrative, it feels like an extension of this problem driving to its illogical conclusion.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Batman (2016) #25

Jun 21, 2017

It looks like chaos is about to be king in Gotham, but King, Jann, Chung, and Clayton Cowles are decidedly in control of this story.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Batman (2016) #27

Jul 24, 2017

A story of casualties, of the ones who suffered as chaos reigned, makes Chuck a ripe subject to study under this lens, that miraculously reaches an ending that'll make you want to say, "hell yeah."

View Issue       View Full Review
7
Batman (2016) #33

Oct 23, 2017

It took a while to get a real sense of the first year's shape and with that now being built on top of, it'll take a while before the expanded picture - and where Bruce's head is now at - becomes clear, however the idea that a run can feel that large more than 30 issues in is worth savoring, as is the opportunity to try and fit the pieces together.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Batman (2016) #44

Apr 5, 2018

Oscillating between continuity throwbacks and a silent nighttime adventure, King's script carries itself with a spring in its step, switching between the two modes as gracefully as Catwoman.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Batman (2016) #45

Apr 18, 2018

One of the biggest strengths of King's Batman since "The War of Jokes and Riddles" is how his arcs have been smaller-length affairs. Having stories that are anywhere from one to three issues, coupled with the double shipping approach, ensures his tenure stays dynamic as it builds towards Bruce and Selina's wedding. This arc allows him to do a big catastrophe-driven story while retaining a psychological angle and without overshadowing the impending nuptials.

View Issue       View Full Review
4
Batman (2016) #57

Oct 19, 2018

This feels like a misfire of an arc that would've worked better had Batman and the Beast's violence had consumed the issue for its full length.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Batman (2016) #59

Nov 21, 2018

The issue brings King's run into further focus as is presumably transitions into a new stage of the game being played, all the while showing that there's more than one way to break a Bat.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Batman (2016) Annual #1

Dec 1, 2016

Everyone involved is in top form for these short-form narratives which are economical in their storytelling " getting in just as the action rises and bowing out as the tension starts to slow. While you may be dying to find out what happens next in "I Am Suicide," this Batman Annual is a worthwhile interlude.

View Issue       View Full Review
4
Batman / Catwoman (2020) #1

Dec 1, 2020

As much as Batman/Catwoman wants to be a summation of everything Batman can be, it serves too many masters to accomplish much at all.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Batman / The Shadow #3

Jun 29, 2017

There's something deliciously pulpy about the way Steve Orlando writes The Joker. His interpretation would feel right at home in Batman: The Animated Series, which drew inspiration from the early 1940's, but he'll makes do with this story involving two heroes from that era.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Batman: Creature of the Night #1

Dec 4, 2017

Which is perhaps a summation of the issue. This world is markedly different from both Gotham and our own, but Busiek, Leon, and Klein don't bend it to the point that it breaks in the process. Instead, they twist it just enough and offer multiple ways to approach Batman: Creature of the Night. They've put the work into ensuring this isn't just a rehash or going through the motions. It's a distinct story. Fresh without being alienating. Intently subjective, but through multiple perspectives, posing questions about objectivity, "truth" and reality in the process.

View Issue       View Full Review
5
Batman: Damned #1

Sep 24, 2018

The imprint's announcement stressed the idea of unique stories, only there's little ambition on display "" though there is a little full-frontal nudity "" just yet another story about The Joker and Batman.

View Issue       View Full Review
6
Batman: The Detective (2021) #1

Apr 13, 2021

Like their interpretation of Bruce's state of being, it is a starting point rather than a fully fleshed-out and understood vision. The thematics are the most detailed factor, making for an issue ruminating on lives saved and the ghosts of those lost, and it remains to be seen if the creative team will be able to use the remaining five issues to connect these various pieces into a more cohesive whole.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Batman: Universe #3

Sep 12, 2019

In a time where decompression is bemoaned, and with Bendis' usual style being used as a prime example, this is a delightful and sharp-looking counterpoint that goes by all too quickly.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
Batwoman (2017) #7

Sep 21, 2017

Writer Marguerite Bennett's narration delves into Kate's mindset as she makes this dangerous trek across the desert, but it's the flashbacks that are the highlight of the issue, focusing on Kate's flirtation with the Arms earlier in his life.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Black Bolt #1

May 3, 2017

The notion of voice is key to Black Bolt, and not just because of the character, but also because this is the first issue of a new series and the first issue from a new comic bookcreator. The issue gains a character about halfway through that fills the issue with actual dialogue, but for the most part, Ahmed, Ward, and Cowles also value silence. This methodical approach shows what visual storytelling can accomplish and indicates a strong creative voice. The focus on establishing a particular mood shows that this team has something to say here. The team could have afforded to be more abstract in their setting, but this isn’t a series which intends to throw everything and the kitchen sink at you straight away. A picture can say a thousand words, and while some may choose to yell it from the rooftops, the team behind Black Bolt wants to first be sure that you’re listening carefully.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Black Bolt #8

Dec 8, 2017

Ahmed and Ward bring a touch of the cosmos back to Earth thanks to all the insanity Black Bolt has dealt with in the first arc, and uses it as proof that difficulty reconnecting with people and family is beyond universal.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
Black Panther & the Crew #1

Apr 14, 2017

So it's more of a slower debut, Black Panther and the Crew isn't just about the characters in the title, but also the world they work in. Harlem's a big place, so it's going to take a while to sketch it all out.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Black Panther (2016) #7

Oct 20, 2016

While Black Panther has always been a worthwhile read, it's been firing on all cylinders since Zeke Stane was added as a main cast member. He's helped to show that the prose like dialogue evident in the first four issues is a Wakandan trait over part of Coates' style and that's proven further here.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Black Panther (2018) #1

May 29, 2018

As a first issue, Black Panther #1 displays a solid handle on what it wants to be and establishes that clearly to readers. As a story, it feels both fresh and exciting, crafting a distinct identity that stands out against the many other books on the stands.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Black Panther: World of Wakanda #2

Dec 22, 2016

Roxane Gay may have found her feet within the comics industry even faster than Coates, and with him in tow as consultant, World of Wakanda is wonderful as a companion piece to Coates' series, but works just as well as a standalone.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Black Racer & Shilo Norman Special #1

Aug 31, 2017

The two teams work together on this story rather than one handling a back-up, their styles blending well and of course this issue comes with reprints of Kirby's work which helps to make this special all the more delightful.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Black Widow (2016) #12

Mar 30, 2017

Black Widow #12 is a phenomenal issue to cap off a phenomenal run that's a deserving candidate of an oversized hardcover in the future.

View Issue       View Full Review
6
Black Widow (2019) #5

May 16, 2019

Jen and Sylvia Soska have demonstrated an understanding of the Black Widow's character that makes it easy to wish they had more than these five issues to work with " even just one more to better serve said scene and expand it into its own distinct issue " to see where else they'd take her and to see them get even more used to working in the medium.

View Issue       View Full Review
6
Blade Runner: 2019 #4

Oct 10, 2019

Taking an extended trip across the border into Mexico, the conclusion to the first arc of Blade Runner 2019 further fleshes out this world in a way the movies didn't have time for.

View Issue       View Full Review
6
Bone Parish #1

Jul 26, 2018

Orlando's premise is ambitious, but the years-long timeframe of the story is a little hard to register over the course of 20 pages, even as he and Braga work hard to include Diana's various costume changes over the years. Regardless, this might be the best issue of Wonder Woman in years, so don't miss out.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
Buffy the Vampire Slayer (2019) #2

Feb 28, 2019

Seeing these characters again with such a comfortable vibe is welcome enough for now, but it does mean we're waiting to see what they'll end up getting up to.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Buffy the Vampire Slayer (2019) #5

Jun 6, 2019

Jordie Bellaire's script gets a little playful with time, opening with a more dynamic scene (and a strong welcome for arc artist David Lopez) and also expediting part of the group's efforts thanks to the story in BOOM!'s Free Comic Book Day offering. Couple this with Jenny's involvement in the story, and this issue really enforces how Bellaire has both the voices and the relationships of the characters down while also creating her own strikingly different narrative for them to occupy.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Buffy the Vampire Slayer (2019) #7

Aug 12, 2019

Compared to the show, it's moving through big events dramatically quicker (largely due to how long an issue lasts compared to a 42-minute episode of a 22-episode season) and is more directly serialized, but it's the emphasis on character which shows just how alive the series is at its core.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Buffy the Vampire Slayer (2019) #13

Mar 9, 2020

Compared to her work on last year's Laura Dean Keeps Breaking Up With Me or recent Shortbox-published book, Valero-O'Connell's isn't as free-flowing, though she retains her intense clarity of emotion across the cast's faces. Coupled with Ral Angulo and Eleonara Bruni's luminous colors, this is in keeping with the aesthetic of previous arcs without requiring a complete upheaval of her style.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Buffy the Vampire Slayer (2019) #14

May 21, 2020

Though a quieter issue overall, it builds to both a big emotional crescendo and an intriguing final page that'll surely complicate Buffy's life more.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Buffy the Vampire Slayer/Angel: Hellmouth #3

Dec 13, 2019

Jordie Bellaire and Jeremy Lambert script their team-up in a way that's true to the essence of both characters (right down to Angel avoiding telling Buffy what he is) and using that as a springboard to craft a story that can be drastically different in its dynamics.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Bug: The Adventures of Forager #3

Jul 13, 2017

Early on Forager remarks his stumbling through dimensions is getting monotonous, but he's in the wrong, for this continues to be delightful, packed with substance and craft in equal measure.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
Bullseye (2017) #3

Apr 6, 2017

It's wickedly dark and has avoided veering into caricature so far, but I'm not sure there's been anything which is truly madcap.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
By Night #3

Aug 20, 2018

Allison’s scripts are densely layered; laced with jokes, character insights and subtle plot machinations without ever seeming heady or overwrought. In Larsen, Stern and Campbell, he’s found yet another creative team which only enhance these qualities when collaboratively translating the story into a visual medium. What’s most impressive is how they’re accomplishing this on a month-to-month basis, something all the more important when thinking about how many books seem to fall prey to decompression and padding for the trade. Juggling plots, characters and stories for serialized comics isn’t always easy, but By Night’s creative team sure does make it look that way.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
By Night #7

Jan 10, 2019

As the series enters its back half, the town of Spectrum collide with what's on the other side of an otherworldly portal, as evidenced by the first scene involving Chip needing to help someone from a creature that belongs on the other side.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Calexit #1

Jul 13, 2017

An oversized issue rich with story, Calexit comes out swinging, and it's commendable that it throws so many punches and pulls none of them.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Captain America (2018) #3

Sep 6, 2018

Some of the meatiest material could've easily fallen flat if not granted proper attention, yet Coates et al manage to keep every plate spinning.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Captain America (2018) #7

Feb 5, 2019

From the outset, it was evident that Coates was running with what Nick Spencer did during his time on Captain America, turning it into something genuinely interesting and nuanced.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Captain America (2018) #12

Aug 1, 2019

Coates has been telling a story that's been sure to parse the difference between Cap the icon and Steve Rogers the person, something which also comes across in Adam Kubert and Matt Milla's art.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Captain America (2018) Annual #1

Sep 24, 2018

It is to the issue's credit and general cohesiveness that the various approaches all gel, even if the ending reads as abbreviated.

View Issue       View Full Review
5
Captain America: Sam Wilson #17

Jan 5, 2017

What prevents this issue being a complete mess is the art from Paul Renaud who also assisted John Rauch on colors. They do some great work with shadow resulting in strong iconography for Sam Wilson, but this isn't enough to help the sour taste of the book's middle subside.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
Captain America: Steve Rogers #13

Mar 9, 2017

On the way to "Secret Empire," Captain America: Steve Rogers marches on to the beat of a drum which sounded foreign when it debuted last year, but has incrementally become attuned to something that might not always be outstanding, but is always interesting.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Captain Marvel (2016) #10

Nov 23, 2016

While this series dipped in quality as a result of Civil War II (like many series did), the main strength of the run was the dynamic Carol had with Alpha Flight, putting it at the forefront makes for a strong closing issue and the fact that it'll continue to be present moving forward makes me all the more eager for The Mighty Captain Marvel next month.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Captain Marvel (2019) #1

Jan 8, 2019

Sharply written, gorgeously illustrated, and unabashedly feminist, Captain Marvel #1 is a showcase for what Carol and this creative team are capable of.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Captain Marvel (2019) #4

Apr 11, 2019

Kelly Thompson has demonstrating a strong understanding of both Carol Danvers' character as well as Rogue's, so it should be no surprise that their confrontation within this issue only exemplifies that further.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
Captain Marvel (2019) #13

Dec 13, 2019

The opening to the "Last Avenger" arc opted to raise a number of questions and let them hang in the air as the spectacle unfolded, and Captain Marvel #13 starts to cleverly answer why and how Carol's going after some of her fellow Avengers, balancing this with another big fight.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Casanova: Acedia #7

Nov 10, 2016

For a volume of the series that's been a slow burn, even more so when contrasted with Avaritia's pacing, this appears to be the ignition for full speed ahead.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Casanova: Acedia #8

Mar 21, 2017

So, yes, this didn't advance the serialised plotting of this album per se, but on a wider level Casanova's about change. Or at least, it is to me, that's the nature of avant-garde comic-booking, that you get out of it what you can find. It's because of this that the issue works so well, even if I'm not clear on all the details the first go-around. It demonstrates a commitment to never slowing down, to never staying on one thing for too long. Sure, it's dense, it's confusing, it's bombastic, it's immoral at times, it's suave, it's cool. That's Casanova. And the only way it'd disappoint me, is if it wasn't.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
Catwoman (2018) #2

Aug 8, 2018

The creative team's visual storytelling is so precise and carefully calibrated to character's emotions that it's hard not to wonder what this series would like if it were silent and it was down to the art to tell the whole story.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Catwoman (2018) #4

Oct 11, 2018

The series operates as a mood piece, not a casualty of decompression, even if will likely read better when collected. This isn't to say the story couldn't be meatier, only it begs the question of if that extra weight would work against the series' gracefulness.

View Issue       View Full Review
6
Catwoman (2018) #9

Mar 14, 2019

Though fun and a fitting Catwoman story, you can feel it hitting the expected beats, right down to the requisite mid-heist twist, one-by-one, even if it gets to each one in time with the rhythm.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Catwoman (2018) #11

May 10, 2019

Structured around an extended chase sequence - first between vehicles, then on foot -Catwoman #11's big draw is in how the thrill of motion can be conveyed through sequential, yet still images.

View Issue       View Full Review
4
Catwoman: Election Night #1

Nov 3, 2016

The main issue with Catwoman: Election Night is that it doesn't say anything new. Meredith Finch adopts a duo of outplayed analogues and while it's message warning against one candidate in particular bears repeating, it gets lost in the stilted dialogue and abrupt ending, even though the closing sentiment is touching.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Cave Carson Has A Cybernetic Eye #1

Oct 20, 2016

In short, another strong debut for the imprint " bring on Mother Panic next month.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Champions (2016) #1

Oct 10, 2016

The Marvel Universe has undertaken a lot of changes in recent years - that much is undeniable, regardless of how you felt about said changes. Champions very much reflects that, but remembers what Marvel did back at its start -classic superhero stories with bright and expressive artwork. Waid knows this, and combines with the sense of belonging that X-Men books have made people feel for decades to create an issue that takes a while to get into the thick of things, but when it does, creates a new team doing what you expect from heroes, only difference being there's someone here for everyone to look up to in some way.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
Children of the Atom (2021) #1

Mar 10, 2021

This issue isn't limited to the art, however. Cyclops-Lass narrates from the outset, so Buddy's personality comes through strongest simply due to having more time to speak and share their thoughts. With the issue filtered through this POV, Buddy's dynamic with Carmen get the most development by virtue of the two being best friends and spending more time together when not in costume. But the other three teammates get the short shrift. Buddy's thoughts about Gabe are briefly detailed at one point, but Benny and Jay get less time. Jay, the youngest of the group who doesn't attend high school with the others, falls by the wayside in particular.

View Issue       View Full Review
6
Civil War II #6

Oct 28, 2016

While it's a welcome change from the original that Civil War II hasn't become an all-out brawl without time for character, this feels too late for the event to be having the conversations where both sides are well and truly given equal weight.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Criminal (2019) #12

Jan 31, 2020

This arc has been a long time coming, and while "Bad Weekend" marks the highpoint of the volume, the great strength of this arc is it still makes you wish it could end any other way, even at the end. But it was always on the road to tragedy.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Crowded #1

Aug 16, 2018

Writer Chistopher Sebela's script teases details about this wider world, though the book's real strength is in how well it digs into the two lead characters rather than hoping the concept is enough of a hook for readers to come back.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Crowded #7

Jul 8, 2019

A new city awaits in the next issue, but it's good to have Crowded back on the stands, where even the transitional parts of the story are a full realization of its potential.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Daredevil (2015) #17

Feb 15, 2017

This arc had a lot resting on it going in. Not only did it need to feel like a continuation of sorts of Waid and Samnee’s run, but also bridge the timeline between their’s and Soule’s in addition to fitting in tonally with the rest of Soule’s tenure on the title until this point. That’s a lot of balls to juggle, but thanks to the creative team’s work up until this point, they’re able to make it look easy. Having done a couple of arcs prior, they’ve clearly worked out the best way to work with one another and they’ve been waiting to tell this story for a while. Much like Samnee and Waid’s work, it feels mature and serious without an overbearing darkness and due to the respectful way that Kirsten is handled in addition to a late reveal, this feels like an arc that will be mindful of what’s come before.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Daredevil (2019) #8

Jul 22, 2019

From the strong sense of class politics that comes across to the sense of history that's built up through a recollection of past events, Hell's Kitchen and its way of doing things comes across as an ever-present force in the story being told even as it's being told within the confines of domesticity. The neighborhood has established its own order that has become a way of life for so many. It's presented as easier to go along with, as any attempt to escape will see the city find a way to pull you back in.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Dark Days: The Forge #1

Jun 14, 2017

What Dark Days: The Forge and Metal have going for them above all else is that they're about exploring something unknown to us, and so even though Snyder has peppered in hints to this story in his earlier work, we as an audience now stand on the edge of exploring a new world. That mere premise and its infinite possibilities is positively captivating.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Dark Nights: Metal #1

Aug 17, 2017

Snyder's script takes a while to get to what Dark Days set up, but what precedes the furthering of that plot is grin-inducing and it's a treat to see superhero spectacle that feels this polished from a creative team this strong.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
Dark Nights: Metal #3

Oct 12, 2017

Metal still feels too stop-and-start to really feel like a rush, but the baseline tempo is underlying and keeping it humming along.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
DC / Looney Tunes: Lex Luthor/Porky Pig #1

Aug 30, 2018

The jabs aren't necessarily subtle, nor offer a grand thesis, but the punching up allows for a consistent string of gags, all the while making it clear that Porky's new-found success is bound to come crashing back down like an unwanted stock sooner or later.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
DC Universe Holiday Special: 2017 #1

Dec 8, 2017

Like a stocking, anthologies are stuffed with all manner of miniature gifts " thankfully, DC has packed 11 tales that move at a pace merry enough to not get bogged down by the duds.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
Death of X #2

Oct 20, 2016

The conflict is taking its time to build, but it's appreciated that neither side wants to go to war before they've exhausted all the pacifist options available. Lemire and Soule do a good job with stressing this, but also continuing Cyclops' character arc. Sadly, the issue is hampered by some inconsistent art.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Deathstroke (2016) #3

Sep 29, 2016

All in all, Deathstroke continues to be a sprawling narrative told through tight episodic installments

View Issue       View Full Review
7
Deathstroke (2016) #50

Dec 5, 2019

All things considered, it's as good an ending as possible, though falls short of the heights thought possible just earlier this year.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Defenders (2017) #1

Jun 16, 2017

There may still be a couple months to go until the four join together on screen, but this book has them assembled (to an extent) with a confident collaboration in Bendis, Marquez, and Ponsor already operating in harmony.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
Demon Days (2021): X-Men #1

Mar 3, 2021

Demon Days: X-Men #1 is most enjoyable when simply being looked at and taking in the strength of Momoko's designs being translated to interior artwork with ease. Her style has not sacrificed its character in that jump from working primarily on covers and that makes for a strong enough starting point for the limited series. There's always a chance that the thematic suggestions made here will be expanded upon in later issues as the world further opens up, but if not, it'll still look impressive regardless.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
Detective Comics (2016) #941

Sep 28, 2016

Orlando has been able to find a nice balance between the major players involved in the arc thus far, and that dynamic improves in this issue now the expository dialogue is out of the way and we’re into the thick of things. However, this issue could be a warning that the thick of things isn’t that thick. The creative team deliver a solid issue with strong action and some interesting character development, but the third issue of purely fighting the Monster Men may leave you wishing that Batman #8 shakes things up dramatically come October.

View Issue       View Full Review
5
Detective Comics (2016) #983

Jun 29, 2018

There's plenty of potential story on display, but little chance to dig into the more interesting avenues as it all gets swept up in the rush, as if it needs to be sped through in order to get everything packed into the space Hill's been given for this arc before the next team takes over.

View Issue       View Full Review
5
Dial H For Hero (2019) #1

Mar 28, 2019

If nothing else, it feels like Quinones is really pushing himself, and the second half of the issue is home to some of his more impressive pages, when someone finally has to Dial H for Hero.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Die #1

Dec 10, 2018

Die #1 is about what we carry with us in life, what we leave behind, and which of these will end up having more tragic implications as the echoes of adolescence reverberate through adulthood.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Die #5

Apr 5, 2019

The party puts their plan into action at the same time as the creative team of Die reveals what this series is really about. The result is a bold narrative gambit that would be impressive in its own right but unfolds in utterly gorgeous fashion as a result of the inimitable work of Stephanie Hans.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Doctor Strange (2015) #382

Dec 8, 2017

The bombshell at the end isn't as earth-shattering as you may have been led to believe, but everything else is enticing enough for that to not really matter.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Doctor Strange (2015) Annual #1

Sep 29, 2016

In both of these tales, the art and colors elevate this pair of safe but well-told stories, and should satisfy anyone looking for a piece of Strange to hold them over until the movie's imminent release.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
Doctor Who: The Thirteenth Doctor #2

Dec 10, 2018

There's room for improvement on a design level "" the settings could do with being a touch more visually interesting as proven by some mid-issue locations "" but in a series based on a licensed property, it's far easier to enjoy when the characters seem like themselves, even more so when Houser manages to multi-task and use the ensemble effectively, something which the show itself has struggled with.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Doom Patrol (2016) #4

Jan 27, 2017

Every scene throws a new idea out there resulting in some expansive world building which will make you want to explore every direction suggested, but at the same time you'll find it hard pressed to look away from the engrossing direction the book is currently heading in.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Doom Patrol (2016) #7

Jul 26, 2017

While other comes fall into repetitive narrative patterns or don't do enough to distance themselves from the rest of the market, Doom Patrol laughs in the face of these potential stumbling blocks, outright gleeful with the sheer magnitude of ideas it chucks out each and every issue.

View Issue       View Full Review
4
Doomsday Clock #6

Jul 26, 2018

It's an ultimately hollow reading experience that turns disappointing when taking the delays which have already affected the series into account, as it's going to be a while before they're able to work on something more intriguing.

View Issue       View Full Review
6
Dracula, Motherf**ker! OGN

Sep 18, 2020

Dracula, Motherf**ker goes on sale October 7. Find out more about the OGN from the writer herself in our recent interview with Alex de Campi.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Eternals (2021) #1

Jan 6, 2021

Eternals #1 is not just a fresh start for the creative team and for potential readers, but also for the Eternals themselves to define who they are.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Ether #1

Nov 17, 2016

Much like Boone within the context of the story, the audience is pulled out of Agartha by the final page, but craving another visit as soon as possible.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
Exiles (2018) #3

May 14, 2018

The ambition of the book, and how much ground it tries to cover, makes it hard to hate, but it's not hard to wonder how much better it would flow in an OGN format.

View Issue       View Full Review
1
Fallen Angels (2019) #3

Dec 13, 2019

Fallen Angels is a book that started off on the wrong foot and has subsequently stumbled with each following step.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
Fantastic Four (2018) #1

Aug 9, 2018

Not rushing to bring them back together is the right approach, one taken with care, yet it doesn't gel well with the Doctor Doom tale drawn by Simone Bianchi and Marco Russo, which speeds through resetting some of the Fantastic Four's surrounding status quo.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Farmhand #1

Jul 16, 2018

Guillory has an immense amount of control on this world, right down to the background gags, wrangling the various aspects together into a well-paced package.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
FCBD 2017: All-New Guardians of the Galaxy/Defenders #1

May 4, 2017

As a taster for Gerry Duggan, Aaron Kuder and Ive Svorcina's newly launched series, this Free Comic Book Day offering is like the escape from the Kiln in the first movie, but with the team dynamic of the second film.

View Issue       View Full Review
5
FCBD 2017: Riverdale #1

May 4, 2017

A prelude to the first season, Free Comic Book Day: Riverdale #1 unfortunately lacks the madcap energy of the show's first few episodes and instead offers a milquetoast vibe more in line with what you used to think of when you heard the word Archie.

View Issue       View Full Review
6
Finger Guns #2

Apr 6, 2020

Richards doesn’t completely lose sight of his lead characters’ dynamic in this sophomore effort - but that said, it’s noticeable how the first issue was more precise in when it introduced elements of its story and started to thread them together as a result. This second issue eventually gets back to Wes and Sadie’s growing connection as they talk and bond, only it’s far more truncated due to everything else going on. A lot of this likely comes down to the first issue having an increased page count compared to the standard 22 pages here, but that only further proves the point that Wes and Sadie’s story, wherever it might be going, clearly needs space.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
Firefly (2018) #1

Nov 16, 2018

It's a start, one that's able to get by on having the gang back together.

View Issue       View Full Review
6
Firefly (2018): Bad Company #1

Mar 21, 2019

Gordon's script is at its best dealing with the second half of that description as it shows her intending to take greater control of her life. It's a reminder of how engaging an element she can be in a story, and hopefully this means she'll be involved in Pak's sooner rather than later.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
Firefly (2018): The Outlaw Ma Reynolds #1

Jan 9, 2020

The issue doesn't wholly resolve this mother and son's complicated relationship, but does illustrate the compelling predicament the two find themselves in, as two soldiers with vastly different ideas about when the fighting stops.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Folklords #1

Nov 14, 2019

When the adventure gets going, the book's look shifts away from warm colors and towards the ominous, an apt visual depiction of the unknown ultimately is, while imploring you to join the quest.

View Issue       View Full Review
6
Friendly Neighborhood Spider-Man (2019) #5

Apr 11, 2019

Yildiray Cinar's linework has a moodier vibe to it than the sleekness of the previous issues by Juann Cabal, so it's curious as to why Taylor's script doesn't opt to wring out as much emotional potential as possible from the issue's initial premise. Even with the understanding this isn't the story's end, the book almost seems scared with dealing with what it's set up.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
Future State (2021): Catwoman #1

Jan 19, 2021

This is a sleek and kinetic issue, one that picks up with her plan already in motion " a train heist, with a twist " carried forth by the sheer energy found in Schmidt's artwork.

View Issue       View Full Review
6
Future State (2021): Superman of Metropolis #1

Jan 5, 2021

Across these three tales, the art is the strongest component of each with de Landro and Louise producing some dynamic pages that stand out the most through the combination of minimalist linework and sharp coloring. It would certainly be interesting to see how they could render Metropolis on a larger story after 'Future State' comes to an end.

View Issue       View Full Review
6
Future State (2021): Superman/Wonder Woman #1

Jan 12, 2021

The real issue with the book however is more how 'Future State' as a whole is functioning as it is unclear when this is happening in relation to its co-leads' other appearances, namely how this fits with what Jon did to Metropolis in his book last week. These series already have to move quickly to get their stories underway considering they're just a couple of issues long, but it'd be nice if they were able to take a minute in order to make the timeline clear and provide a better sense of its heroes' overall journeys.

View Issue       View Full Review
4
Future State (2021): The Flash #1

Jan 5, 2021

Are you a Flash fan? If so, make sure you've read the best Flash stories of all time.

View Issue       View Full Review
5
Future State (2021): Green Lantern #1

Jan 12, 2021

Ernie Altbacker's story is more light-hearted than the other two. It involves Guy Gardner getting stuck on a planet outside of his usual jurisdiction and how he spends his time waiting for his ring to fix itself. Of the three, this one starts at the right moment, allowing for a beginning, middle, and end, but the comedy is all one-note miscommunication jokes and gets stale fast, which means the issue goes out on its lowest note.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Future State (2021): Wonder Woman #1

Jan 5, 2021

The briskness and head-strong determination that she demonstrates throughout drives Future State: Wonder Woman #1 and is more than enough to warrant getting on board in order to follow her and see where she ends up.

View Issue       View Full Review
4
Future State (2021): Nightwing #1

Jan 19, 2021

With how much time is spent on this otherwise run-of-the-mill confrontation, Constant tips his hand too early in regard to there being something of later narrative importance happening within this sequence, and as a result, the rest of the issue reads as padding until he can give deliver one last switcheroo. There are a number of twists here and ultimately not a substantial enough story to support them.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
Future State (2021): Justice League #1

Jan 12, 2021

The narrative, which sees the team on the run, demonstrates Takara's strong grasp on each cast member's character and his skill in crafting plots that give them all something to contribute. If you've read any of Ram V's prior JLD issues, it's just as solid and enjoyable.

View Issue       View Full Review
4
Future State (2021): Green Lantern #2

Feb 9, 2021

The main story in Future State: Green Lantern #2 picks up in the midst of the ongoing planetary evacuation while John Stewart has been captured by the Khund cult, but Geoffrey Thorne's scripting never stirs any emotion.

View Issue       View Full Review
3
Future State (2021): Shazam! #2

Feb 18, 2021

There's been a good deal of pessimistic times presented in 'Future State,' but many of those have at least seen heroes taking a stand to try and better the world from getting any worse. Future State: Shazam #2 however, is resigned to the bleakness of the situation " even the body language of the characters reads as cold and at a remove from one another " and that dissonance between the chosen tone and what you'd expect for a Shazam story is a factor which the creative team proves unable to reconcile.

View Issue       View Full Review
5
Future State (2021): Superman: Worlds of War #2

Feb 18, 2021

Future State: Superman: Worlds of War #2 features one of his battles under Mongol's rule, giving Mikel Jann and Jordie Bellaire some close-quarters fighting to depict. The former's tight framing and the latter's use of red and similar colors capture the brutal tone well without coming across as too vicious.

View Issue       View Full Review
6
Future State (2021): Immortal Wonder Woman #2

Feb 16, 2021

While the primary creative team of Future State: Immortal Wonder Woman #2 are sure to follow through on the conflict between Superman and Darkseid which their opening salvo set-up, the strongest material from all involved comes as a result of the scenes which see Diana coming to terms with the end.

View Issue       View Full Review
6
Future State (2021): The Next Batman #2

Jan 19, 2021

There's plenty to like in Future State: The Next Batman #2, though it must be said upfront that the first issue's distinctive cyberpunk vibe is lacking " a result of Nick Derington and Tamra Bonvillain not handling the art of this issue's Tim Fox story.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
Future State (2021): Superman/Wonder Woman #2

Feb 9, 2021

Dan Watters' script is a stronger one than the previous issue's, precisely because it has more time for the central duo to share scenes and let these interactions further define their individual dynamics.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Generation Gone #3

Sep 21, 2017

Andr Lima Arajo and Chris O'Halloran bring a strong visual eye to the series, the opening scenes darts between the red and blues of the police and the more dialogue-driven scenes use unconventional framing, pushing characters to the edges, and sometimes the corners, of the panels, resulting in a distinctive look that ensure the series is looking to be its own thing rather than pure pastiche.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Generation X (2017) #2

Jun 5, 2017

This series is likely not what people expected it would be - it's very different to its namesake and is pretty abstract when compared to the rest of the X-lineup. When it comes to X-Men, it is particularly difficult to put together a team because every person has a different idea of what the X-Men should be. When it came to X-Men: Gold, I was struck by a tagline on an ad " "You asked for it. You got it" " as it seemed to suggest they were going with a straight superhero book because that's what was being demanded the most. That might be what people thought they wanted from the X-line, but Generation X is what never knew you needed.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Generation X (2017) #5

Aug 21, 2017

If some of the other ResurreXion titles have felt too homogenous for your taste, then take a chance on this one-shot that's willing to be this oddball.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Generation X (2017) #8

Nov 9, 2017

What makes Generation X so special is that writer Christina Strain can find the time to mention how annoying it is that Quentin Quire can pull off speedos without taking up vital space that'd be better served otherwise.

View Issue       View Full Review
4
Ghost Rider (2016) #3

Jan 27, 2017

Amadeus Cho and Laura Kinney are great characters, but they're pulling too much focus away from the titular hero and the ending of the issue suggests this problem will not only persist, but get worse, keeping the book in some unfortunate traction.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Giant Days #19

Oct 7, 2016

The trio's first year at university ended with many roads open for exploration and while it'll be pleasant to return to Sheffield next month, this is a delightful experience that most series would be hard pressed to provide.

View Issue       View Full Review
10
Giant Days #22

Jan 5, 2017

Giant Days has always been a ridiculously funny book, but it's also been capable of these heartfelt emotional beats. This is one of those issues that has a lasting emotional impact.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Giant Days #36

Mar 8, 2018

The issue plays like a season finale, everything that's been building over the past year comes to a head, including the fact that the core trio are moving out of the house they've shared during that time.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
Giant-Size X-Men (2020): Nightcrawler #1

Mar 27, 2020

The fact that Giant-Size X-Men was first intended to be annuals for the line becomes clearer with this Nightcrawler-titled one-shot.

View Issue       View Full Review
5
Giant-Size X-Men (2020): Jean Grey And Emma Frost #1

Feb 25, 2020

That detail shows how the past and current can work in tandem without the former holding the latter back. Beyond that, this is an issue of surface pleasures rather than a meaningful examination of the pair’s relationship right now, much less what’s been alluded to between them, Scott and Logan. Its final story beat lacks the wow factor of its influencing issue because it seems at odds with the new status quo and the direction it set up. Previous stories are always going to have a level of influence on current ones, but this is the most beholden that the Krakoa-era has been to looking back instead of prioritising moving forward.

View Issue       View Full Review
10
Glitterbomb #2

Oct 11, 2016

Followed up with a poignant essay by Hughes, it becomes clear that the sense of dread the book is imbued with doesn’t spring forth from the paranormal elements, but the reminders of normality taken directly from the real world. Everyone involved is crafting a tale that serves to show Hollywood isn’t as glamorous as the pictures make it out to be.

View Issue       View Full Review
10
Glitterbomb #3

Nov 9, 2016

I don’t believe these essays shouldn’t be defined as back matter, because that implies they’re only for the most dedicated of readers, nor do I consider it correct to label them as supplementary material because for the same reason. Instead they should be treated as required reading because not only are they poignant, but they ground the horror. The body horror might be the hook, but the most resonant idea is that the industry itself is a living nightmare for many. Without these essays, Zub, Hughes, Morissette-Phan, Marshall and Dillon wouldn’t be able to reinforce that there’s a truth to this book, and that’s the scariest thing of all.

View Issue       View Full Review
10
Glitterbomb #4

Dec 7, 2016

The real-world stuff has always been the more important thematic factor, but they seem more real now, something which can also be said about Holly Raychelle Hughes’ essay. In a way this makes Glitterbomb the book of 2016, in an ideal world we wouldn’t be at this point, but as a result, we have art like this to stand up and speak out. The series and creative team are taking a break until the back half of next year, operating like a TV show, but it’s guaranteed that this series will be something to think about until it returns.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Glitterbomb: The Fame Game #1

Sep 11, 2017

While not necessarily empowering, there's a transgressive slant to the narrative that'll likely have you hoping the supernatural horror wins out over the real-world horror.

View Issue       View Full Review
10
Glitterbomb: The Fame Game #2

Oct 26, 2017

Bolstered by the emotional artwork of Djibril Morissette-Phan and K. Michael Russell, so much is said through posture and positioning over explicit dialogue and makes Glitterbomb: The Fame Game one of the most powerful (and perhaps vital) books on the stands.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Green Lantern (2018) #1

Nov 9, 2018

From alien lifeforms and far-off planets to a quieter moment with Hal observing the sky, it is distinctive; a relic from a bygone era that feels fresh all the same.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Green Valley #6

Mar 9, 2017

Max Landis is a writer that has these out-of-the-box pitches, and that's certainly true of Green Valley, which debuted as a medieval tale and now encompasses dinosaurs. Another concept gets thrown in in this issue and similar to, Paper Girls, a lot of the fun stems from seeing how the pieces fit together.

View Issue       View Full Review
5
Guardians of the Galaxy (2019) #6

Jun 20, 2019

As a resolution, it's too small and too big at the same time, having qualities of big event storytelling and a more intimate character-driven story, each preventing the other the full space and time required for it to satisfyingly play out that way.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Hawkeye (2016) #1

Dec 14, 2016

Towards the end of the issue, Kate says that she can “actually make this whole P.I. thing work. Like work work.” This debut appears to be indicative that’s true. L.A. doesn’t feel like a single street where everything looks the same, Kate’s voice is as snarky as one would expect, the investigation isn’t as open and shut as initially perceived to be and this has all been achieved in twenty pages. From the evidence presented, this is certainly due to the synergy of the creative team who are already operating like a well-oiled machine. If anyone can make it work for longer than an arc, it’s these guys.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Hawkeye (2016) #2

Jan 5, 2017

Combined with the necessary detail of Leonardo Romero's work, how Jordie Bellaire switches up her previous colour set to match the setting and an impressive action sequence and you've got the book which continues to be the strongest of the new Marvel Now launches.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Hawkeye (2016) #5

Apr 5, 2017

Jessica Jones and Kate Bishop have some similarities. Obviously, they’re both private investigators and their snark registers on a magnitude that would cause Professor Frink’s sarcasm detector to explode, but they also have different energies. Jess is more unfiltered, while Kate is a little more willing to hold off and get the lay of the land before going in guns a-blazing. So it takes a lot to make those energies meld together, and here it’s a triumph with regards to the writing of Kelly Thompson and the art of Michael Walsh and Jordie Bellaire that they're able to pull it off so well. In short: this issue really is the best of both worlds.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Hawkeye (2016) #13

Dec 11, 2017

When the first issue of the series released back in December 2016, I deemed it “fully realized” right out of the gate - and perhaps even more miraculously, the creative team has only built it up further since then. Just as much as the team excels on a macro scale, there’s no shortage of impressive moments on a micro-level, like the way a knife thrown travels along a traceable arc across panels. Hawkeye bounds along, but cleanly enough that it’s easy to scour for these kinds of details, proving it an achievement of craft and joy in equal measure.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Hawkeye: Freefall #3

Feb 14, 2020

Rosenberg's scenarios are a wonderful match for Schmidt's scratchy linework " his figures are so expressive and nimble throughout.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
Heroes In Crisis #1

Sep 26, 2018

To return to looking at the cover image again, take note off where Sanctuary is positioned, off in the distance. For all the in-universe references, let alone interviews and promotional material, the issue only provides glimpses at the location. A result of this first installment's deliberate structuring, which offers just a peek at the series' true self and so it remains to be seen if Heroes in Crisis is up to handling this concept and the accompanying ideas with as much respect and care as they require.

View Issue       View Full Review
2
Heroes In Crisis #9

May 30, 2019

When it comes to Mann and Tomeu Morey's art, it's just as tactile as previous issues, the level of clarity and detail brought to each panel is an artistic approach that could've been utilized so much better if it was allowed to focus in on the more tender, heartfelt and emotional material that the book hasn't really dealt with.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Hi-Fi Fight Club #3

Oct 26, 2017

Hi-Fi Fight Club is simply a top-tier delight, and the laid-back approach of the series is enough to wish it had more than an issue to go before being done.

View Issue       View Full Review
5
High Level #2

Mar 21, 2019

Other page filling images, one while on the road and another from up high, offer a glimpse of the larger world, suggest more depth than the plotting, that there might be something worth seeing on the horizon and are the main reason to stick around despite a mediocre start.

View Issue       View Full Review
4
History of the Marvel Universe (2019) #2

Aug 23, 2019

One can appreciate the lesser-known details of continuity it ropes in along the way, like a reference to the Gibborim that features on the same page as one related to Peter Parker and the establishing of S.H.I.E.L.D, but it never seems in service of a deeper point than noting that one event happened after another.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
Home Sick Pilots #1

Dec 4, 2020

The structure of Home Sick Pilots #1 might not be the ideal way to sell its premise, but the design and energy go a long way in selling you on the tone and milieu to make up for that.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
Hulk (2016) #3

Feb 24, 2017

It's also a more conventional book in terms of layouts from Nico Leon " there's a couple of pages which fit the aesthetic of the book prior, but there's a greater number of recognisable layouts utilised by many artists.

View Issue       View Full Review
6
Hulkverines #2

Mar 28, 2019

Greg Pak knows why you're here " to see Hulk, Wolverine and Weapon H get into some fisticuffs, whether they be amongst themselves, against the Leader, or against everyone else in their way. So he wastes no time, as when this issue first shows Clay and Logan, the former is already diving towards the latter, both have their claws extended already.

View Issue       View Full Review
5
Hunt For Wolverine: Dead Ends #1

Aug 30, 2018

Dead Ends' vagueness about what's to come is an ineffective story hook, as the build-up and teasing seems never-ending.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Immortal Hulk #4

Aug 2, 2018

Bennett's characters are rarely shown in full, with panels that can never seem to contain them, and this visual grammar affords this character study a terrifying combination of intimacy and claustrophobia.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Immortal Hulk #7

Oct 11, 2018

There's clearly a larger plan at play, and each installment works towards this without just promising the good stuff is on its way.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Immortal Hulk #21

Jul 26, 2019

Ewing's script here is more clinical than grotesque, yet still manages to include one heck of a body horror concept that's sure to come back in a future issue.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
Infamous Iron Man (2016) #1

Oct 24, 2016

Infamous Iron Man #1 isn't an explosive issue, and its subdued nature puts it in line with International Iron Man and the final few issues of Invincible Iron Man - which is actually a good thing as this doesn't feel like a dramatic departure from what came before. But one can only wonder if it would have been better with an explosive plot point to get people intrigued and talking.

View Issue       View Full Review
5
Infinity Countdown #4

Jun 7, 2018

It's always disappointing to see when a series, already designed as both build-up and lead-in for an upcoming event, has to slow down and noticeably move pieces around the board in preparation.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Invaders (2019) #2

Feb 28, 2019

Editor's notes remark about this building off a recent Avengers arc, but prior reading is unnecessary as Zdarsky puts the work into showing what the team was like in wartime compared to now they're at odds, and in demonstrating the mental effects it can have on one's psyche.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Invincible Iron Man (2016) #2

Dec 22, 2016

The majority of Bendis' work on the various Iron Man titles has been strong up until this point and here he appears to have found a story he can dig deeper with, even more so than International Iron Man.

View Issue       View Full Review
6
Jean Grey #3

Jun 29, 2017

Hypothetically, fights under the sea are more appealing than pure conversation, but in reality, it's disappointing to see Jean's inner monologue start to fade, even if it's replaced by sea monsters taking up the page.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Jessica Jones #1

Oct 10, 2016

Alias #1 set the tone for this world. The seedy underbelly of New York where people dropped f-bombs instead of gamma bombs, characters were repulsed by the abhorrent tendencies of the villains instead of blasting the villains with repulsors and where a hero could take a moment away from the public eye, but find themselves in the gaze of a private eye. Jessica Jones #1 reestablishes this world and it's aesthetic before setting the scene for an intensely personal conflict for Jessica Jones. This issue by no means gives you all the information, but it certainly gives you enough to get hooked all over again.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
Jessica Jones #2

Nov 17, 2016

Following up on an astounding first issue, Jessica Jones digs into the past like a private eye should and it pays off in some ways, while causing the issue to stumble in others.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Jessica Jones #6

Mar 9, 2017

As much as it carved a niche for itself, Jessica Jones continues to feel like another issue of Alias in part due to Michael Gaydos and Matt Hollingsworth's consistency. They shine in this element as much as they did back in the early 2000s and have brought some new flourishes with them here, like the explosion of color when characters get hit, marking the impact.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Justice League (2016) #34

Dec 6, 2017

Maybe I'm grading on a curve after the past 11 months, but when considering just first issues, this is the most exciting iteration of the League since Morrison's.

View Issue       View Full Review
6
Justice League (2018) #59

Mar 16, 2021

It's a case of a thin main story and a back-up that shows what can be done with a little. Bendis's pacing has become more relaxed as his career has gone on; nevertheless, it is still surprising to see him be so upfront with a thesis by putting it on the first page and not manage to take it further than this. Still, after a few years where the title has been a somewhat impenetrable series as a result of Scott Snyder's big plans, Justice League #59 is a much easier jumping-on point for new readers. Just they might find it lacking in reasons to stay on board.

View Issue       View Full Review
5
Justice League Dark (2018) #4

Oct 17, 2018

Taken in conjunction with the Manitou Dawn body horror moment mentioned earlier, the pair's ability to shift scale is clear. But the issue as a whole reads as a bit too vague and large-scale, with the extensive action overshadowing the idea about the price and weight of magic.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Justice League Dark (2018) Annual #1

Aug 1, 2019

Carried along by an undercurrent of sorrow, Ram V's scripting of the story he and Tynion IV co-wrote deals with how the new guardian gradually comes to terms with the limits of their new powers, unaware that their transformation cements there is no going back to the way things were. Any moments of hope that occur become consumed by the realization that they're not built to last.

View Issue       View Full Review
5
Justice League of America (2017) #4

Apr 14, 2017

While I still prefer this book to its sister Justice League title, Justice League of America hasn't done enough to define itself as the better team book of the two.

View Issue       View Full Review
5
Justice League vs. Suicide Squad #1

Dec 22, 2016

With any luck, the bookends to this issue will quickly come into play and shake up the event, but if the paneling remains as rigid and Williamson's dialogue remains at this level of nuance, it's going to be a long six issues.

View Issue       View Full Review
6
Justice League vs. Suicide Squad #3

Jan 5, 2017

Maybe the second half of this event will drastically change the game and there'll be surprises abound, but right now it feels a lot like Night of the Monster Men did when we kept hoping there was more to it, only to find out this is all it is.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
Kamandi Challenge #1

Jan 27, 2017

If the series is going to continue in this manner, then the only thing you can expect is that you won't truly know what to expect.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Kill Or Be Killed #4

Nov 17, 2016

As a conclusion to the arc, it sets David down a path he'll find it hard-pressed to return from, while also setting up characters and narrative arcs for the future which are sure to haunt Dylan just as much as the demon on his back.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Kill Them All #1

Oct 2, 2017

It's a blast, and like the most beloved of 1990's action cinema, something that you're sure to go through, or even just skip to your favorite parts, over and over again.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
King In Black: Black Knight #1

Feb 3, 2021

Thanks to a strong take on Dane and his mythology, the creative team doesn't just deconstruct him over the course of the issue but are also sure to start building him back up so the upcoming Black Knight limited series can take him in a new direction.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
King of Nowhere #1

Mar 9, 2020

W. Maxwell Prince, Tyler Jenkins, and Hilary Jenkins craft a woozy first issue where it's easy to give into the flow of the story's direction. Events and locations flow into one another in such a way that make Nowhere a real, connected place, albeit one that seems to operate on a subconscious understanding of arriving somewhere without much recollection of how you did.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Kingpin (2017) #1

Feb 9, 2017

The name of the book may be Kingpin, but writer Matthew Rosenberg looks beyond this, instead choosing to focus on who Wilson Fisk is besides a crime boss.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
Little Bird #3

May 16, 2019

The main draw and reason for recommending Little Bird is to see the fruit of Ian Bertram and Matt Hollingsworth's collaboration.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Lois Lane (2019) #2

Aug 8, 2019

Not only does this book provide a human perspective on a world of superheroes, the noir tone shows it as one with something to be uncovered and potentially turned upside down as a result.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Lost on Planet Earth #1

Apr 15, 2020

One standout moment is Basil grappling with her doubts, as she stands as the center of four panels while the world carries on around her. But another standout follows shortly after as the thematic flip side - a full-page depiction of the world as possibilities open up for Basil, as Aguirre renders the open space and the freedom of discovery as something that’s utterly terrifying. Basil’s spent so long focusing on today, and now she has no idea what tomorrow will bring - but if the first installment of Lost on Planet Earth is any indication, this sci-fi slice-of-life adventure has a whole universe of potential ahead of it.

View Issue       View Full Review
5
Man-Eaters #1

Sep 28, 2018

Coupled with an art style that can serve sight gags as well as horror-orientated pages, this should be a home run, only it falters when it comes to how much actual narrative is on the page.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Marauders (2019) #1

Oct 28, 2019

In other words — Marauders, you had me at “ahoy.”

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Martian Manhunter (2018) #1

Dec 10, 2018

Based on this first part, Steve Orlando has lofty ambitions for the series, using this book as opportunity to contrast what J'onn J'onzz was like as a Manhunter on Mars, to how John Jones is as a homicide cop in Colorado; as well as how life on Earth differs to that on Mars, and crucially, the ways in which they are the same.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Midnighter And Apollo #3

Dec 12, 2016

Complete with a tender moment from Midnighter, this series is everything it could possibly be and more, as Midnighter and Apollo packs both a physical and emotional punch.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Mighty Morphin' Power Rangers (2016) #9

Dec 1, 2016

Kyle Higgins and Hendry Prasetya pull off the mighty feat of setting the table for the upcoming third act of this year-long narrative, while also continuing to drive the story forward without letting its momentum slow.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
Mighty Morphin' Power Rangers (2016) #17

Jul 24, 2017

The portion of downtime is unfortunately the weakest part of the issue from an art perspective, suffering from a lack of detail in places, but this sentiment doesn't linger for long as Higgins gets back to the big stuff in an issue which allows you to jump-on and take a cursory glance and what this series is looking to do moving forward.

View Issue       View Full Review
10
Mister Miracle (2017) #1

Aug 9, 2017

The creative team might be anxious about where the world is heading - that sentiment is distilled into every facet of the story - but they've taken that apprehension and a desire to interrogate it and poured it into a fantastical and contemporary tale, one with a confidence that feels excitingly era-defining.

View Issue       View Full Review
10
Mister Miracle (2017) #2

Sep 18, 2017

This issue feels even more rhythmic than the last, through Clayton Cowles' word-balloon placement enhancing the more melodic segments, as the inclusion of more characters and aspects help it to build further momentum and hint at what's really going on without throwing the audience off its relatively stable footing.

View Issue       View Full Review
10
Mister Miracle (2017) #3

Oct 16, 2017

King, Gerads and Cowles are interrogating this world - while still being respectful of Jack "The King" Kirby - digging into the core of New Genesis and Apokolips, planets ruled by gods and fuelled by the exploitation of slave armies to unearth the harsh realities of both. They've already found plenty of rich veins, and there's still so many left to mine as the series continues.

View Issue       View Full Review
10
Mister Miracle (2017) #4

Nov 13, 2017

Mister Miracle #4 is the series at its most absurd. Largely a one-location play with much of the action (and inaction) taking place in Scott and Barda's apartment. It blends an extended gag about a veggie plate with another involving an impending delivery and the issue's primary focus: Scott Free's trial at the hands of Orion. It's also a comic book where this highly pressing concern is also juxtaposed about the day-to-day struggle of getting out of bed, something which many know all too well.

View Issue       View Full Review
10
Mister Miracle (2017) #5

Dec 14, 2017

Working with King and Cowles, this issue's nine-panel grid dictates the content, and in these cases, the creative team has to create a space in the first panel that works for the rest of the page, packing in every detail and nuance they can. Time appears to be inescapable, but Gerads makes the moments beautiful while they last.

View Issue       View Full Review
10
Mister Miracle (2017) #6

Jan 12, 2018

Even as the walls are closing in around Barda and Scott, the incredibly creative team of King, Gerads and Cowles have never felt freer to be formally daring.

View Issue       View Full Review
10
Mister Miracle (2017) #7

Mar 15, 2018

While the first arc began with near-death, the second starts on the cusp of new life, which makes for some dynamite juxtaposition. Despite this difference, the series retains its wry and sardonic tone as it marries comedy and almost-tragedy.

View Issue       View Full Review
10
Mister Miracle (2017) #10

Aug 2, 2018

This issue is everything the series has been previously "" defined by its nine-panel grids, stunning rendered by artist Mitch Gerads and King's concoction of gallows humor, poignant conversation and brief observations on Earth's mundanities; sometimes all at once.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Mother Panic #1

Nov 10, 2016

The latest Young Animal book to debut might be set in Gotham and deal with common scenarios you'd expect from a book set there, like socialite parties and gang violence, but make no mistake - this is not a Bat-family title.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Motor Crush #5

Apr 14, 2017

For a series that has been vibrant thus far, the use of black and white for these flashbacks is striking, and the vibrancy is made up for tenfold in the present day when the Dark Rider resurfaces.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Mr. and Mrs. X #1

Jul 25, 2018

That’s always proclaimed as the tricky thing about marrying characters off. The idea that on-off relationships are easier to write because they run on drama and possible tension, but after a while, the ebb and flow transitions into just going through the motions, never seeking to change it up. (Especially in superhero comic books, where the looming threats of stagnation and the status quo are already well established.) This doesn’t mean that this issue serves as concrete proof that Rogue and Gambit can never be unhappy again, or have no difficulties to face in their future, but that they can get through it together.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
Ms. Marvel (2015) #33

Sep 5, 2018

There’s a couple of pages around the midpoint that get more out there, both in story purpose and imagery, with Herring in particular being able to craft a striking page with a dramatically different colour palette to the one they traditionally use on the book. For the most part, however, Ms. Marvel #33 is a solid issue that’s never anything less than engaging - one that delivers what long-term readers expect from this book as well one that can give new readers a taste of what the series is like. The book deserves commendation for being able to be that, after more than 50 issues. That length of run is rare these days and so having one that continues to be worth reading is worth treasuring, even the story potential isn’t always completely capitalized on.

View Issue       View Full Review
5
Mystik U #1

Nov 29, 2017

Ultimately, Mystik U is a disappointment because it doesn't do enough to define itself beyond a familiar premise. Without its prologue, there'd be little to suggest something different is on the way and that shouldn't be happening with this kind of book. One unbound by continuity and with twice the page count of what other writers are generally granted per issue.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
Nancy Drew (2018) #1

Jun 11, 2018

Based on all this evidence, Nancy Drew appears to be a book where the creative team have clicked very early on in the process, which was true of Hawkeye as well. What prevents this from being as successful of a debut is in how it trades in similar ideas, structure and mysteries. Thompson handled them well previously, but seeing them crop up so soon after prompts a degree of hesitation that she’s returning to the same well so soon. Though the narration of this series is already self-reflexive, so she’s likely aware of this and knows not to go down the same avenue of investigation once more. Returning home to confront the past is already a difficult enough thing to do in and of itself.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
New Mutants (2019) #5

Jan 9, 2020

Jonathan Hickman's writing on New Mutants is him in full goofball mode, more in line with that issue of Future Foundation where Peter Parker and Johnny Storm (and Annihilus) were roommates than the overall seriousness of his Avengers work and a step further than the glimpses of lightness found in the flagship X-Men series.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
New Mutants: Dead Souls #4

Jun 18, 2018

Even if superhero comic books can never truly end, this issue is exemplary of how they’re still capable of showing how far some characters have come and how they’re affected by those who didn’t make it that far. It’s an issue much like Buffy the Vampire Slayer’s “The Body”, so calibrated on every wavelength to understanding the harshness of what leads to grief, how differently it can manifest in everyone. That’s a weighty goal, some media properties can dedicate their entire existence to exploring it, but Rosenberg, Gorham, Garland, and Clayton Cowles –– whose work here shifts the space between balloons into uncomfortable silence - offer a succinct summation on the nature of it.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
New Talent Showcase: 2016 #1

Nov 30, 2016

There should be something here that appeals to you, if not one story in particular, then the opportunity to sample the work of numerous creators to see if there’s someone you want to keep an eye on. Not all of the stories come together or conclude in the pages provided, and it would have been preferred that they did, but regardless New Talent Showcase #1 is a tantalizing glimpse at the up-and-comers that DC has been able to scout out thus far with the program that suggests there are some new and bold voices about to make a splash, but need a little more polishing before they’re perfect.

View Issue       View Full Review
6
Nightwing (2016) #6

Oct 7, 2016

While Nightwing makes for a more tense issue of the series as the walls seem to close in on the Bat-family, the attempt to up the stakes falls flat due to it just being a larger monster

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Nightwing (2016) #18

Apr 6, 2017

Fans of Grant Morrison's Bat-run will find a lot to love here as Dick and Damian team up to face Professor Pyg and some Dollotrons in order to save Dick's girlfriend Shawn. The past and present Robins had an immediately engrossing dynamic within Morrison's Batman and Robin, and Tim Seeley retains the playfulness and snark that's been part of that since the start.

View Issue       View Full Review
5
Nightwing (2016) #44

May 3, 2018

The rest of the arc will hopefully flesh out the particulars and make the appropriate bug fixes, but this first issue seems flawed on a conceptual level.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
No One's Rose #1

Mar 30, 2020

Writers Emily Horn and Zac Thompson offer narration that posits man's relationship with nature as a symbiotic one " we help it survive so we can as well, no altruism attached. Artist Alberto Jimenez-Albuquerque and colorist Ral Angulo present a desolate world of dilapidated buildings that could topple over at any moment, with gray and patchy land and crackling lightning.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
Nova (2016) #1

Dec 12, 2016

For a book that includes Richard Rider on what is essentially his big return to the Marvel universe, Nova #1 includes very little of him. Instead Jeff Loveness and Ramn Prez choose to spend the bulk of the issue with Sam Alexander tracking him through a space-faring adventure with Ego, through to school day mishaps. As a result, the balance that should come from having a primary cast of two space cops isn't there yet, but appears to be fast approaching.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
Nova (2016) #6

May 4, 2017

Once the recap is over, it starts to get back up to speed, but it's no longer rocketing towards the finale as much as it felt it was a month ago.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
November #2

Jun 3, 2020

As much as the multiple perspectives craft captivating glimpses of the city as everything goes to hell, what brings it all to life is the revelatory pairing of Charretier and Hollingsworth. The definition the two provide the characters is so sharp. Moments involving heavy shadow or shading manage to accentuate this even further, highlighting each character's expressive facial features.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Occupy Avengers #5

Mar 30, 2017

Like Fargo's second season without the snow, there's a lot going on and it's easy to immerse yourself in the story without feeling like the threads are purely tangential.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Occupy Avengers #9

Jul 31, 2017

Comic books are static, panels work as single moments, but there's a sense of motion in their work. It's clear how characters moved to reach the position in the current panel and where they're heading next. This dynamic art in combination with Walker's kinetic and resonant script does enough to ensure that the comic flows even as characters travel a great distance in a scene transition, but you'll also realise once you come to the final page, that they've done enough to ensure that even if Occupy Avengers comes to a close in that moment, it's not the end. The fight goes on and there's a good chance we can win. Together.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Old Guard #1

Feb 22, 2017

This raid is representative of The Old Guard. Meticulously researched, planned and executed with precision. This sharpness ensures that this book is just as impactful of a release this far into Greg Rucka’s career as it would be if it were his debut. While using ideas he’s written about before, it’s his familiarity with them that means he uses them exceptionally well, with a new angle of approach instead of looking at the same way he has prior.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
Once & Future #3

Oct 18, 2019

Artist Dan Mora and colorist Tamra Bonvillain have proven to be a match made in heaven. Their work is textured and rich with expression - even a wide shot with scratchy linework for characters conveys their emotions.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
Once & Future #13

Nov 19, 2020

Once & Future #13 might start a new arc and provide a strong sense of what the book is in the process, but it's not a jumping-on point. It builds on what the first 12 issues have done and gets to work setting up for the ones that'll follow. Even when telling a relatively quiet part of the story " and even if that narrative doesn't hit the same levels of depth that Gillen's name might presume " Mora and Bonvillain are granted ample opportunity to dazzle and show off what they can do.

View Issue       View Full Review
3
Pearl #1

Aug 16, 2018

That the meet-cute between two tattoo artists which kicks off Pearl feels forced and strained is a worrying sign, because not only does result in the dialogue being a chore to read, but the sluggish narrative of this installment is unengaging as well.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Peter Cannon: Thunderbolt (2019) #2

Feb 28, 2019

"I...created a dragon once. An experiment. I didn't pursue it." It is dialogue like this which cements Peter Cannon to be the latest, great main character from Kieron Gillen.

View Issue       View Full Review
10
Peter Cannon: Thunderbolt (2019) #3

Apr 1, 2019

There’s even a moment that plays to this reviewer as a reference to Jonathan Hickman’s work with the Avengers, and as with all these references, Peter Cannon: Thunderbolt balances a deep respect for these iconic tales and what came before with a story that’s directly about the breaking of rules. Though even with these grander allusions at play, it never forgets the humanity at its core, brief moments of mourning and melancholy; what our protagonist version of Cannon doesn’t say to this other dimension’s version of Tabu. Instances like this make the characters more than just mouthpieces, and it’s a miracle that Peter Cannon: Thunderbolt packs as many ideas as it does into 20 pages and still has space for beats like this.

View Issue       View Full Review
10
Peter Parker: The Spectacular Spider-Man (2017) #310

Sep 28, 2018

Complete with a wordless sequence that lands an emotional gut-punch through the art alone, a result of Zdarsky laying the groundwork prior, he has such a clearly understandable sense of who Spidey is and it's all the more powerful as a final statement for him knowing when he doesn't have to say anything.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Powers of X #3

Aug 23, 2019

This issue isn't as heady as previous issues from the outset, but still manages to recontextualize everything that's come before by the end and it's simply thrilling to read something that manages to shake proceedings up so drastically as a result of its structure.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Powers of X #6

Oct 10, 2019

With Dawn of X on the imminent horizon, the final issue of Powers of X remains true to the ethos of previous issues, in so much that it manages to recontextualize plenty of what's come before in addition to paving a road towards a bold, new future.

View Issue       View Full Review
6
Punisher Kill Krew #2

Sep 12, 2019

It's a goofy concept and so he plays it up, taking it as far as he can push it (read: includes a robot shark) in order to write an outlandish action romp.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
Queen Of Bad Dreams #2

May 30, 2019

Danny Lore's script is right to dig into these two characters via their conversation, that Wei doesn't do much legwork in her investigation works in the book's favor, as it allows more space for characterization rather than letting the worldbuilding pile up.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Quicksilver: No Surrender #5

Sep 6, 2018

Saladin Ahmed's scripting is blunt in its thematics, making Quicksilver's emotional journey overt, though the approach works well considering the character is essentially fighting himself.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Rogue & Gambit (2018) #5

May 3, 2018

Given the success of this creative team, it's ultimately disappointing they won't be able carry on developing Rogue & Gambit further.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Romulus #2

Dec 1, 2016

This might have been one of the more low-key releases to come from Image Comics in recent months, but Hill and Blake have kept the quality consistent from the first issue to the second as it heads further down the rabbit hole, and that consistency is enough of a reason this should be on your radar.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
Royals #1

Apr 6, 2017

What makes this stand out is the cold open for the book taking place five thousand years into the future with gleaming buildings and wall-hanging cocoons. He gradually introduces the core cast of characters, a technique which has become a trademark of his writing and there's something to be said how he's honed this as his career has blossomed.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
Runaways (2017) #4

Dec 14, 2017

Enter Molly Hayes " she's a total delight.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Runaways (2017) #12

Aug 30, 2018

Put simply, the issue looks great, everyone sounds as they should, and even 12 issues into the run, it's hard to believe exactly how strong this team's reunion has been.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
S.W.O.R.D. (2020) #1

Dec 10, 2020

While the book is predominately based on the station, the glimpses of what lies beyond are even more visually ravishing. The art team is already proving to be a strong match for the series' thematic concerns.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Sabrina the Teenage Witch (2019) #3

Jun 24, 2019

Even as it moves between genres, from horror to teen drama and even finding time for a spot of romance along the way, those transitions never come with a sense of whiplash. In fact, it feels as natural as the way the color of the sky can shift on a magical night.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Sabrina: Something Wicked #2

Apr 30, 2020

As Sabrina walks home later in her day, the atmosphere is colored by some less radiant hues that cast the ordinary streets with shadows of her other world. The two palettes are merging more and more with each passing day, and there's likely no means of separation at this point. Taken with the quote I opened this review with, Sabrina is finding herself in a major crux in her life, and the creative team have found multiple ways of indicating this both visually and narratively within their story.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Savage Town #1

Aug 28, 2017

The team have created a rich world around a familiar narrative archetype, but considering their desire to tell more tales, it's a solid start for Shalvey's long-form storytelling, and hopefully a fitting prologue for more Savage Town in the future.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Scarlet Witch #12

Nov 7, 2016

Which is what this book was structured around in a nutshell. Not only does this issue continue the trend of spotlighting artists, some well-known, others which will hopefully become known, but it also provides closure on Wanda's quest that's driven her in these first 12 issues. This issue is lighter on the magic than others, but delivers on the thematic content about family to really drive home the point about this chapter of Wanda's life being resolved meaning those emotional beats hit as intended. These past experiences have caused Wanda to grow as a person, and keeping these fresh in her mind, she's ready to walk the Witches' Road and see where it leads. There's no doubt that you should be following it as well.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
Secret Empire #0

Apr 19, 2017

So, Secret Empire #0 is devastating, but if the idea of this whole storyline involving Steve Rogers is devastating to you, and that feeling is only amplified when this story tries to say something about the world, while simultaneously shying away from those implicit real-world implications, then this tale about one of the darkest days in the Marvel Universe likely won't land as intended. Regardless, we have to hope that it's always darkest before the dawn, right?

View Issue       View Full Review
6
Secret Empire #3

Jun 1, 2017

If Secret Empire has one thing going for it, it's that the pacing is precise. Even as more threads get strung together, to the point where it's not easy to quickly sum up what's going on, Nick Spencer never spends too long away from them or too long on them to distract from others.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Secret Weapons #2

Jul 24, 2017

Limited series don't last forever, so it's always rewarding to see one like Secret Weapons come together as quickly as it has.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Secret Weapons #4

Sep 21, 2017

By all means, the miniseries has been strong enough to warrant getting excited for whatever that may be, but the dynamics of Secret Weapons have been so strong that I want to spend more time with the group right now.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Serenity: No Power In The 'Verse #1

Oct 28, 2016

The character dynamics are just as banter-filled as what's come before, but some newer ones develop, like River and Emma, the daughter of Wash and Zoe. It's a little slower in setting up the main narrative of the miniseries, but lays the thematic foundation for it to build upon.

View Issue       View Full Review
4
Seven Secrets #1

Aug 17, 2020

Reading the word "secret" so many times in the space of 24 pages led me to think about the briefcase in Pulp Fiction. As the McGuffin of the story, what's inside intrigues Jules and Vincent, not to mention the many people who have come up with theories about the cause of the glow. Tarantino, however, knows choosing not to divulge the answer allows it to hold greater thematic potential for any given reading. Seven Secrets #1 falls headfirst into that problem by being so intently focused on its namesake, and by proxy, offering little insight into the kind of the story this series will tell going forward. Which begs the question: when everything is kept a secret, what is ultimately revealed?

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Seven to Eternity (2016) #2

Oct 28, 2016

If you're familiar with Remender's work, you'll notice some familiar elements, but it's still compelling in this new world.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Sex Criminals #28

Mar 27, 2020

The tightness of his formalism makes the contrast found in the last few pages' craziness work even better, and with the pair still firing on all cylinders, it'll be interesting to see where they go in the final few issues.

View Issue       View Full Review
5
Shazam! (2018) #1

Dec 10, 2018

After a few years of the character lying dormant, Geoff Johns finally gets around to writing that Shazam series" and it's hard not to wonder how many other creators would've been able to deliver a more interesting take.

View Issue       View Full Review
6
Southern Bastards #20

May 14, 2018

Southern Bastards #20 is not an issue built on catharsis and resolution for either its characters and readers, but knowing that doesn't mean it doesn't mean it stings any less.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Spider-Woman (2015) #17

Mar 30, 2017

Spider-Woman gets a warmer ending than Black Widow this week as she decides to throw a party in the down time she can spare and encompasses how this series has excelled by going against the grain of being a superhero book or even a detective story.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
Star Wars (2014) #23

Oct 3, 2016

Hampered by a change from the high gear of last year to cruise control and some inconsistent art, Star Wars #23 is certainly enjoyable, but finds it impossible to shake the idea something doesn't sit right.

View Issue       View Full Review
6
Star Wars (2014) #38

Nov 9, 2017

While not as a big a triumph as Darth Vader felt from the outset, Gillen nails the most important building block with his handling of the core trio of Han, Luke, and Leia, as they travel to Jedha (or what's left of it after the events of Rogue One) in their search for a new base, while the Empire are there in search of kyber crystals.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
Star Wars (2014) #68

Jul 11, 2019

Let's get the obvious out of the way first " Star Wars #68 is drawn by Phil Noto, so of course it looks gorgeous.

View Issue       View Full Review
6
Star Wars (2014) Annual #3

Sep 25, 2017

This is ostensibly a variation on the tale that's always being told about Han and Leia during this time period and because the confines of said period are starting to show themselves, it can't help but feel more like a bug than it is a feature. Still is isn't forgettable because of the visual approach that comes from Walsh's art which at least has the benefit of granting it distance from Aaron's run. It's just that it's an expected story, and it's hard to blame someone for expecting one that's a little different.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Star Wars: Darth Vader #25

Oct 14, 2016

The issue caps off the run with an intriguing set-up for Gillen's next Star Wars project, as well as a coda with art by Max Fiumara that relates to Issue #1, bringing the series full circle both narratively and thematically.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Star Wars: Doctor Aphra #1

Dec 12, 2016

Complete with a back-up that reunites Gillen with Darth Vader artist Salvador Larroca, this issue is a strong debut that kicks off the initial digging into the nefarious archaeologist's past.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Star Wars: Poe Dameron #14

May 4, 2017

While it may not have an oversized issue to extend this vibe, it is instead strengthened by the presence of General Leia Organa (and by being written by Charles Soule following Carrie Fisher's death). It allows the story, and the Resistance at large, to catch their breath and remember the good times.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Star-Lord (2016) #1

Dec 22, 2016

All of this means that Star-Lord has a strong foundation, is within the creative team's wheelhouse and doesn't suggest they'll be going back over already covered ground.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Star-Lord (2016) Annual #1

May 25, 2017

It's not the way you may expect this run to end, especially on which scene Zdarsky chooses to say farewell, but that unexpectedness, while not hilarious, lands in much the same way Zdarsky's more

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Steeple #2

Oct 18, 2019

Even with this being the least of the comics Allison has written this year " that might be more of a compliment towards their greatness " Steeple still perfectly conveys his sensibilities.

View Issue       View Full Review
6
Strange Skies Over East Berlin #3

Dec 5, 2019

The real reason for sticking with Strange Skies over East Berlin is to witness artist Lisandro Estherren's scratchy, yet textured linework. What he can make a character say with their eyes alone is more effective than any other aspect of the book so far.

View Issue       View Full Review
5
Suicide Squad (2016) #2

Sep 19, 2016

Three issues in, Suicide Squad's biggest crime might simply be that it hasn't really done anything new yet. The additions to the team could result in that, but the series has been hindered by the unfortunate combo of being decompressed and not having a full issue to tell a story. There's a reason that John Ostrander's run is revered so long after it was first published, but almost everyone that's been on the book this decade has tried to be Ostrander, but with less of an edge. If Williams' reveal had been at the end of the first issue, I could see myself sticking around and wondering where it goes, but at this point, readers might be forgiven if they've already lost interest.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Super Sons (2017) #7

Aug 17, 2017

It's solid superhero storytelling with the boundless energy of a young cast to give it that extra spark.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Supergirl (2016) #2

Oct 14, 2016

This and Kara's interactions at home help to build a slice-of-life or young adult spine to the book, assisted by Brian Ching and Mike Atiyeh who get the chance to capture incredibly powerful beings in action, but also in their downtime.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
Supergirl (2016) #7

Mar 13, 2017

While the book's general structure may result in Orlando returning to this every so often, it's just disappointing to see that it doesn't get a chance to reach the natural, and expected stopping point within the covers of this issue.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Supergirl (2016) #19

Mar 15, 2018

While a story about how a superhero can impact one specific person is nothing new, a high level of craft ensures that Supergirl #19 soars.

View Issue       View Full Review
6
Supergirl (2016) #21

Aug 9, 2018

New writer Marc Andreyko's script can be heavy on the exposition in putting her on her new path, but much of this interaction also displays a strong understanding of Kara's character.

View Issue       View Full Review
6
Supergirl (2016) Annual #1

Aug 31, 2017

The general idea is strong, the action has weight and Orlando's characterization of Kara is a joy, particularly with how she responds to family, but it also feels like it's one script pass away from attaining the heights it should be soaring at.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Supergirl: Being Super #2

Feb 24, 2017

Kara wasn't Supergirl right from the get-go and spending this amount of time with her means that we get to know her instead of her superhero persona and as a result this is fast becoming one of the strongest Supergirl stories ever told.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Supergirl: Being Super #3

Apr 28, 2017

This is an intense and internal story, seen through the midpoint flashback and the strong sense of character that comes from this approach shows that Supergirl: Being Super should be the go-to recommendation for Kara Zor-El.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Superman (2016) #8

Oct 7, 2016

Overall, the team deserves massive praise for crafting an issue which had me reaching for my New Frontier collection to compare similar scenes. "Rebirth" is about legacy and what is legacy, if not paying respect to Cooke's magnum opus about the everlasting heroes?

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Superman (2016) #11

Nov 16, 2016

All in all, Superman #11 is about symbols. Bruce and Clark don’t deem their sons worthy to wear them because of their actions last issue. In order to wear the Superboy and Robin emblems, Jon and Damian need to prove they can uphold the codes of their fathers, a lesson that can be learned practically and is best represented by the zipper on Jon’s jacket. Without that self-control, the symbol on Jon’s chest can’t connect and come together - a metaphor that might also apply to the mutual understanding between Jon and Damian. Yet even despite the bickering that characterizes the Super-Sons’ inaugural adventure, it’s clear that Peter Tomasi and Pat Gleason are on their way to establishing a strong sense of chemistry for DC’s newest Dynamic Duo.

View Issue       View Full Review
6
Superman (2016) #18

Mar 1, 2017

This isn’t to suggest that the blame lies with Tomasi and Gleason as storytellers either. As already stated, when the issue does start to build in that final third, the genuine emotion hits in the same way the best issues of this series have already. Which means that the problem is the connection to the wider "Rebirth" plot and as a result, it’s possible to make links between this and Justice League vs. Suicide Squad, which also started with residents of a prison escaping. The stuff with the Kents feels like it could be a normal arc of this series, easily fitting into the two or three issue structure that the book has followed since that opening arc, but instead it’s a part of the "Rebirth" narrative and you’d think that after all this time that it’s spent simmering, it might finally want to feel like a rush.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
Superman (2016) #42

Mar 8, 2018

The dynamic that this team helped to establish as the start of the series is still warm, but certainly doesn't burn as brightly as it did then.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
Superman (2018) #8

Feb 15, 2019

Ivan Reis and Brandon Peterson split the art duties on this issue, with Joe Prado and Alex Sinclair's respective inks and colors endeavouring to provide a uniform look to the full issue. Their effort is not entirely successful, if only because Reis has really stepped up his game while working on the series and really captures that tension of Clark's emotions.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Superman's Pal Jimmy Olsen (2019) #2

Aug 23, 2019

It's a welcome return to Big Two comics for Fraction and it's great to see him matched with an artist of similar sensibilities in Lieber.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Superman's Pal Jimmy Olsen (2019) #7

Jan 21, 2020

As easy as it is to whiz through reading the issue, it invites returning for a re-read in order to home in on the finer details like the preceding six have. Not knowing where the story will zig and zag to on the page turn is exciting. That versatility and potential to be different is such a strong fit for a character like Jimmy, to take a look at the DC Universe from a different angle.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Superwoman (2016) #2

Sep 19, 2016

What started out as a book that impressed me with its character dynamics and surprised me with its final page twist in Superwoman #1 has become my favorite book of "Rebirth" with how committed it is to the ideas of the new line. It's jumped right into to dealing with legacy and what it means to Lana Lang in not only a post-Superman world, but a post-Lois Lane world, and I can't wait to see how this is further explored.

View Issue       View Full Review
10
Superwoman (2016) #4

Nov 10, 2016

Despite Lois re-joining the cast of this book's already impressive list of players, Jimenez's writing in combination with Emanuela Lupacchino's ability to block scenes means that no one gets side-lined to make way for Lois and instead means the series has found a way to bring back the dynamic some thought lost without reversing the emotional beats that worked so well.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Superwoman (2016) #7

Feb 9, 2017

This debut arc of Superwoman has taken a while to reach its conclusion, and it delivers on the expectations prior issues have set up. This means that not only does it see Lana and others attempt to stop Ultrawoman, but it also provides more surprises.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Superwoman (2016) #11

Jun 16, 2017

The plot itself zags instead of following the way that the current Superman arc has zigged leading to an interesting direction that looks like it'll be layering in Lana's anxiety without it being a crutch to fall back on for tension.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Superwoman (2016) #16

Nov 9, 2017

As Superwoman nears its conclusion, K. Perkins does a fine job of tying up the loose threads of Phil Jimenez's initial story while still telling a strong superhero story of her very own.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Superwoman (2016) #18

Jan 12, 2018

Perkins' scenes move briskly along, and as much the way the issue ends is a fitting conclusion for the series, this is the kind of concept that could've worked for more than just one issue.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Tartarus #1

Feb 14, 2020

An explosive opening for a captivating science-fiction story, Tartarus dazzles in both Christmas' characterization and world-building, and in how Cole depicts that visually.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
Teen Titans (2016) #4

Jan 27, 2017

It's entertaining enough, but it would be even more so if the rest of the Teen Titans were given more than they currently have to do.

View Issue       View Full Review
3
Teen Titans (2016) #30

May 16, 2019

Considering that this issue is positioned as an epilogue to the crossover, the fact it doesn't end on something conclusive (or as conclusive as a serialised medium can provide) renders this half of the crossover a waste.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Teen Titans (2016): Lazarus Contract Special #1

Jun 1, 2017

Leave it to Christopher Priest to not only script half of this latest crossover, but to bring it home, and back to where it began in such a way that it astutely circumvents the issues of previous "Rebirth" crossovers - namely the lack of consequences.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
Thanos (2019) #6

Sep 27, 2019

The smartest thing that Tini Howard has done with this miniseries is dial in on how the Mad Titan's abuse and attempts at indoctrination on Gamora lead to a mental obstacle she's battling with to this day " in fact, the ongoing conflict with Magus manages to feel secondary to that, but it's a welcome kind of character work that the last couple years of Guardians stories involving Gamora haven't had the time to dig into due to their scale.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
The Few #1

Jan 20, 2017

In the vein of Mad Max: Fury Road, The Few is a fast-paced thrills ride that keeps dialogue brief and the action heavy, but unlike Fury Road doesn't have a story which instantly grabs hold and refuses to let you go, even in this oversized issue.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
The Fix #8

Feb 24, 2017

Nick Spencer and Steve Lieber's current comedy-crime vehicle may have slowed down from a storytelling perspective, but The Fix can still lay out a surprise when it wants to.

View Issue       View Full Review
10
The Flintstones #12

Jun 12, 2017

Absurdist in the best way, the team took concepts and ran with them when other creative teams would balk at the notion of using a tenth of the ideas on display here. In doing so, they found biting satire, but understood when to cut through this and find genuine, heart-warming sentiment.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
The Life Of Captain Marvel #2

Aug 23, 2018

Writing for comics can be a learning curve, so it's rewarding to see the results of a creator coming to grips with it.

View Issue       View Full Review
6
The Man of Steel (2018) #1

May 31, 2018

Bendis is still setting a lot up, not yet digging into the meat of his story, but this suggests he has a confident handle on where Superman is heading under his pen.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
The Man of Steel (2018) #3

Jun 14, 2018

There's a strong emotional core to this instalment, as Clark has the chance to process what Rogol Zaar has done due to the pacing of the issue, but it's not likely to land unanimously because of how incremental everything leading up to it has been.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
The Man of Steel (2018) #6

Jul 5, 2018

What Bendis has laid out here is the potential for greatness as his run further accumulates, and there's already enough of a strong authorial handle to feel he's capable of achieving that - tics, quirks, and all.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
The Mighty Captain Marvel (2016) #1

Jan 20, 2017

Overall, this is a minor issue with the book and it continues to be another "Marvel Now" book which takes the superhero stuff in its stride and then go one step further.

View Issue       View Full Review
6
The Mighty Captain Marvel (2016) #5

May 25, 2017

It has as big of a scope as it can, considering the main Secret Empire series has already shown where this ends up, but it does mean that Stohl can continue to pile on the pressure to see how well Carol contends.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
The New World #1

Jul 26, 2018

This is an audacious, bold and striking debut.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
The Picture of Everything Else #1

Dec 21, 2020

Kishore Mohan's light linework and sumptuous watercolors are the kind you want to dive right into.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
The Terrifics #5

Jun 29, 2018

Though it doesn't all come together just yet, there's still not enough going on within the pages no matter how much playfulness they're brimming in, and an artist change for the next issue will likely mean yet another adjustment period.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
The Unworthy Thor #4

Feb 9, 2017

Coming to the issue's conclusion, the emotional response felt is only possible because of Aaron's commitment to producing a saga as sweeping as this.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
The White Trees #2

Sep 27, 2019

The first issue of The White Trees was so smart about its worldbuilding and scope that it seemed capable of sustaining an ongoing series to further build on all that, yet it's to the creative team's credit that they stick the landing on the single story they want to tell in this realm.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
The Wicked + The Divine #28

Apr 14, 2017

It's always a treat to see Jamie McKelvie and Matt Wilson depict a godly party and it pops in every panel, even when the issue gets more talky. And that's before Sakhmet's sequence demonstrates what this team can do with black pages.

View Issue       View Full Review
10
The Wicked + The Divine #32

Oct 12, 2017

No part of it feels truncated to squeeze another in, and where the issue leaves off is proof the band-aid has been ripped off and everything's going to come spilling out.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
The Wicked + The Divine #34

Mar 8, 2018

Jamie McKelvie and Matt Wilson depict expansive vistas as the opening and close to the segment, with the middle focusing in on the characters and showcasing how the strength of their character design persists even in this long of an ongoing series, one which has returned without missing a beat, the creative team clearly in step with another and marching towards the end.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
The Wicked + The Divine #36

May 16, 2018

This issue is likely to be remembered for its conceptual qualities, but this second half is a vital part of the entire book. In fact, the issue's real strength is that it makes use of this concept without being beholden to it.

View Issue       View Full Review
10
The Wicked + The Divine #45

Sep 9, 2019

Much like the series opening with "And once again we return to this," there are shades of Grant Morrison in the ending of the surface, but when you take these bookends in tandem with everything in between, it's intrinsically Gillen, McKelvie, Wilson, and Cowles, it's an ode to living life on your own terms and as what appears to be a final creative statement from this team, it's a heck of a way to go out.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
The Wicked + The Divine Annual #1

Dec 14, 2017

While not all of the Pantheon appears, there's overlap between characters that shows how their relationships have changed, driving home how much has really happened between the covers" of these comics.

View Issue       View Full Review
10
The Wicked + The Divine: 1831 #1

Sep 21, 2016

If you’re looking for a The Wicked + The Divine fix before the main series returns later in the year, or haven’t yet jumped on the title and want a taste of what the series can do when it’s firing on all cylinders, or simply want a one-off story, then you should not hesitate to pick this issue up. It’s a stunning issue: Gillen gives us a look into a scenario that’s familiar, but has enough divergence from what we know to feel fresh, Hans’ expressive art breathes life into these characters so the issue can slowly drain them of said life and together they set a high bar for one-shots that follow in the future.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
There's Nothing There #1

Apr 28, 2017

A story that combines the spiritual, physical and material worlds as they intersect with the lives of the social bourgeois, There's Nothing There should feel as uniquely arresting as Olivier Assayas' Personal Shopper, but despite the raw sexuality, found present in similar works like The Neon Demon, this debut feels more mechanical than the orgy in Westworld.

View Issue       View Full Review
5
There's Nothing There #4

Aug 31, 2017

Maria Llovet's art is still the main attraction, as haunting as always, but the book is spread so thin that even when one of these threads ends in a bang, it lacks that punch that's expected from something so socially conscious.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
These Savage Shores #5

Oct 10, 2019

The level of blood spilled across the pages of These Savage Shores has resulted in the cast gradually shrinking and the book becoming more refined in terms of focus with each passing issue as a result.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
Titans (2016) #8

Feb 9, 2017

The first arc of Titans had such a heavy focus on Wally West, that it didn't really feel like a team book all of the time, but if this issue is any indication, it appears that Dan Abnett will be able to provide a well-balanced dynamic moving forward.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Trinity (2016) #1

Sep 26, 2016

While the book is light on plot progression, there's something to be said for how the wonderfully illustrated pages grab your attention and hold it until the end. In that way it's a lot like Manapul's The Flash run from a few years ago. It remains to be seen whether his plotting has become more intricate, but it's clear from this issue alone that his visual storytelling has only gotten better. With that in mind, this series looks like it will be a joy to read and should the narrative remain simple moving forward, this is sure to be a book that's enhanced by the art.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
U.S.Avengers #2

Jan 20, 2017

While not as explosive, the second issue of U.S. Avengers is still delightfully bombastic.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Ultimates 2 (2016) #100

Aug 21, 2017

Ultimates2 may have gotten lost amidst a plethora of other titles that launched around the same time, but it will be remembered as the place where Ewing and company were given a sandbox to play around, and chose to use this space to help build a better universe.

View Issue       View Full Review
6
Uncanny X-Men (2018) #2

Nov 26, 2018

All this set-up thus far has been nothing groundbreaking, though still promising considering where the co-writers have taken other X-books. Hopefully we won't have to wait too long to see what this foundation is in service of, and considering the relaxed pacing of the book thus far, when it arrives hopefully it won't have to be raced through in order to fit it all in by the end.

View Issue       View Full Review
4
Uncanny X-Men (2018) #17

May 3, 2019

Up until now the art has been what's primarily held Rosenberg's run back from achieving its true potential, though in the case of this issue specifically, the greater fault it with the swing-and-a-miss major story decision, one where the implications appear to have not been properly considered.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
Undone By Blood #1

Feb 14, 2020

Both stories give Kivel and Jason Wordie the space for some striking work, with their most impressive pages coming once night falls and Ethel visits the gaudy, neon-lit bars, with the violence that kicks off being reflected in dark red hues.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Venom (2018) #7

Oct 11, 2018

During the first arc, it was difficult to see how Venom could sustain itself as a lengthy run, but this issue promises Cates' ideas about Eddie and the symbiotes have even larger aspirations.

View Issue       View Full Review
10
Vision (2015) #12

Oct 26, 2016

A moment isn’t beautiful because it lasts and we treasure the good ones because of what they make us feel. This series has now come to a close and is the end of King’s time with Marvel for the foreseeable future (he’s DC exclusive), but it made us run the full gambit of emotions. Horror, sadness, dread, joy. And is there anything more human than feeling something?

View Issue       View Full Review
7
War of the Realms #3

May 3, 2019

While this event is a capstone to Jason Aaron's long-standing Thor run, an underrated quality of War of the Realms is how much of a rollicking good time it is even if you haven't been following along since he started writing the character back in 2012.

View Issue       View Full Review
5
We are The Danger #1

May 31, 2018

Lelay goes through the motions, and while the pair at the center get some sweet moments "" including one that emphasises Julie's upbringing "" it's an awfully thin issue in terms of substance. A lot happens, but not a whole lot that's new.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
We Only Find Them When They're Dead #1

Aug 24, 2020

We Only Find Them When They're Dead is such a clear and effective means of establishing a world's rules through just a single instance that by virtue, it also becomes immediately clear why someone would set out to find a living god. To prove that this is not all there is.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Weavers #6

Oct 14, 2016

This is by no means Spurrier's strongest work after his X-Men: Legacy run and his previous miniseries The Spire, but that doesn't mean Weavers is something to sleep on.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
Wild Storm #16

Aug 16, 2018

Due to the running timer on the covers, The Wild Storm always reads as building to its conclusion in a deliberate way. Each interaction plays as essential to the series' endgame, as players like Jenny Sparks and Angela Spica gradually get pulled into contact with one another; a restrained sequence bolstered by Jon Davis-Hunt's formalism and precision.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Wild Storm: Michael Cray #7

May 14, 2018

Even if the end result isn't at that level of quality, it's certainly worth appreciating a series that has taken its time to develop its concept, weave it into a larger story and display with visuals that pack this much of a punch when needed.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
Winnebago Graveyard #1

Jun 16, 2017

Stephane Paitreau handles both parts equally well, being sure to increase the level of color while keeping a creeping shadow in the second half and Steve Niles' script here is shocking, not because of what's seen or unseen, but instead because it feels like it leaves off on an easy cliff-hanger before a real hook has been established.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
Winter Soldier (2018) #5

Apr 15, 2019

It's a slight misstep for a book that has otherwise been sturdy, as Winter Soldier #5 navigates murky thematic material, and yet Higgins and Reis still manage to right their course in time for the final scene and the last image of their collaboration here.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Wonder Woman (2016) #8

Oct 14, 2016

Rucka continues to portray strong women well, while Evely's art is akin to Scott's and will clearly be a fine replacement in the near future.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Wonder Woman (2016) #25

Jun 28, 2017

The harmony of the creative team has been front and center throughout, a team with a single vision – to show what makes Diana Wonder Woman in the first place over creating an interpretation that would be more at home in an Elseworlds tale. A tale rich with symbolism and dense with meaning that never lost sight of what Diana represents even as her world was shaken up. I can only hope that this run provides a sense of stability going forward for her, after countless origin stories, having had her core ideals re-cemented and then her story furthered. That said, even if this does itself subject to a future writer deeming this tale another lie, I have faith that this will go down as one of the classics, as fondly remembered as Rucka’s original run, as a compassionate conclusion that stands as affirmation of everything Diana can be. 

View Issue       View Full Review
7
Wonder Woman (2016) #26

Jul 12, 2017

Overall, arcs which have too much going on are preferable to ones which have to stretch a thin amount of material into the length of a trade and Fontana's looks to err on the side of the former. With any luck, these are purely growing pains and Fontana will be able to properly examine these ideas.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Wonder Woman (2016) #28

Aug 17, 2017

As the midpoint of the run, there's still a feeling that Fontana's hindered by having such a short time for her run, but if the remaining two issues can retain the pacing found here, it'll end strong.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
Wonder Woman (2016) #29

Aug 31, 2017

With just one issue left, Fontana merges the two halves of her run into a concise and intriguing package, but this could be hampered by the fact that her tenure has been so short; here's hoping that won't be the case.

View Issue       View Full Review
4
Wonder Woman (2016) #32

Oct 12, 2017

Remember how James Robinson is, possibly best, known for writing compelling family drama? Most extensively in his Starman run, but even recently with Scarlet Witch, it was a welcome hallmark to his writing because he did it so well. Yet as of the end of his second Wonder Woman issue, it just feels like he's going through the motions attached to the theme as does his story.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
Wonder Woman (2016) #58

Nov 16, 2018

Wonder Woman is a character where new writers can treat their run as a chance to upend everything that came before, so it's appreciated that this creative team builds their debut of something sturdier at the center.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
Wonder Woman (2016) #71

May 28, 2019

This run might not be as vitally fresh as Wilson's Ms. Marvel was for the industry back in 2014, but this is further proof about how compassionate, considerate and entertaining her comics can be.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Wonder Woman (2016) Annual #1

Jun 1, 2017

This quartet all have a very specific goal, from Greg Rucka and Nicola Scott's depiction of when Diana first met Batman and Superman to Michael Moreci and Stephanie Hans' picturesque tale of a sparring match in Japan.

View Issue       View Full Review
5
Wonder Woman: Come Back To Me #1

Jul 26, 2019

The latest of these reprints, Wonder Woman: Come Back to Me by Amanda Conner and Jimmy Palmiotti, is unfortunately the weakest of the Trinity's titles.

View Issue       View Full Review
4
X-23 (2018) #6

Nov 9, 2018

Put simply, it's an issue without depth, and hopefully the next issue will get the book back on track quickly.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
X-Force (2019) #6

Jan 31, 2020

Having established the operation's existence with its opening story - a factor which becomes recontextualized here by a killer data page - Benjamin Percy refines the series' focus with each passing issue.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
X-Men (2019) #2

Nov 14, 2019

Jonathan Hickman's Summers Family Adventures, aka X-Men #2, is a blast to read and moves like a bullet " taking just a page to set up the mission " and winds up in an unexpected destination.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
X-Men Prime #1

Mar 29, 2017

Storm states, “We’ve been so consumed with surviving today, we’ve forgotten how to live for tomorrow.” As a result, everyone involved in “ResurrXion” appears to have set a direction for the X-Men, and have taken this launch issue to demonstrate it. The reason that comics readers come to the X-Men in their adolescence is because a family that’s a little strange, but welcoming is a welcome prospect. And there’s nothing wrong with being aware that we’ll struggle at times, or that the X-Men have to contend with the threat of extinction every now and again, but it’s also smart to take some time to think ahead with a sense of optimism. Which is what this issue has, and inspires. Sure, we could worry that this is too much of a tilt in the other direction, that overcompensation has gone too far, but that feels like we’d be missing the message of this issue and how warm it feels today.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
X-Men: Black (2018): Emma Frost #1

Nov 5, 2018

X-Men Black may not have been a wholly successful endeavor, but these two stories means the grand scheme was definitely worthwhile.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
X-Men: Blue (2017) #2

Apr 28, 2017

While not a grand reinvention, the basics are locked down enough that anyone's who jumped on will be able to ride out the growing pains without too much trouble.

View Issue       View Full Review
3
X-Men: Gold (2017) #36

Sep 24, 2018

The run ends dedicated to Chris Claremont. Guggenheim's final note calls his book a love letter to that monolithic run "at the expense of some originality" that could never reach "the stratospheric heights Mr. Claremont reached in even his most mundane of issues." In that, Guggenheim himself has given what should be the last word on his run.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
X-Men: Red (2018) #10

Nov 9, 2018

To Tom Taylor's credit, even as X-Men: Red conclusion draws nearer, he's still finding way to add additional wrinkles to the work's subtext.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
Year of the Villain: Sinestro #1

Aug 8, 2019

Sinestro's efforts to accomplish his mission see him realising the amount which he can affect a society by; this sociological slant to the book is expected this far into Russell's career, but the allegory doesn't hit upon as deep a truth as he has proven capable of previously.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Young Justice (2019) #1

Jan 10, 2019

It may have taken a while to get here, but already Young Justice is making up for lost time.

View Issue       View Full Review
3
Young Justice (2019) #12

Jan 9, 2020

Young Justice #12 is an example of what happens a busy book has no solid structure to support its plot threads.

View Issue       View Full Review
4
Youth #2

May 21, 2020

After a shoddy first and second impression, Youth offers little to captivate and too little an incentive to stick around in case and see if the back half will offer more.

View Issue       View Full Review

Reviews for the Week of...

December

November

More