-
9.0
Although I don’t agree with Taylor’s portrayal of Daken, he still writes Laura and Gabby perfectly and this issue had a great twist. I really hope that when Logan eventually comes back Laura will still have her own place in the Marvel Universe.
-
8.0
This issue is used to catch a breath and get caught up on the plot that we were picking up to this point. The Orphan's of X (OoX) are exactly as they claim in their name, people that are effected by the killings of Logan (although why refer to him as X?). We also get a little more clarification on the return of Laura's mother. The reveal creating my most shocking moment with Daken's reaction to her. We also get an idea of what the plan of the OoX is. I am enjoying the dialog and the action of the story arc. I still have had trouble seeing the OoX as a truly frightening antagonist for the heroes. I think the biggest problem for the group is having no central figures that represent a threat. Instead we have the collection of guards used as obstacles upgraded to main threat. We get acts of violence and generic collections of faces usually reserved for background foes. While a bit of mystery and intrigue can be thrilling, being too ambiguous makes the threat seem less genuine. This is still a good Legacy start and if the ending leads to a satisfying conclusion I could see this working over all. It would probably work best as a second read through than the first as breaking up the chapters slows the pace a bit. Again fans of the one dimensional killing machine that was Daken will be saddened by the fact that Taylor is trying to give him a bit more character. If that was your Daken I would suggest skipping this arc as Taylor is obviously trying to carve Daken a place in Laura's world. more
-
7.0
The Orphans of X at last have their Deal explained: They're surviving relatives of the folks Wolverine and his descendants have killed, and they're nursing a mighty grudge. Solid art and a rational plot can't quite overcome the cold, clinical way the characters are presented here. Everyone is too much an actor on a stage, going through the motions because the plot demands "X" regardless of how they might feel if examined more humanely. The Orphans are a little too straightforward and the conclusion of this arc - duh, Laura's gonna wind up hugging it out and defusing this conflict diplomatically - is a little too obvious.
-
5.0
Ok that was weird ... I kind of feel like that was a little unnecessary. Too slow, too heavy, too fighting for what ?
That's the first Taylor's Arc I didn't like on Wolverine ... And I really liked the one with the Gardians (I despise this version of the Guardians. Not mine, and though I liked the first movie. Like what ! ^^ )
It's feel weird to see the leader of the orphan with a kind of Cerebro, and to see Captain Marvel have her as kick that fast.
Cover - I will be honest. I not like it at all. 0/2
Writing - First time for everything, sorry Mr Tyler because I trust you do what you can & believe to be your best for us. But this one wasn't for me 1/3 (Thanks to gabby tea proposition).
Arts - And for add to the thing I don't like Cabal. That without any soul at all. Too freezed. 1/3
Feelings - I kind of having shame of my notation because I really love what Tyler does until there. So for All the fun I read before and because All New Wolverine is a title you have to read (Maybe not this arc, but all the rest. Plus I shure other like this one two). 2/2
I give a 1 point in more ... Just Because this title did not deserve having less than
5/10
more
-
2.5
As almost all of us had already predicted ever since the beggining of this. Nothing new or surprising here. No emotional impact, everything happening far too fast. Also, the Cap Marvel addition feels forced.
-
10
-
10
-
10
-
10
-
10
-
9.0
-
9.0
-
9.0
-
8.5
-
8.5
-
8.5
-
8.5
-
8.5
-
8.0
-
8.0
-
8.0
-
7.5
-
7.5
-
7.5
-
7.0