The series is already three issues in..., but Rowell and company really feel like theyre settling into something much longer than a five-issue series. Its uncomfortable to watch Jen just beginning to connect up with a whole new life, knowing that there will only be a couple more issues in the whole series. Rowell spends a hell of a lot of time exploring the personality of the Jack of Hearts for a chapter that really should be a lot more about Jen if its going to be satisfying by the end of the fifth issue. Read Full Review

I am still enjoying this story and am looking forward to more in this story so I will keep recommending it at this stage. Maybe in a couple of issues it will be too far into the story to start from that exact issue and not miss things but it does not seem to be at that point yet. Read Full Review

There's an intriguing mystery at play, a delightful supporting cast, and plenty of humor present in the wonderfully drawn package of She-Hulk, but the series is still struggling to balance those strengths and deliver a complete issue that rises above being slight. Read Full Review

She-Hulk #3 is a golden opportunity to bring the character back to her glory days but Rowell seems content to have the character sitting and talking for the entire issue without uncovering anything about the plot. It's effectively a 22-page idle chit-chat session. At some point, Rowell needs to get going with a story because the only progress being made is in how quickly this issue is losing readers. Read Full Review

Everything with She-Hulk in this She-Hulk comic seems really fun. But we're three issues in and this comic has been 80% explaining Jack of Hearts. I don't even think a new Jack of Hearts comic would feature this much explanation about Jack of Hearts. Read Full Review

Another pretty good issue that gives us a little bit of development on Jen's job along with bringing in Andy. Towards the end, we get to see her friendship with Patsy, which was conveyed very well. The bulk of this issue deals with Jen and Jack, who are developing a fun relationship to read already. This is far from being action-packed (I don't even know that there was any actual fighting in this issue), but it's still a really entertaining and well-written book.

Nice slice of life plus mystery story

I know it's slow. Like, objectively too slow for a monthly series. And I'd like more smashing -- I'm starting to think the Titania fight in #1 was an editorial mandate.

But doggone it, this series tickles me in all the right places. I love its slow-moving, all-talking, "comic where nothing happens" confidence. I love the minimalist art style that always nails the important details. I love the witty repartee. And I love the fact that what's happening isn't actually "nothing"; it's a slow (yes, very slow) burn toward something wonderful.

I won't rate it in "great" territory because I know it's aimed at a very narrow niche (and because of the pacing thing). But because I'm deep in that niche and I love what these creators are doing, I will shamelessly rate it as almost great. more

This issue was obviously a dialogue heavy build to things to come. Rainbow Rowell is great at building up a cast of characters that we care about and I am certain many of the interactions throughout this issue will pay off later. We see a lot of time spent between Jack and She-Hulk and I love the two's dynamic in this issue. Additionally, Bartel is an excellent artist and brings a fun feel to this book.

She-Hulk is my favorite character, and I love how she is portrayed by Rainbow Rowell — a really relatable and even adorable character. She comes out as a really sweet and down to Earth person. A great friend, who you can rely on to share your problems and your inner struggles. She is trying her best to help Jack of Hearts solve his mystery as much as she is trying to cheer him up — all of that while keeping her promise to maintain his current status unknown to other superheroes.
Rowell is extremely detail-oriented on continuity. Past references are recurring: Mallory Book, Awesome Andy, Jack of Hearts’ last appearance as zombie — to name a few. Even the apartment in which Jen now lives was first seen in Sensational She-Hulk #2. Rogê Antônio is reproducing Byrne’s original art in detail, and his art is really stunning across the issue!
His She-Hulk is big and beautiful.
In spite of all the high points, the story is lacking in action. Afterall, this is a superhero book, and fans love some senseless mayhem. Aside from a quick scuffle with Titania in #1 — a character who she fought and defeated dozens of time –, She-Hulk hasn’t flexed her muscles. The book may be struggling to find the right balance between action and cuteness — a flaw that might turn casual readers off.
And while the focus in on Jack of Hearts, She-Hulk’s superhero status is still up in the air. She left the Avengers and is currently serving with the Fantastic Four, but there are points that need to be addressed: Does She-Hulk maintain her connection with the Celestials? Is she at her original powerlevel before being killed by Thanos or does she maintain some of her last powerup? Can she still absorb energy and project radiation in different forms, or are those ability gone?
All in all, a great issue, that needs more action as well as to focus on She-Hulk’s own superhero status. more

AWESOME ANDY IS BACK!!!!
Issue 3 of Rowell's run is still a lot of fun, and it is nice to see these characters chilling around. Her novelistic style bleeds through this one a lot and in odd ways, I really don't mind the chit-chat but we don't learn anything new this issue other than having Jack have a reset, which was established in #2, so not sure why we're doing it again in #3; the seeds for a romance are being planter but I feel there are better ways.
I trust Rowell will pay all this off, but I've seen her harken back to previous runs of a series and bring them into something new brilliantly before in ways that aren't so small.

so boring it was sad