It should come as no surprise that Robert Venditti is able to channel some of the magic of James Robinson's Starman. Both writers are extremely sensitive to character and have a sense of DC Comics history. So far, it's been rather subtle, even though a deeper examination reveals that it seems he been drawing on it since Hawkman #1. Hawkman #17 solidifies it and at the same time feels like a real “Venditti book” as the writer pushes things to another level entirely with the final page. You don't want to miss an issue of this series. It's never too late to jump on…. Read Full Review

His battle against Shadow Thief was brutal on both sides, but the ending to this issue makes it appear as just a sample of what lies ahead. When a comic book makes you check when the next issue is out, it's a sign of a good comic book. And ladies and gents, Hawkman is a good comic book. Read Full Review

Venditti widely didnt drag out this tie-in especially with Hawkman linking up with another big DC storyline for the winter.Hawkman retains a consistent level of quality as Venditti and Oliffe wrap one storyline and tease a very compelling looking next subplot. Read Full Review

I have good faith in the team and I'll follow them in whatever direction they take this character. Read Full Review

As one door closes, another one is blasted wide open. By the end of this story arc, it has become pretty clear what was meant by blood and war being in the forecast in Carter Hall's future. Knowing his past was only the start to understanding the kind of person he would become. Hawkman #17 gave us a taste of what that person looks like, and it was more than reason enough to anticipate what the next issue has to offer. Read Full Review

Just when things begin to show even the slightest staleness, Venditti rips you back into the fray with another jaw-dropping issue"that's exactly what Hawkman #17 is. Read Full Review

Venditti continues to prove he can write a strong, large-scale Hawkman title. Read Full Review

If you're looking for Hawkman to kick a lot of ass... Well, look no further, but if you're looking for a solid end to this Year of the Villain story than this issue might come up a little short because it seems too preoccupied with setting up its next tie-in story to really give Shadow Thief his due. Read Full Review

Now that was some Action! Still a strong story 17 issues in!

Hawkman produced another great issue. You really cant go wrong with this series. From the writing to the art its got it all.

The only shame is this deserves better art, but at least it is improving in that area.

Prelude:
As we continue into Hawkman's Year of the Villain story, does it all wrap up properly?

The Good:
Sky Tyrant has a lot to work with and can be quite interesting.

I loved the conflict between Shade and Carter.

The Bad:
Shadow Thief was ok but really could have been much better.

Conclusion:
It's a strong enough story overall but as we now transition to the Infected, I wonder if Hawkman can survive all of these tie-ins.

Both the art and story are very solid! The cliffhanger has me excited to read more of this! Something that hasn’t happened since end of issue 12.

Meh.

Oh my god, Sky Tyrant, I’m dying.

This book is super overrated and hyped to me. The art is okay...the storing is boring and has been the last two arcs

*YAWN*. Why am I still buying this?