A new, thrilling crime saga from the writer of WILDSTORM: MICHAEL CRAY and the artist of The Old Guard! Disgraced FBI agent Richard Wright is offered a chance for redemption when his old mentor sends him undercover to infiltrate a white supremacist group believed to be responsible for the death of a fellow agent.
American Carnage is a strong start to a story that feels very important, especially in today's world. It feels authentic and comes at a time where we need a hard look at how these movements start. Read Full Review
The subject matter is difficult but this is a great comic. Great writing and art set the perfect tone for this unflinching crime drama. Read Full Review
It eventually ends in a terrifying cliffhanger. The last line of the book is "Welcome to Real America." Its pretty shocking where we end up at the end of the issue. It's even more shocking that it reads true, with not a false note anywhere. Read Full Review
American Carnage quiet frankly is our real world. It is America in it's truest form. Like previously stated many won't be okay with that truth. But Hill and Fernadez give it to you. I implore everyone who wants a well told and well-drawn story of that truth to pick up this book at your local comic book shop. Because it's more than a good read. It's a needed read for all Read Full Review
American Carnage is a powerful display of human complexities struggling for societal influence. Inspired by real-world relevance and a beautiful artistic direction, the first issue proves to be a strong start to a series that couldnt be released at a more opportune moment. Read Full Review
Overall, an excellent debut issue that drops you into a world that is unfortunately way too familiar. The story by Hill is excellent. The art by the creative team is beautiful. Altogether, a sobering looks at the ugliness hiding in plain sight. Read Full Review
The art is fantastic with stunning details in composition as well as the use of shadow in many of the panels. It's evocative of the dark, mysterious tone of the issue. Read Full Review
Though you’ll have to wait until November to fully experience it, know that Vertigo Comics’ crime bonafides are in great condition thanks to the incoming debut of American Carnage. Helmed by a rising star around the DC offices and an art team that has a keen eye for character, violence and mood, this Vertigo debut continues their strong efforts from original, creator-driven series with a bracing dose of socially conscious mayhem. Read Full Review
AMERICAN CARNAGE is a stunning book, one that feels necessary and timely but also straddles that line by presenting a gripping and hopefully long-term story. The art is fantastic on all fronts as well. Read Full Review
The third new Vertigo title to launch, Bryan Hill's American Carnage, is by far the most gritty and down-to-earth. Read Full Review
The inaugural issue is enticing because it shows the jagged edges. It does not shy away from brutality, but it does not revel in it. If this honest reflection can continue throughout the series, American Carnage will be a fascinating social critique, but this book will not be for everyone. Read Full Review
I foresee the team delivering a story that doesn't shy away from addressing both the blatant and poorly concealed racism and bigotry that plagues America currently. American Carnage #1 feels like a perfect fit for a Trump era America where hate and bigotry are marketed as real values and opinions rather than the filth that they perpetuate. Read Full Review
While this book won't win any points with the comics-gate community, true crime fans will find American Carnage quite engaging. Read Full Review
Other than the art, this is a solid first issue. I am interested enough in the premise to read more and I like a lot of the thematic ideas being presented. I'm curious to see where this book goes moving forward. Read Full Review
A well-paced introductory issue, this is a book that has already provided some memorable – and unsettling – moments. If you were expecting an excoriating railing against Trump's America, you might be disappointed. With well-drawn characters and an involving set-up, this is more subtle – and considerably better – than that. Read Full Review
A strong start to a series that looks to help re-establish Vertigo as a line of substance and depth. Read Full Review
AMERICAN CARNAGE #1 is for mature readers. As such, it addresses themes and ideas that may be unsettling. That said there is a potential for a great dramatic tale to be told. Read Full Review
The thing is on it's own Bryan Hill and company still delivered a good issue, the only thing stopping it from becomes a great title will be the ability to deliver the epic story its title promises. Read Full Review
A good opening. The first issue brings you into the story, so that you want to read more. There is a sense that Richard's back-story is more interesting and complex than revealed thus far, and I hope that this is explored more fully later on. This is a strong start to a promising new series from DC Vertigo.
Bryan Hill tries his hand at modern political intrigue. It's not bad, but rings a bit hollow and uninspired.
The end page gives us a more over-the-top look at racism. However, it's the subtler, more complex moments that are harder to shake.
This is fine. That's all.
I dunno what to think about this! I’ll probably read another issue.
© 2024
Prev
