Scott McDaniel Comic Reviews

Current Series: 0 Total Series: 30 Issues: 194 Critic Reviews: 201 User Reviews: 403
6.4Avg. Issue Rating
6.6Avg. User Rating
+ Creator Watch List

User Ratings Critic Ratings
N/A
 JSA: Classified #17  
8.1
 Nightwing (2016) #100  
7.9
 80th Anniversary 100-Page Super Spectacular: Robin #1  
7.2
 Flash (2016) #37  
8.5
 Green Arrow (2001) #60

Mar 15, 2006
9.0
 Green Arrow (2001) #61

Apr 12, 2006
9.5
 Green Arrow (2001) #62

May 17, 2006
9.5
 Green Arrow (2001) #63

Jun 14, 2006
9.5
 Green Arrow (2001) #64

Jul 12, 2006
9.5
 Green Arrow (2001) #65

Aug 9, 2006
10
 Green Arrow (2001) #66

Sep 13, 2006
10
 Green Arrow (2001) #67

Oct 11, 2006
10
 Green Arrow (2001) #68

Nov 8, 2006
9.0
 Green Arrow (2001) #69

Dec 13, 2006
9.5
 Green Arrow (2001) #70

Jan 10, 2007
9.0
 Green Arrow (2001) #71

Feb 14, 2007
9.5
 Green Arrow (2001) #72

Mar 14, 2007
9.5
 Green Arrow (2001) #73

Apr 11, 2007
10
 Green Arrow (2001) #74

May 9, 2007
10
 Green Arrow (2001) #75

Jun 13, 2007
7.8
 Detective Comics #766

Jan 9, 2002
6.5
 Detective Comics #867

Jul 28, 2010
6.0
 Detective Comics #868

Aug 25, 2010
N/A
 Detective Comics #869

Sep 29, 2010
N/A
 Detective Comics #870

Oct 27, 2010
7.0
 Batman Confidential (2006) #22

Oct 8, 2008
6.5
 Batman Confidential (2006) #23

Nov 12, 2008
6.0
 Batman Confidential (2006) #24

Dec 10, 2008
5.5
 Batman Confidential (2006) #25

Jan 14, 2009
4.5
 Batman Confidential (2006) #29

May 13, 2009
8.0
 Batman Confidential (2006) #30

Jun 10, 2009
N/A
 Superman: The 10-Cent Adventure #1  
N/A
 Trinity #6

Jul 9, 2008
N/A
 Trinity #8

N/A
 Trinity #9

Jul 30, 2008
N/A
 Trinity #10

Aug 6, 2008
N/A
 Trinity #15

Sep 10, 2008
N/A
 Trinity #17

Sep 24, 2008
N/A
 Trinity #33

N/A
 The Great Ten #1

Nov 4, 2009
N/A
 The Great Ten #3

Jan 6, 2010
N/A
 The Great Ten #6

Apr 7, 2010
N/A
 The Great Ten #9

Jul 7, 2010
N/A
 Red Circle: The Shield #1  
1.0
 Countdown Arena #1

Dec 5, 2007
1.0
 Countdown Arena #2

Dec 12, 2007
1.0
 Countdown Arena #3

Dec 19, 2007
1.0
 Countdown Arena #4

6.0
 Superman / Batman: Secret Files 2003 #1  
6.7
 Robin: Son of Batman #7  
6.0
 Static Shock #1

Sep 7, 2011
6.2
 Static Shock #2

Oct 5, 2011
5.5
 Static Shock #3

Nov 2, 2011
5.0
 Static Shock #4

Dec 7, 2011
6.5
 Static Shock #5

Jan 4, 2012
5.0
 Static Shock #6

Feb 1, 2012
6.2
 Static Shock #7

Mar 7, 2012
6.5
 Static Shock #8

Apr 4, 2012
6.5
 Batman and Robin (2009) #17

Nov 24, 2010
5.9
 Batman and Robin (2009) #18

Dec 15, 2010
6.0
 Batman and Robin (2009) #19

Jan 12, 2011
N/A
 Superman (1987) #190

N/A
 Superman (1987) #191

N/A
 Superman (1987) #192

N/A
 Superman (1987) #193

N/A
 Superman (1987) #194

N/A
 Superman (1987) #195

N/A
 Superman (1987) #196

N/A
 Superman (1987) #197

N/A
 Superman (1987) #198

N/A
 Superman (1987) #199

N/A
 Superman (1987) #200

N/A
 Batman #575

Jan 26, 2000
N/A
 Batman #576

Feb 23, 2000
N/A
 Batman #577

Mar 29, 2000
N/A
 Batman #578

Apr 26, 2000
N/A
 Batman #579

May 24, 2000
N/A
 Batman #580

Jun 28, 2000
N/A
 Batman #581

Jul 26, 2000
8.0
 Batman #582

Aug 30, 2000
N/A
 Batman #583

Sep 27, 2000
9.0
 Batman #584

Oct 25, 2000
N/A
 Batman #585

Nov 22, 2000
N/A
 Batman #586

Dec 13, 2000
8.5
 Batman #588

Feb 7, 2001
9.0
 Batman #589

Mar 7, 2001
9.0
 Batman #590

N/A
 Batman #591

N/A
 Batman #592

N/A
 Batman #593

N/A
 Batman #594

N/A
 Batman #595

N/A
 Batman #596

N/A
 Batman #597

7.5
 Batman #598

Dec 26, 2001
7.7
 Batman #599

Jan 30, 2002
8.0
 Batman #600

Feb 27, 2002
7.5
 Batman #601

Mar 27, 2002
7.5
 Batman #602

Apr 24, 2002
8.7
 Batman #604

Jun 26, 2002
7.3
 Batman #605

Jul 24, 2002
7.8
 Batman #606

Aug 28, 2002
7.5
 Batman #607

Sep 25, 2002
N/A
 Birds of Prey (1998) #125  
3.5
 Birds Of Prey (2011) #23  
8.0
 Amazing Spider-Man (1963) Annual #26  
N/A
 Bruce Wayne: The Road Home: Ra's al Ghul #1  
5.8
 Daredevil (1964) #305

4.8
 Daredevil (1964) #306

3.8
 Daredevil (1964) #307

0.0
 Daredevil (1964) #308

0.0
 Daredevil (1964) #309

0.0
 Daredevil (1964) #310

0.0
 Daredevil (1964) #311

5.0
 Daredevil (1964) #312

5.5
 Daredevil (1964) #313

3.5
 Daredevil (1964) #314

3.0
 Daredevil (1964) #315

4.2
 Daredevil (1964) #317

Apr 6, 1993
5.0
 Daredevil (1964) #318

6.0
 Daredevil (1964) #319

6.2
 Daredevil (1964) #320

6.2
 Daredevil (1964) #321

5.8
 Daredevil (1964) #322

6.5
 Daredevil (1964) #323

5.8
 Daredevil (1964) #324

4.8
 Daredevil (1964) #325

5.0
 Daredevil (1964) #326

2.2
 Daredevil (1964) #327

2.2
 Daredevil (1964) #329

2.0
 Daredevil (1964) #330

2.0
 Daredevil (1964) #331

1.5
 Daredevil (1964) #332

8.0
 Deadpool (1997) #27  
N/A
 Marvel Comics Presents (1988) #71

7.2
 Marvel Comics Presents (1988) #74

Feb 19, 1991
7.2
 Nightwing (1996) #2

7.0
 Nightwing (1996) #3

7.0
 Nightwing (1996) #4

6.5
 Nightwing (1996) #5

7.6
 Nightwing (1996) #6

7.2
 Nightwing (1996) #7

6.8
 Nightwing (1996) #8

6.8
 Nightwing (1996) #9

7.3
 Nightwing (1996) #10

7.2
 Nightwing (1996) #11

7.3
 Nightwing (1996) #12

7.7
 Nightwing (1996) #13

7.5
 Nightwing (1996) #14

7.3
 Nightwing (1996) #15

7.2
 Nightwing (1996) #16

7.0
 Nightwing (1996) #17

6.8
 Nightwing (1996) #18

6.8
 Nightwing (1996) #19

7.0
 Nightwing (1996) #20

6.7
 Nightwing (1996) #21

6.8
 Nightwing (1996) #22

5.5
 Nightwing (1996) #23

6.5
 Nightwing (1996) #24

7.5
 Nightwing (1996) #25

7.2
 Nightwing (1996) #26

7.0
 Nightwing (1996) #27

7.0
 Nightwing (1996) #28

Dec 9, 1998
7.0
 Nightwing (1996) #29

Jan 13, 1999
8.8
 Nightwing (1996) #30

Feb 10, 1999
8.0
 Nightwing (1996) #31

Mar 10, 1999
8.5
 Nightwing (1996) #32

Apr 14, 1999
7.0
 Nightwing (1996) #33

7.0
 Nightwing (1996) #34

Jun 9, 1999
7.5
 Nightwing (1996) #35

Jul 14, 1999
7.0
 Nightwing (1996) #36

Aug 11, 1999
7.0
 Nightwing (1996) #37

Sep 8, 1999
8.8
 Nightwing (1996) #38

Oct 13, 1999
9.0
 Nightwing (1996) #39

Nov 24, 1999
7.0
 Nightwing (1996) #40

Dec 8, 1999
7.5
 Nightwing (1996) #101

Jan 12, 2005
7.8
 Nightwing (1996) #102

Jan 26, 2005
6.9
 Nightwing (1996) #103

Feb 9, 2005
7.4
 Nightwing (1996) #104

Feb 23, 2005
7.6
 Nightwing (1996) #105

Mar 9, 2005
7.5
 Nightwing (1996) #106

Mar 23, 2005
N/A
 Peter Parker: The Spectacular Spider-Man (1976) Annual #9

9.0
 Peter Parker: The Spectacular Spider-Man (1976) Annual #12

N/A
 Robin (1993) #139

Jun 22, 2005
N/A
 Robin (1993) #140

Jul 20, 2005
N/A
 Robin (1993) #141

Aug 31, 2005
N/A
 Robin (1993) #142

Sep 21, 2005
N/A
 Robin (1993) #143

Oct 19, 2005
N/A
 Robin (1993) #144

Nov 23, 2005
N/A
 Robin (1993) #145

Dec 21, 2005
N/A
 Robin (1993) #146

Jan 25, 2006
N/A
 Robin (1993) #147

Feb 8, 2006
8.5
 Web of Spider-Man (1985) Annual #8  
N/A
 X-Man (1995) #8  

Reviews for the Week of...

May

1st

April

24th 17th 10th 3rd
More
© 2024