Colleen St. Lucie's Profile

Joined: Jan 09, 2020

Recent Activity

8.5

Bonus points for the amazing art.

Exceptional X-Men #1

By: Eve Ewing, Carmen Carnero
Released: Sep 4, 2024

KATE PRYDE LEADS A TEAM OF ALL-NEW X-MEN! After the fall of Krakoa, Kate Pryde is trying to get as far away from all things X as she possibly can. She's just a regular-degular bartender now. Definitely NOT getting ready to head up an ALL-NEW TEAM of wayward young mutants while avoiding the watchful gaze of Emma Frost. Nothing in this title but work...

+ LikeComment
Colleen St. Lucie rated Phoenix #1 Aug 24, 2024
9.0

Phoenix #1

By: Stephanie Phillips, Alessandro Miracolo
Released: Jul 17, 2024

LIFE! FIRE! POWER! POSSIBILITY! PHOENIX!
She is JEAN GREY. She is PHOENIX. She saves the world. She brings death. One woman, alone in space, who not only must do what no one else can: she yearns to. A desperate S.O.S. from NOVA brings the Phoenix to the edge of a black hole, where hundreds of lives hang in the balance...and whatever Jean does ...

+ LikeComment
Colleen St. Lucie reviewed Phoenix #2 Aug 24, 2024
8.0

Yay for Jean as a solo hero. Good seeing a familiar face in Corsair but he's weirdly inappropriate here! Sold on a Jean book; not necessarily the cosmic angle, but giving it a fair shake.

Phoenix #2

By: Stephanie Phillips, Alessandro Miracolo
Released: Aug 21, 2024

JEAN GREY is dedicated to protecting innocents in deep space! Yes, space is vaster than imagination, greater and darker than the mind can comprehend - and yet, not big enough to stop family from dropping by without warning... But that's how it goes when your father-in-law is CORSAIR of the STARJAMMERS! Leaving the pirate life behind, he's got the i...

+ LikeComment
Colleen St. Lucie reviewed X-Men #33 Apr 3, 2024
7.5

I like the Latverian mutants. Don't have much else to say.

X-Men #33

By: Gerry Duggan, Joshua Cassara
Released: Apr 3, 2024

X-MEN X-SSEMBLE! If there were ever a time to rally the troops and take the fight to the enemy, it's NOW! Stand side by side with the X-Men as they head for their final stand! They can't stop ALL of us!

Rated T+

+ LikeComment
7.5

Actually a commendable ending to a series that was probably 2 issues to long.

Astonishing Iceman #5

By: Steve Orlando, Vincenzo Carratu
Released: Dec 20, 2023

SHATTERED!
ORCHIS has figured out ICEMAN's secret - and brings the fight to his frozen front door! Can BOBBY DRAKE survive this ultimate showdown?
Rated T+

+ LikeComment
Colleen St. Lucie rated Jean Grey #4 Nov 16, 2023
9.5

Jean Grey #4

By: Louise Simonson, Bernard Chang
Released: Nov 15, 2023

JEAN GREY'S GREATEST ENEMY!
The most powerful telepath on Earth still doesn't know the extent of her own mind. For months you've watched her relive her greatest traumas. Now the smoke clears...and the flame burns brighter than ever. All secrets are revealed in the finale of Louise Simonson and Bernard Chang's deep dive into the heart and mind ...

+ LikeComment
Colleen St. Lucie reviewed Realm of X #3 Oct 26, 2023
2.5

The art is not Neves but Bruno Oliveira. I am sorry to say that this style completely took me out of this narrative. Literally everyone is cross-eyed on every panel, giving the whole thing a goofy feel.

Realm of X #3

By: Torunn Gronbekk, Diogenes Neves
Released: Oct 25, 2023

NO GODS, ONLY MUTANTS!
The date of the prophecy looms ahead, and despite their best efforts, the Vanir and their mutant protectors are ill-equipped to meet their destiny. Meanwhile, their enemy grows ever stronger, sinking their claws deeper into the misguided Curse. Lost and at the end of her rope, Dani beseeches her former friends in Asgard ...

+ LikeComment
Colleen St. Lucie reviewed X-Men #27 Oct 4, 2023
6.0

Beautiful Phil Noto art. But I can only hang on so long to this title while the lead characters are freaking Ms. Marvel, Rasputin IV, Talon and Synch. I need my A-list X-Men please.

X-Men #27

By: Gerry Duggan, Phil Noto
Released: Oct 4, 2023

SOMETHING CAUGHT YOUR EYE?
When Cyclops joined this iteration of the X-Men, his pitch was simple - "I am the X-Men." If this is so, the enemies of X-Men seem to have this fight all sewn up.
Rated T+

+ LikeComment
Colleen St. Lucie reviewed Immortal X-Men #16 Oct 4, 2023
9.0

I think it's clear Gillen is the best X-writer in the stable right now.

Immortal X-Men #16

By: Kieron Gillen, Lucas Werneck
Released: Oct 4, 2023

APOCALYPSE WHEN?
When everything has already gone wrong, you may think at least you have nothing to worry about. You'd be wrong.
Rated T+

+ LikeComment
Colleen St. Lucie reviewed Storm #5 Sep 27, 2023
7.0

I'm not nearly as harsh a critic on this series as most. I thought it was pleasantly fine. I just think it pretty uncool that Marvel is willing to pay writers and artists and spend other publication costs on * flashback * series. Hello, what about a current Storm mini in continuity? Or Gambit? Or Jean Grey?

And, if you're going to do a flashback, answer a dangler. Example: How the h more

Storm #5

By: Ann Nocenti, Geraldo Borges
Released: Sep 27, 2023

THE ALL-POWERFUL STORM! STORM is mad as hell, and she's not going to take it anymore! BLOWBACK's mind-blowing secret is revealed, as the former X-Man reaches her ultimate breaking point! What are the consequences of Storm's full power unleashed? You won't want to miss the climax to the ultimate ORORO MUNROE masterpiece.
Rated T+

+ LikeComment
Colleen St. Lucie rated Storm #2 Sep 27, 2023
7.5

Storm #2

By: Ann Nocenti, Sid Kotian
Released: Jun 28, 2023

OUT-OF-CONTROL POWERS VS. AN OUT-OF-THIS-WORLD ADVERSARY!
As ORORO MUNROE tries to balance her responsibilities as leader of the X-MEN, her difficult relationship with KITTY PRYDE and even a NEW LOVE INTEREST, her powers are creating deadly weather that threatens to tear it all asunder! In the eye of the storm is the powerful NEW VILLAIN BLOWB...

+ LikeComment
6.0

Ms. Marvel: The New Mutant #2

By: Vellani, Carlos E. Gomez
Released: Sep 27, 2023

Stay tuned for more information (including the actual title) in July!
Rated T+

+ LikeComment
6.0

Emma is Duggan's Mary Sue. She must appear in every issue he writes.

Invincible Iron Man #10

By: Gerry Duggan, Juan Frigeri
Released: Sep 27, 2023

You are cordially invited to the wedding of Anthony Edward Stark and Emma Grace Frost...Come join the lucky couple as they exchange vows. Attire is Hellfire formal. Orchis raid to follow. Plus some exclusive wedding extras!
Rated T+

+ LikeComment
Colleen St. Lucie reviewed Jean Grey #2 Sep 27, 2023
7.5

Disappointed this is another 'What If' story. I want a real adult Jean Grey solo in present time, not flashbacks and what ifs. However, the actual writing is good.

Jean Grey #2

By: Louise Simonson, Bernard Chang
Released: Sep 27, 2023

THE DARKEST PERIOD IN JEAN GREY'S HISTORY! The Dark Phoenix has haunted Jean Grey since it emerged from Jamaica Bay. But what if the Phoenix had chosen...someone else? The love story of Cyclops and Jean Grey is one of the most beloved in Marvel Comics' history. Now witness a legendary creator break their hearts - and their minds. But this is no "wh...

+ LikeComment
Colleen St. Lucie reviewed Jean Grey #1 Aug 30, 2023
8.5

I have asking for an adult Jean solo series for years and it's finally here! Only. . . it's kind of a 'What if?' story. It seems only the last issue will be relevant. However, the writing and art is very good, so I'll score it well.

Jean Grey #1

By: Louise Simonson, Bernard Chang
Released: Aug 23, 2023

SUPERSTAR CREATORS TAKE JEAN GREY'S LEGACY TO FIERY NEW HEIGHTS! After the events of the Hellfire Gala, Jean's life is in shambles. Mutantkind is in dire straits - and there's nothing this founding X-Man can do. She'll have to save herself first. And that means looking into her past - for the moment when it all went wrong - in a desperate attempt t...

+ LikeComment
Colleen St. Lucie reviewed Dark X-Men #1 Aug 16, 2023
7.5

Don’t like this lineup (particularly comic trash Azazel) but it exceeded expectations.

Dark X-Men #1

By: Steve Foxe, Jonas Scharf
Released: Aug 16, 2023

WELCOME TO THE DARK X-MEN? HOPE THE WORLD SURVIVES THE EXPERIENCE! Following the explosive events of the Hellfire Gala, MADELYNE PRYOR realizes the world needs the X-Men now more than ever. HAVOK and GAMBIT have served on the team before... but never one that looks like this! And how does GIMMICK, breakout star of MARVEL'S VOICES: PRIDE, fall under...

+ LikeComment
7.0

Uncanny Avengers #1

By: Gerry Duggan, Javier Garron
Released: Aug 16, 2023

The FALL OF X calls for the return of the Avengers' Unity Squad! Innocent people and world leaders are dead after simultaneous attacks on the U.S. and Krakoan governments, and that means one thing: It's time for a new squad of Avengers. False-flag attacks meant to whip up anti-mutant hysteria are unfolding, and hey, some of Steve Rogers' best frien...

+ LikeComment
Colleen St. Lucie reviewed X-Men #25 Aug 2, 2023
8.0

I can’t with the nonsensical spelling of Shadowkat but on the whole this was good. Her scenes and development were the highlight. Not sold on the composition of this team though, especially Ms. Marvel and Rasputin IV. I want my banner X-Men 😢

X-Men #25

By: Gerry Duggan, Stefano Caselli
Released: Aug 2, 2023

THE FALL.
She's been known as Kitty, Sprite, Ariel, Red Queen and Captain Kate. Now, as a new X-Men team finds their way through their darkest hour...SHADOWKAT emerges!

+ LikeComment
Colleen St. Lucie liked this:
derbycomics reviewed X-Men #25 Aug 2, 2023
8.5

There was a lot of anticipation for the first issue of X-MEN in a post-Hellfire world and Gerry Duggan showed that the X-writers’ room wasn’t going to hold any punches during the Fall of X. X-MEN #25 continued to show how bleak the mutants’ current reality is and offered little hope for an immediate fix.

The main story of the issue primarily focuses on Kate Pryde’s new role in more

X-Men #25

By: Gerry Duggan, Stefano Caselli
Released: Aug 2, 2023

THE FALL.
She's been known as Kitty, Sprite, Ariel, Red Queen and Captain Kate. Now, as a new X-Men team finds their way through their darkest hour...SHADOWKAT emerges!

+ LikeComment
8.0

Don't at all like Ms. Marvel as a mutant.

Some things didn't add up like the practitioners of the Red Triangle Protocol.

Plausible practitioners of the Red Triangle Protocol

Angel
Nightcrawler
Shadowcat
Wolverine
Bishop
Forge
Gambit

Probably Not

Emma Frost (She would have her own defense; it was designed to withst more

X-Men: Hellfire Gala 2023 #1

By: Gerry Duggan, R. B. Silva
Released: Jul 26, 2023

THE FALL OF X BEGINS HERE! The Hellfire Gala is always the biggest event of the season...but this year's will change everything for Krakoa. What is meant to be mutantkind's biggest night becomes their biggest nightmare as the Fall of X begins! All your favorite X-Men are going to be left reeling after this one - shocking revelations, stunning betra...

+ LikeComments (1)
Out of Gluck - Aug 1, 2023

Never mind Magik and Mirage who were both trained by Xavier. If Sunspot knows Red Triangle, they do, and both have formidable psyches. Those who knew Red Triangle didn't seem well thought out.

5.5

After completing this series I'm not sure what the point was. Hoping for a break from Betsy, she received a huge push the past 4 years and needs to be in background for a while.

Betsy Braddock: Captain Britain #5

By: Tini Howard, Vasco Georgiev
Released: Jun 21, 2023

EARTH'S MOST FURIOUS HEROES UNITE! And the villains alike! Morgan Le Fay has saddled up with her old lover, none other than Doctor Doom! And that can't mean good things for the old country. But Betsy Braddock has a plan up her sleeve?and a Multiverse of allies even Morgan can't magic-wand away. The fight for Britain, for Betsy, for Captains everywh...

+ LikeComment
Colleen St. Lucie reviewed X-Men #24 Jul 19, 2023
8.0

Don't get the Jean/Scott spat but otherwise very solid.

X-Men #24

By: Gerry Duggan, Joshua Cassara
Released: Jul 5, 2023

POGG UR-POGG FOR HIRE! Hired for the dirtiest of jobs, a deadly mercenary comes crashing into the X-Men right at their most vulnerable moment! But not just any mercenary - finally, the breakout fan-favorite from X OF SWORDS, Pogg Ur-Pogg, returns!
Rated T+

+ LikeComment
Colleen St. Lucie reviewed Immortal X-Men #12 Jul 19, 2023
9.0

Heartbreaking!

Immortal X-Men #12

By: Kieron Gillen, Lucas Werneck
Released: Jun 7, 2023

A COLOSSAL MISTAKE? The Quiet Council gather to fill the empty seat. It's the last chance to make a smart, kind decision to prevent the fall. Luckily, the deciding vote is in the hands of trusty old Colossus. Let's hope he hasn't got plans to ruin everything. That would be terrible.
Rated T+

+ LikeComment
Colleen St. Lucie reviewed Immortal X-Men #13 Jul 19, 2023
8.5

Want more Doug.

Immortal X-Men #13

By: Kieron Gillen, Lucas Werneck
Released: Jul 12, 2023

LISTEN CLOSELY. Time is running out. Fall is here. Doug Ramsey is the voice of Krakoa. It's time for Krakoa to speak.
Rated T+

+ LikeComment
2.0

*sigh*

New Mutants Lethal Legion #5

By: Charlie Jane Anders, Enid Balam
Released: Jul 19, 2023

DANGER! BATTERY OVERLOAD! The New Mutants' plan to take down Count Nefaria has epically failed, and as a result, he's more powerful than ever! But there's no time for Escapade and her teammates to lick their wounds - Nefaria and his diabolical Lethal Legion have set their sights on a convention center in Midtown New York to make hundreds of humans ...

+ LikeComment
Colleen St. Lucie liked this:
Logan X reviewed New Mutants #31 Feb 26, 2023
3.0

Wake me when the New Mutants show up.

New Mutants #31

By: Charlie Jane Anders, Alberto Alburquerque
Released: Oct 26, 2022

ESCAPADE JOINS THE NEW MUTANTS! Hugo and Nebula Award-winning author Charlie Jane Anders brings the breakout character of this year's MARVEL'S VOICES: PRIDE anthology to one of the Marvel Universe's most beloved teams! Personally recruited by Emma Frost herself, Shela Sexton reluctantly joins her fellow mutants on Krakoa in the hope that the X-Men ...

+ LikeComment
5.5

Liked the artist!

X-Men: Before The Fall: Mutants' First Strike #1

By: Steve Orlando, Valentina Pinti
Released: Jun 7, 2023

KRAKOA STRIKES?! Ever since mutants declared themselves humanity's new gods, certain circles have been waiting for the other shoe to drop - the wrath. When a small New England town is hit by a devastating mutant attack, it seems the wrath is here. But all isn't as it appears. And Krakoa doesn't hesitate to save lives - so it's time for BISHOP to le...

+ LikeComment
Colleen St. Lucie liked this:
4.5

Kudos to Orlando's deep cuts but this was literally a litany of just mutant reports one after the other.

X-Men: Before The Fall: Mutants' First Strike #1

By: Steve Orlando, Valentina Pinti
Released: Jun 7, 2023

KRAKOA STRIKES?! Ever since mutants declared themselves humanity's new gods, certain circles have been waiting for the other shoe to drop - the wrath. When a small New England town is hit by a devastating mutant attack, it seems the wrath is here. But all isn't as it appears. And Krakoa doesn't hesitate to save lives - so it's time for BISHOP to le...

Colleen St. Lucie liked this:
1.5

[Art: 4.5
Writing: 2.5]
/2 = 3.5
-2 points for repeatedly using Wolfsbane's ridiculous multiple man powers which make no sense whatsoever.

New Mutants Lethal Legion #4

By: Charlie Jane Anders, Enid Balam
Released: Jun 21, 2023

STEAL FROM THE WORST! Escapade, Cerebella and Scout's plan to perform the ultimate heist and steal from Count Nefaria has not been going as smoothly as they would have liked. In fact, they now have to face the Count and his new nefarious Lethal Legion! Thankfully, Dani, Karma, Galura, Rahne and Morgan join the fray and will bring some order to the ...

+ LikeComment
2.0

New Mutants Lethal Legion #4

By: Charlie Jane Anders, Enid Balam
Released: Jun 21, 2023

STEAL FROM THE WORST! Escapade, Cerebella and Scout's plan to perform the ultimate heist and steal from Count Nefaria has not been going as smoothly as they would have liked. In fact, they now have to face the Count and his new nefarious Lethal Legion! Thankfully, Dani, Karma, Galura, Rahne and Morgan join the fray and will bring some order to the ...

+ LikeComments (1)
Colleen St. Lucie - Jun 29, 2023

Real life teenagers are not this annoying. Please save Dani from this writer.

Reviews for the Week of...

November

October

More