Superbly written and spectacularly illustrated, featuring a Supergirl who is coming into her own as a hero to be admired, respected, and reckoned with, this is hands down the best book coming out of the Superman family of books and shouldn't be missed. Read Full Review

The art by Kevin Maguire is quite excellent. He is an odd fit for this book and that's what makes it work. The expressions and body language for the characters are all excellent here. Hopefully, he and Andreyko have a have a long run on this title. It's been an excellent ride these past few issues. Read Full Review

Supergirl has really benefited from the change in creative teams as Andreyko is on to something special and it's only just beginning. If you're not reading this book yet, you're truly missing out on one of the best Supergirl runs in years. Read Full Review

This series is a must-read. The story kicks into gear and the art is important. Find a more gorgeous issue this week, you will not. Read Full Review

Aside from that, I really havent anything else to say about the issue. Lovely to look at, fun to read. Read Full Review

Supergirl (2016-) #23 starts slow with a lot of exposition, then picks up the pace as Supergirl begins her breakout of the Green Lantern Corps. Well-written and drawn wonderfully, the only thing that could have improved this comic would be some more depth to the secondary characters, as well as another setting or two to display how Supergirl truly is on a cosmic quest across the galaxy for the truth about Krypton's destruction. Read Full Review

I don't know how to put it all together. It seems like story points just happen to occur to keep Supergirl in space. A gem treasure hunt to gather Apsa's confession? A rebuilt ship? Mogo keeping silent? Kara's anger? All seems arranged to keep  her off Earth. Maguire's art definitely raises the book a ton. I found myself pausing before turning the page to let everything really sink in. Luscious. It probably nudges the grade up a whole letter. Read Full Review

Overall Supergirl #23 finally sets things on the right path with both a story and a character worth investing in. Read Full Review

Armed with a new lead, Supergirl's quest continues, but just how far is the circle willing to go in order to keep their secrets safe? Worth a look. Read Full Review

I view Supergirl in much the same way as Batgirl; both characters deserve to have great creative teams, delivering the best stories. For both books, that creative team change has come with this team having a few more issues of Supergirl under their belt than their Gotham based counterparts. So far, I am pleased with both books, with my interest piqued by the Supergirl team enough to keep checking in on this book. Read Full Review

Supergirl's quest for answers does a great job of focusing the character and giving her a place in a larger story with consequences that have meaning to both she and her cousin. Read Full Review

I did have fun reading this book, though, and can't wait to see how the story ends. Read Full Review

While this book only has a couple of long scenes, I still found it very entertaining. It didn't reveal enough of the mystery in my opinion but it has given me enough to be interested in seeing what happens next. And isn't that really the goal of any book? Read Full Review

As far as the rest of the issue Maguire gives us his usual brand of excellent art, but there was one thing I noted; there was a lack of backgrounds in this issue, so I'm not sure if the artist was rushed for time, or if there was just too much action for the page and Maguire wanted the reader to focus elsewhere. It's not a major distraction but one that I noticed during the first part of the comic. Read Full Review

All in all, there's nothing here to drive off those who are interested in the continuing mystery of Krypton's destruction. Fans of Supergirl, however, may find themselves hard-pressed to care about a story that is competently handled but largely lackluster. Read Full Review

I like this comic and I am really interested in the plot, some weird moments but I forgive.

I really liked this issue. Which is a shocking thing to say about Supergirl.

I will admit I wish a fellow lantern was helping her along the way. Issue itself was pretty good. Art was fair and dialogue was nicely done!

If Andreyko manages to keep his current momentum with the series, everything shows it's going to be the best Supergirl run in years. It's fun, full of action, the humor is not forced and works very well with the protagonist, who I may add, is just... super. Kara is entertaining, and her quest engages the reader.

My previous criticism related to art is still relevant - panels more often than not leave a lot to be desired. They are by no means terrible, but I'd welcome a bit more attention to details and backgrounds, as well as Kara's facial expressions.

I keep my fingers crossed for this series. So far I'm not dissapointed, even in the slightest. You go, Kara! Up, up, and away!

I thought the art took another downturn. And the story isn't bad but is a bit annoying.

from a base of 6, this gets a rating of: 7.
+1 because: krypto! and a nice enough story going on

+ Like • Comments (2)

•

Synthozoid - Oct 12, 2018

From a base of 6? Does that mean 6 is the best or the worst? A 6 point scale? Are you saying you prefer a 6 point system? Daddy T, you are an enigma wrapped in a cosmic cube wearing Supergirl's headband.

daddyT - Oct 13, 2018

nah... if a book is just "meh" - good enough to get me to read the next one usually, but with nothing to complain about or nothing really good either, it gets a 6. there are various ways to get points added or removed. "confusing" gets -1, "great art" gets plus 1, etc. this book was pretty average with nothing to really move me except that between the mildly interesting story and Krypto, it got one extra point.

Sign in to comment