Ice Cream Man #4 should be read immediately by anyone reading this. It is the most fun you’ll have reading a comic book that is also making you depressed and kind of scared. This team has taken so many terribly real things about life and artistically created a comic book of them so that we can see these nightmares outside of our minds. This fourth issue is another perfect comic book to add to the first three. Read Full Review

This was another great issue of a fun series. This time round though there is a sense of an issue which is now starting to establish linkages with a broader piece of storytelling, and we seem to be getting a greater level of story continuation in a series that has consisted of (seemingly) standalone issues to date. The ending with the appearance of a tall dark stranger in a cowboy hat has me dying to see how things develop in this series. Read Full Review

Not for the faint of heart, but still a touching and/or horrifying tale. Well worth the read. Read Full Review

Ice Cream Man is all about the subtle creepiness and horrors of everyday life. You might not have to leave the lights on for this one, but it is haunting nonetheless. Read Full Review

You do not need to have read the first three issues for any context for the primary story in this issue, but for the overall book, it will help. This should not only be made for horror fans but also people wanting a strong story about humans and our fears over loss. Read Full Review

We'll have to keep reading to find out, but this issue took big steps towards this being more than just another horror anthology. Ice Cream Man #4 managed to give us all these questions and tell another effective horror story up front. The next issue isn't coming until July so we've plenty of time to theorize! Read Full Review

Overall, I found this to be an enjoyable chapter in this series. I liked the interaction between Joel and Chris' father and I also loved the horrifying interlude that we see involving Chris. There was one particular scene involving Joel and Chris' father that bugged me a little, but aside from that I thought it was pretty ace. Read Full Review

It's clear that this series has bigger ideas, but on the level of an individual issue that present a story that work in neither the micro nor the macro, which is particularly disappointing in this installment. Read Full Review

I'm really enjoying each issue with this series of horror anthology at its finest. The art is solid, great storytelling mixed with dark humor this book is a must for horror fans. Keep the ice cream coming!

This is my favourite ongoing at the moment, even if this particular issue was slightly weaker than the previous 3. There was some good imagery in this issue and a cliffhanger that is definitely intriguing.

A good installment that shows some signs of a larger plot being revealed.

A disappointing fourth issue. The cliffhanger at the end is interesting in the formation of a larger narrative, but the story within this individual issue is weak. There is no background as to why Chris is experiencing this torture after death, and frankly I don't care either because he isn't a character who I have ever heard of before.

This series has some nice moments, but it is reaching for more without getting there. It may achieve that goal in the next run, but on present form it is torn between being an anthology series or having an over-arching plot. If it is to be the latter, then more of the Ice Cream Man is needed in each issue. If it is to be the former, then it needs better constructed stories than this one.