Captain America #3 is fantastically written by Zdarsky in terms of developing the story but still keeping the readers thinking about the current world around them whilst doing so. The fantastic art from Schiti and Martin which combined really helps Zdarsky in tell his story. He truly is lucky to have a creative team behind him that can add to his story and understand what he's trying to do where in it. Please, please, please keep up the fantastic work, all of you. Every minute detail has been picked up on and it really does add to the telling of the story! Can't wait for issue 4! Read Full Review

Captain America #3 delivers a riveting and weighty chapter that pushes Steve Rogers into new, uncomfortable territory while firmly grounding the series in the complexities of modern warfare. Zdarsky and Schiti balance superhero spectacle with the trauma of real conflict, creating a Captain America story that feels both timeless and urgently contemporary. Read Full Review

It's only 3 issues in but already this series is one that you don't want to miss. Chip Zdarsky is writing an absolute masterclass of a story, and Valerio Schitti & Frank Martin are right there alongside Chip with some of the best artwork you'll see this week! This issue is absolutely a can't miss issue! Read Full Review

Captain America #3 veers away from bombastic superheroics, instead leaning into quiet dread, political subtext, and emotional resonance. Doom isnt just a supervillain; he's a symbol of a harsh new era Steve must adapt to. The art and pacing underscore the sensory weight of that emotional journey. With rich landscapes, moody shading, real sense of place, this issue pops with a vivid sense of unease and displacement. Captain America #3 feels cinematic in its tensionan emotional ambush wrapped in gothic architecture and political power plays. Its not just a battle; its a reckoning. If you came for punchy heroics, this may feel slowerbut for those eager to explore Steve Rogers psyche as he faces a world that has moved on, this issue is a rich, slow-burn gem. If you want atmosphere over spectacle and weight over fireworks, this is worth it. Read Full Review

Schiti delivers fantastic art throughout the issue. I love the visual contrasts between Coltons past and the events in the present as well as the visual differences between his and Steves story. Read Full Review

Zdarsky isnt afraid to bring up major, sometimes divisive topics head on. Hes also willing in most cases to let the reader draw their own conclusions. This issue is no different than the first two in that regard. Its a good way to keep the series both compelling and relevant to major issues of the day. All of that said, Captain America #3s greatest strength is the powerful art in the issues final pages. If you havent picked up Captain America yet, do yourself a favor and grab an issue. Read Full Review

The stories in this series continue to be very strong, though I want more focus on the new David Colton character over just another Doctor Doom story. But that might just be me. Read Full Review

I like this series way more than I should. It's a little generic, but it has a lot of good scenes.

I’m going to continue to read this because I feel like it has a lot of potential. Story is pretty good. But a lot of potential. The art was definitely inconsistent this issue. Some pages look amazing. Others ok. I thought there were two artists working on this book. But Valerio schiti is laboring some pages come off as very rushed.

This issue was the weakest and most predictable so far. I’m still interested to see where this is going though.

I want Chip to do well with Cap, but I'm not feeling it... yet. There's potential here, but playing with 'untold stories' and multiple Caps isn't doing him any favors.

And on the matter of 'retcons', I remember how in Avengers #20, Cap didn't even remember who the ruler of Latveria was.

Like I said, the story stioll has potential - but the art and editing are a different matter. Half the time, you have to guess which Cap is narrating this and if it weren't for the white or black star, it'd be easy to confuse which Cap is which.