Crocodiles, MI5, fist fights with mysterious assassins" this is Scott Snyder making it look easy. All Star Batman is the book that other books want to be when they grow up. Read Full Review

I'm really having a lot of fun with this story.  Its a mystery with a ton under the surface and I can't wait for Snyder to peel the layers back some more.  I am a Rafael Albuquerque fan so this book may just have it all!  Highly recommended! Read Full Review

Fun, exciting, heartfelt and easy on the eyes.All Star Batman continues to be one of DC's most original books. With only three issues left, strap in for a fun ride. Read Full Review

Snyder continues to prove that he's the best Batman writer of the last few years, tying together Alfred's past with a new threat here to haunt Batman. Albuquerque's art was stellar and the story is very engaging. Buy it for the main story, ignore the back-up if you want. Read Full Review

Part 2 of the First Ally story arc illuminates some of the darker corners of Alfred's past. Action-packed and emotional, this issue is yet another must-read from Scott Snyder. Read Full Review

All-Star Batman continues to deliver thrilling and unexpected Batman action. That unpredictability factors remains one of its greatest assets. Read Full Review

All-Star Batman #11 moves “The First Ally” story arc forward in exhilarating fashion, as in addition to adding more mystery to this tale, the creative team also give us some wonderful twists and revelations. This is all once again accompanied by a thrilling back-up story, with the events of both sure to leave readers eager for the next issue. Read Full Review

I like Rafael Albuquerques work. It reminds me of Eduardo Barretos work but with thinner lines. The art is probably the one thing that made me most interested in the comic. It reminded me of the old 1950s Batman or the one from the Bruce Timms cartoon but with a bit more realism and crime noir. Read Full Review

This issue provides a unique look at Alfred's past contrasted against Batman's present. This is shaping up to be a great Batman story. The backup story seems a bit less exciting, but still is a solid story. Read Full Review

Overall, All Star Batman continues to try things different with Batman and give us stories that feel different but also add interesting new wrinkles to the mythos of the Dark Knight. Read Full Review

'The First Ally' arc continues to unravel a fascinating mystery surrounding Alfred, with its strongest moments coming from delving into the butler's backstory. Read Full Review

With over-the-top ridiculousness, paired with emotional storytelling makes this book something special. Read Full Review

Sometimes in this arc it just feels like Alfred's backstory, albeit worthy, is obstructing a cool, apparently new villain story in the A plot. Now, an Alfred spinoff prequel series -- there's an idea. Read Full Review

A fun and exciting issue that loses some of its luster due to a few glaring plot contrivances. Read Full Review

One part daring adventure serial and one part fairly frustrating narrative, the former is thankfully favored so it's easy enough to recommend. Even when some of the ideas and concepts he resurrects don't really resonate with me, I still enjoy the fact that Snyder is willing to write a more care-free, dare I say fun Batman. The backup takes a bit to get going, but once it does it's reminiscent of the best types of crime drama: grimy and intense, full of twists and turns. All-Star Batman may make some questionable storytelling choices, but if it's nothing if not interesting and engrossing. Read Full Review

All in all, All-Star Batman #11 is another solid entry in the series. It might not have the grit and intensity of the previous issue, but it succeeds in moving the story in an exciting direction. Also, we get to see Alfred punch Hush in the face and Penguin wear a Hawaiian shirt. Those two things alone are worth the cover price of this comic book. Read Full Review

An attractive book with a new and interesting take on the narrative"I mean who doesn't love Alfred. At the same time, I don't feel like your getting the whole story that Snyder wants to tell, it's almost too messy. Splitting the issues up may help the reader adjust to which story is the main plot. I know it's all coming together, so hopefully the pay off is worth it. Read Full Review

I have been enjoying the story so far and like everything that has to do with Alfred's past. At certain points it can be humorous, while at other points it is more serious and direct.

I'm digging Alfred's backstory, I'd almost rather read just that. The backup story is getting good too, I'm glad that my extra dollar isn't going to waste.

This issue had highs and lows. I liked the Rafeal Albuquerque art, but wasn't really feeling the black-ops Alfred thing or his narration about his dad. I kind of sighed when I saw the back-up, because with these 8-page instalments I never remember what happened in the last one (I read a lot of comics!), but I got into this one. So, not great, but pretty good issue.

Still solid. There are two stories going on, one past and the other present, and the past story is far more interesting. I know both stories will eventually collide but I find myself a little bored during the the Bruce Wayne, super-spy, elements. Hopefully the landing will be solid.