Loved this issue and back up was so damn good litteraly can't wait for next one

The entire event sucked. 2 stars for it being over, nothing else.

I really would like to know how some of reviews of this is 10 out of 10 because there was nothing literally nothing right with this issue it didnot answer a single question Bruce bailed on everyone and well said the batfamily responsibility is no longer on me and well guess what he is gonna be isolated because he wanted it himself great just great thus issue really doesn't deserve more than a 1

Such a weak book i dont like this type of stories using zur as an excuse to let batman do whatever the hell he wants even putting a failsafe into his son it was like really painful to see jason like that in the end and well we saw another time how catwoman just trusted sb in a week and that guy turned out to be traitor since catwomans new run she can been nothing butba totall fool but how we salvage this?? Instead of writing her in character we just make batman worse what a novel approach this event has been one of the worst events ever it litteraly contains the oposite of every thing peoole want they want batcat together well they are fighting for the dumbest reason the want batfam to be a family we see how fractured they are such a disappointment i really feel bad for the art which is wasted on this comic more

Well this issue was written much better than battle lines and i had less problems reading it and the majority of it is because selina panels was limited and she didnot talk much last issue when ever she started to talk it was so painful to read ok move on the art was much much better so i am glad about it lets continue to talk about writing well unlike many people i had no problem with the characterisation of batman well this man has had so much on his plate recently from 4 back to back wars to failsafe to insomnia to waking up and seeing the love of his life has built a criminal empire so him acting like this is totally fine with me ok the fight scenes were cool but unrealistic on the concept bruce one shotting everyone was too much to take and is just wrong,batfam members take on crime was awkward because yu know their job is to stop crime no matter what type seeing them doing nothing towards crime is again wrong as well and we still have the biggest issue of this event which is the most painful part of this story( charactetisation of selina) truly it hurts to see her being dumb, heartless and mobboss at the same time i wish i just wish they come with sth to redeem her character later on because this is not who she is at all
And her characterisation is the exact reason that i just cant be excited about this event
Zor en ar is cool, batman going on beast mode is cool but as i said i cant be inttested about this selina what so ever well i am done more

Well it was an awful issue regarding selina they couldnot have written her worse than this if you are even slightly a selina kyle fan you will definatly get headache by reading it like the worst portral of the character i have seen in ages
The real selina wouldnot talk to bruce like this, she is smart and doesnot make stupid decisions she is caring and a great woman but here we see an emotionless cold woman who is so idiot and only she cares about is her and her stupid plan i am pretty damn sure i will understand zorenar aproach and characrer much more than selina in this event
To be brief: it is such an awful time to be a selina kyle fan more

I am really suprised it was the best catwoman book that tini howard has written in a long time and again for the first time batcat interaction had meaning and i liked that i hope she can keep this pace for gotham war too and i would be glad to keep giving her high rates if it wasnot for maggie being sister zero which i dont like it would be a 10 out of 10 from me but i just dont like the idea the maggie that i love was definatly from ram v era but all said a really solid issue more

DC needs to cancel this title before too much irreparable harm is done to this character. Her level of stupidity in this issue is mind-boggling. Why would anyone root for this character in this situation?

I am realy sorry i know the art deserves a score here but the writing sooo bad that i cant give it more selina treating black mask like she and specially her sister has no history which they do and its so harsh and wll selina making some new rules which shows how idiot she is and totall clueless on how gotham runs and ofcourse batman should be ok with this too or guess what we gonaa use this as the start of upcoming war ah its so lame destroying a character to set up an event this issue was one of the worst isdues of the run with issue 47 and 49 more

Apart from selinas dialoges which was written so harshly this was a very good issue i have seen this type of writing for selina in catwoman book and now this i hope it pays off in the end and bat and cat really go back to each other otherwise i wont know what to tell about this selina characterisation

Let us all rejoice for there shall be a catfight...next issue...between Noah and Dario...what the f@#$?

This issue, however, is filled with more bad dialogue, more bad references to He Who Shall Not Be Named, and Black Mask, with a new uglier mask. And apparently the most inept mobsters I've ever seen.

For the love of all that is holy, please stop the assassination of Selina Kyle. more

A bit of imrprovement from last issues because finally sth happened, the most problem i have with this issue is the same i had with issue 50 you just cant say how much you miss a man how much he meant to you but come out and say your in love with sb else and still are this is so weird and selina in this issue accepted the fact that when she wanted to start things with valmont she was in love with bruce and knew its not gonna work out but she did it anyway it just shows how idiot she is and how insensitive she can be in the matter of love
But all things said if you cut out all valmonts plots i could really at least give it a 7 out of 10 but now 4 is just enough more

A few notes:
1. Can people please stop pretending that Tini Howard is a competent writer?
2. The dialogue continues to be atrocious.
3. For the love of Christ, give up Valmont. Stop trying to make him a thing. He's not even a has-been; he's a never was.
4. Tini's knowledge of the prison system must have come from a children's book.

I just cant beileve how the dialoges be this bad its unbeilevable this issue had a bit more story proggression than the whole prison arc but still not much happened well now that selina is out i am really more worried about her future and we cant catch a break from valmont and his memories as well i wish it just could end

Nothing happened and i didnot even enjoy the art much

I really enjoyed this issue and i am very curious where this alternate selina story will lead and how it affect the main line catwoman and bruces feelings for her

It was definatly improve since last issues bruces letter to selina was nice but i found the rest of the issue as a filler nothing basicly happened and selina making her own gang is not anything new we just saw it recently valmonts thought didnot much apear in the issue and it definatly helped the issue and i hope it stays this way and i hope bruce and selina relationship becomes more consistant as well with the recent events on catwoman and batman book i am hopeful in this case art was nice as always more

Excellent issue you cant imagine how much i loved it as a cw and batcat fan i really needed this after current cw run events i wish g wilson could write selina instead of current one

One of the most boring and pointless issues i have read so far i dont know where the writer is going at all and what is her purpose on writing this run this way i wish i knew tbh my rating is just for the art because the story is basicly nothing

Well it was a great setup i have much more hopes for this arc than failself had pretty decent dialoges i give it 9 because i dont know where it goes but it could even be 10

I know comic book standards are low but this is pathetic. You've got a writer self-inserting and stealing plot ideas from a 1988 movie while forcing it upon a character that simply doesn't fit into it. Not going to waste more than a few minutes on reviewing this garbage so I'll just say that it is basically a character study on how to ruin and degrade a character to the point where even her fans are calling her a POS. Selina is utterly unlikeable and despicable in this and it's honestly infuriating to see such a beloved character disrespected by her own owners/writers/editorial staff to such a heinous degree. Why is she friendly with a murdering stalker? Why is she intimate with a murdering stalker? Why is she comparing this murdering stalker that she barely knows to Bruce? Why is the plot of this run so boring the only thing anyone ever talks about is the horribly out of character and absurd relationship drama? If this run doesn't convince you of nepotism I honestly don't know what will.

Very rarely do I rate anything, comic, movie, book or otherwise, below a 3, but the entirety of this run is certainly deserving of it. What the fuck was the point? more

SPOILERS.
Dear god, just when I thought the writing couldn't get worse, it somehow manages to accomplish exactly that. Tini continues to thoroughly destroy Selina Kyle in a way I didn't think was possible. Apparently, Selina is so in love with Valmont after approximately one week of knowing him that she had a hard time trying to choose who to save, him or BATMAN?????? She kills Valmont to save Batman and then has an absolute breakdown over his death. JESUS CHRIST! I would rather be set on fire than have to suffer through more of this run. more

My rating is just for the art nothing more the art is being totally wasted on this disrespectful run i just dont get how some people can give this 9 or 10 i am really curious to see what good thing they saw in this issue catwoman hasnot been this out of character in ages she fell for valmont some body she just knows for weeks and what kind if a person he is liar,murderer,untrusratable god we dont even know his true name how could you posdibly think of falling for this guy and it just doesnot end here after she kilks,he dies or whatever she misses him more the love of her whole life i cannot tolerate this anymore its so bad and i think poor batman is just being used here no way in hell that i love you and i will always will is real noway if you love sb this much you cannot do this to him i just wish this distespectful run end sooner more