Maybe I am just missing something here but the plot is an absolute mess. The art is great and the concept is good but it feels like the action and dialogue are out of sink with each other. If I was being honest it felt like the art was completed before the speech was inserted. This happens way to much and usually when the writer is spinning to many plates. Sorry only my take and I will quietly drop the title. more

As a jumping on place for new readers this is a disaster that should have been avoided at all costs. The writing is fun and the story is strong with lovely visuals and awesome covers. This I failure due to a writer that didn't get the sodden memo.....Mr Priest.....please write so new readers don't have to read 50 plus years of back catalogue to understand the script.... Ella as a character should be on every single fantasy pull list and if it's not then why the Hell not??????? more

After reading this issue I feel like I'm grinning like a small child. This was fun , witty and just plain bizarre. Nothing about this comic should work and yet it does with an encore. The writing and art just seem to gel together perfectly and I enjoyed every single page. Brilliant

I'm not a fan of TMNT in anyway shape or form but I am now!!!! Cool clean art with vibrant colours gift wrapped in a script that packed a punch. The dialogue was so on point that I couldn't find a single gripe.

This issue was at least better written than the last but 4 issues is a lot when all we know about the suit is next to nothing. If you're new to Spawn then this would be so frustrating. The art was glorious yet again and to be honest it's holding this story together with all it's got. Erica needs to have an editor all over her like a rash when it comes to plot development or replaced quickly before this comic ultimately gets cancelled prematurely. more

The saving grace to this mostly okay story is the wonderful manga style modern art. It's rich , vibrant and pops of the page. The dialogue is written by a simpleton for a 1990's revamp of a revamp. OMG would someone tell this moron that adults buy comics not pre facial haired teens. Please Todd would you replace her quickly as this comic in the right hands has a real chance.

The art and colours are really starting to shine and the story itself is not new to be honest but enjoyable all the same.

In the most part I really enjoyed the story and the art but the dialogue could do with being a lot more natural. Altogether not a bad start.

Perfect!!!!!!!

The problem with reinventing a past success by a wonderful artist that is sorely missed , is finding a new voice for a different generation. The story was way to fast and frenetic to be enjoyable , plus the art and covers were to be honest a little dated. I hope as the months go by the team gel and start producing great work but I'm doubtful and so disappointed. Time will tell.

I've actually no idea how to score or review this comic at all. Nic Klein take a standing ovation as your art is to die for. PKG this is a bit of a mess and so boring. Marvel why have a Deadpool/Wolverine story in a Hulk Comic??? I despise Deadpool but Wolverine is cool. Sorry I'm an old time Hulk fan and he really needs a writer that takes it back to basics with a modern twist. To Marvel please get this sorted as I only want Hulk please...... more

I'm reading this years after the first printing and I'm going to be honest it looks and feels very dated. Maybe my taste in horror is a bit more refined but it left huge gaps in the actual story. So/So in 2024

I enjoyed the pacing of the book better this issue and Nate wasn't anywhere near as annoying. Parts of the art are still looking rushed but overall the story is starting to lead somewhere

The problem although partially addressed in this issue is Nate. The art was better and the size of the environment feels amazing but I just can't stand the constant drivel that comes out of Nate. Fix this issue and I would be in foe the long hall.

The concept of the story is a little weak as it feels like so many TV shows of yesteryear. Kung Fu and Hulk spring to mind but I can see where it could go. This issue the art was a bit of a let down as it felt rushed and nowhere near issue 1...

As a script it's not exactly new and Knight is seriously annoying but it's got a charm and the art is exquisite. With a bit of development this could be a really enjoyable ongoing series.

Quite simply the best comic book series on the shelfs just now. The art is magnificent and the script sublime. The level of raw emotion that drips of each pages makes you read it slow to enjoy every aspect. Utterly up there with the best team for many a year.

As much as I loved the story I found the art hideous. John is a dark , funny , complex and really deep at his core so needs an artist that delves into these dark moods. Sorry but this kind of art ruins the mood of a great book.

Brilliantly drawn and scripted with 2 book ends that could be placed either side. It's difficult to read this issue without looking at life differently. I suppose that any comic that makes you think about things you'd really rather avoid is doing something right.

This is a breath of fresh air as a story. Great script , wonderful art , fantastic homicide story and lots of little threads to make you think with one of the most disturbing endings to a comic in forever. Outstanding and to the idiot that gave it 2 for a score your wife says your new glasses prescription is ready love.

The story itself is mostly enjoyable and the art is outstanding but I'm afraid it's kind of let down by some atrocious dialogue. He keeps mentioning its going to get a lot darker with a parental guidance rating and yet some of the dialogue is really for a 10 year old with a couple of really needless swear words. Sorry I hope Derek dosn't take this badly but with a professional writer and his amazing art this comic could be a must read. more

The journey meanders of into many stories within stories and makes the framework for the real story all the richer. The diverse art and voice was reminiscent of different times of what is John. Not going to lie but I want an 80pg special written this way each summer as I could never tire of these short stories.

Great art as usual with a lovely charming little story that hide an awful lot of truths about real friendship and family. This takes a lot of skill and courage as it's easy to make a mess of the writing but hats of again to the team for keeping things fresh and exciting.

This has all the promise of a great story but some of the dialogue was unnecessary and way to many characters in one issue. The art was awesome but the lettering was a mess. I think the real reason I'm struggling with this comic more this issue is I actually don't like Rook as a person and that is probably why I will ultimately fall away as the issues go on.

As a second issue it was a bit of a mixed bag to be honest. The art really lifted some pretty repetitive dialogue from crashing the whole comic. Dire Wolf as a character is so one dimensional that you actually start rooting for the bad guy. Won't give spoilers but the bad guy gets my vote and will keep me coming back for more.

Okay I am so biased it hurts as a complete Negaduck geek but this is still and always will be all kinds of awesome. Baddies , caverns , space all wrapped up in a villian that just is the greatest villian the world has ever seen. Okay a bit dramatic but us geeks are like that ya know.

There seems to be a sudden switch away from the dross of yesteryear into what I call intelligent thought provoking stories that seem to find an artist at the very top of his game. As a number 1 issue for a new reader this is how to write a comic.

Maybe I'm just out of touch with Marvel comics just now as I found this a mess. The dialogue was juvenile and the art was patchy at best. No offence but the blazing church and Tulip?? Was I reading amateur hour Preacher? Sorry but the list of mistakes kind of rattled an old fan boy like me so much. As I said current Marvel is a mess of timelines and multiverse dog crap. I would ask for a complete reboot of the Marvel universe but the thought of yet another No1 more

I really love what DC are doing with these black label stories as they are fun , intelligent and get to breath enough to really develop the characters and the story without needing a 1000 different comics to read it first. Great start and wonderful colours and art.