Akash Sil's Comic Reviews

Reviewer For: Batman-News Reviews: 30
6.3Avg. Review Rating

7
Batman '89 (2021): Echoes #3

Jul 10, 2024

The problem with Batman '89 Echoes actually stems from issues that are not really apparent on the page. The lack of a proper schedule kills any momentum for a book that really isn't treading any new ground. Personally, this isn't that bad a story; there is a lot to like about the art, and I'm mildly interested in seeing what happens next. But as of now, nothing in the story has failed to convert this book from 'mild' to 'must read' for me.

View Issue       View Full Review
7.5
Batman '89 (2021): Echoes #4

Sep 11, 2024

This book is starting to grow on me. A lot of it is thanks to the amazing artwork by Quinones and Ito, but the story has its fun moments. The slow pace of the earlier issues comes back to haunt this one, but hopefully, from here onward, the pace will manage to even out.

View Issue       View Full Review
3
Batman '89 (2021): Echoes #5

Dec 18, 2024

This issue and this series at this point reeks of a contractual obligation needing to be fulfilled by both parties. Maybe the whole thing will read better as a trade, but for now, I struggle to recommend it to even die-hard Keaton fans.

View Issue       View Full Review
5
Batman / Superman: World's Finest (2022) #32

Oct 16, 2024

I wanted to like this more than I did, but I just couldn't bring myself to leap past the plot holes. And once you fall into one of them, well it's hard to stop falling. The characters take actions that seem convenient for the story to happen and any hero not named Superman, Batman, or Robin feels replaceable.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Batman: Dark Age (2024) #2

Apr 23, 2024

While the art and story for #2 remain pretty solid for the most part, I can't help but wonder how this will all end and whether or not the ending will be able to deliver a satisfactory conclusion. It is probably unfair to draw comparisons with Superman: Space Age, but the book does force them with the shared similarities between the two series. However, we do seem to be past the setup stage and I do want to keep reading to know what happens next.

View Issue       View Full Review
7.5
Batman: Dark Age (2024) #3

May 28, 2024

While I did complain a fair bit about certain plot points and I do feel this title isn't doing enough to distinguish itself from its predecessor, Batman: Dark Age remains one of the more bright and optimistic Batman stories I've read in recent memory. A lot of it is thanks to the art by the Allreds, which remains a standout, even if I struggle with the faces on occasion. Despite its flaws, #3 remains a decent read, and I remain hooked on what's to come next…even though the ‘next generation' is a no-show this month.

View Issue       View Full Review
8.5
Batman: Dark Age (2024) #4

Jul 25, 2024

Batman: The Dark Age took its time to get out of the shadows of its predecessor. But it has been worth the wait as the series delivers its strongest issue so far. The art is good as always – to the point where I can't find new words to praise it – but there's an injection of color in this month's issue that has helped make the book more livelier. Dark Age takes delight in depicting the Batman of a simpler time through a modern lens and does it exceedingly well.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Batman: Dark Age (2024) #5

Aug 28, 2024

Batman: The Dark Age has gone from strength to strength with each issue, to the point where I didn't even mind when the Pariah subplot crept back into the story. Its only real flaw is that the story did not pace itself well in its previous issues, but I am unwilling to blame this issue for it. Delivering some shocking deaths, shocking team-ups, shocking backstory changes, and, of course, a shocking cliffhanger, this series continues to be a pleasant shock to the system.

View Issue       View Full Review
6.5
Batman: Dark Age (2024) #6

Nov 13, 2024

Unfortunately, Batman: Dark Age not only failed to stick the landing, but it somersaulted into a web of confusion made up of all the tangled plot threads the series has been juggling so far. The art remains decent, and I like the journey this Batman went through, but the similarities to its predecessor and confused social messaging hold it back too much for me.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
Batman: The Brave and the Bold (2023) #11

Mar 27, 2024

Like most anthologies, this issue is a mixed bag. There was some truly great stuff, some mildly amusing stuff, and some stuff that can be classified as filler at best. I do wonder what it says that the stories that stood out the most were the Bat stories, but I hope we see more stories like the ones we goteven the Sgt. Rock one. These characters are a part of the tapestry that makes up DC's rich history and deserve to be remembered.

View Issue       View Full Review
6
Batman: The Brave and the Bold (2023) #14

Jun 25, 2024

Brave and the Bold is a title that lacks any direction. Whether or not any of the stories told here will matter in the future is up for debate, though personally speaking, I don't think most will. It's hard to recommend this title just for the Batman: Black and White stories when they will probably be collected into their own separate volume at some point. They aren't particularly bad stories, but I won't rush to revisit them once I finish this review.

View Issue       View Full Review
5
Batman: The Brave and the Bold (2023) #15

Jul 25, 2024

Without the Batman: Black and White story, which would raise the overall score of the book, we can see the true value of this anthology series. Despite my championing these types of stories as a way for fans to read about lesser-known characters or fan favorites that don't have their own titles, it doesn't matter if the stories we get are bland and just grossly misrepresent the characters involved. I mean, at this point, DC might just have the characters going full meta and discussing among themselves how they act differently, even if it doesn't make sense.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Batman: The Brave and the Bold (2023) #17

Sep 26, 2024

This is a much better offering of stories overall. I like that we get a no-nonsense Batman story, a story where Streaky features prominently, and the microstory at the end made me chuckle. It's a decent, if not spectacular, collection, which is probably the best you're getting with this series.

View Issue       View Full Review
9
Batman: The Brave and the Bold (2023) #18

Oct 23, 2024

This is a good collection of stories. I was not expecting to like the Harley and Robin stories as those concepts seemingly were done to death, resurrected in an event comic, and promptly died off again. And yet, I found myself liking most of the stories in the comic. Maybe the good vibes from the Batman story carried the rest of the issue, but that does feel unfair on the rest.

View Issue       View Full Review
2
Batman: The Brave and the Bold (2023) #19

Nov 28, 2024

Well, this series took a steep nose-dive for the worse. The first and final stories are not only poor in their own right, but are terrible choices to be paired together in an anthology together. The issue is saved by some decent character work between Diana and Plas and Tim and Damian, but it feels like a stretch to even call this a mixed bag. Well, only another issue before my suffering ends

View Issue       View Full Review
7.5
Catwoman (2018) #69

Oct 16, 2024

Going into this issue relatively blind was certainly an eye-opener as I was able to enjoy the story on offer despite having a few issues with it. As a jumping-on point, it does everything right to hook a new reader, however, similarities in structure to past stories might make this appeal less to more experienced ones. However, Torunn Grnbekk's writing and the overall art made this comic a pleasant read.

View Issue       View Full Review
6.5
Catwoman (2018) #70

Nov 22, 2024

This issue is definitely a drop in quality on all fronts from the previous one. The writing and visuals can't mask the genericness of the plot and the new characters emerging from every orifice of this story makes it hard to care for any of them beyond their appearances and generic character traits. Catwoman seems mildly bored with the proceedings and at this rate, I'll end up just like her.

View Issue       View Full Review
6
Catwoman (2018) #71

Dec 19, 2024

Catwoman #71 continues this run's dedication to hitting every familiar beat that can be found in a Catwoman story, which hopefully appeals to Selina Kyle fans, as I'm not sure how many others would care. The art remains stellar, especially with Delpeche's coloring, but it can only carry the plot so far.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
DC Horror Presents... (2024) #2

Dec 5, 2024

DC Horror Presents fails to get a reaction out of me, let alone chill me to the bone. The stories are mildly entertaining at best and reek of DC wanting to bring talent from outside the industry who have some name recognition in other fields of entertainment. The art is only serviceable and fails to elevate the story beyond its basic visuals. I'm not really sure what the sales numbers of these types of series are to justify constantly publishing them, but I guess "good enough is an acceptable metric.

View Issue       View Full Review
7
DC vs Vampires: World War V (2024) #1

Aug 14, 2024

While whether or not this series deserved a sequel can only be decided after the end of this long mini-series, for now, DC vs Vampires: World War V manages to start well, if not exactly strong. There are some intriguing elements, like a character who might be from one of the backups of All Out War showing up and some decent characterization (who would've thought vampire Grodd would be the most loyal of all of Barbara's followers?), which are enough to keep my interest for the time being. But the cracks haven't exactly been papered over, and I wonder how long it will take before they start to become more visible.

View Issue       View Full Review
7.5
DC vs Vampires: World War V (2024) #2

Sep 11, 2024

There are a lot of moving parts in the main story, but thankfully, not all of them are focused on at once, giving each of them some much needed breathing space. We don't see Damian in this issue, but we feel the ramifications of his actions. The story is still mostly setup at this point, but it does enough to spice up the story with bits of action now and then, and the art is decent, if not spectacular, and shines through during the big moments.

View Issue       View Full Review
5
DC vs Vampires: World War V (2024) #3

Oct 9, 2024

SighI was worried about the incoming padding of the material in World War V, and unfortunately, I was not proven wrong. So, now all we have to do is watch the series spin its proverbial wheels until it decides to untangle its threads. As for when that will happen, your guess is as good as mine.

View Issue       View Full Review
6.5
DC vs Vampires: World War V (2024) #4

Nov 14, 2024

The story is unbelievably stuffed, with this issue only adding more to the madness. However, some decent characterization and a great backup actually make this the best issue in the series so far. However, as the plotlines continue to haphazardly converge with each other, with the New Gods apparently joining the party, that might not be enough for most people to continue with this series.

View Issue       View Full Review
7.5
DC vs Vampires: World War V (2024) #5

Dec 11, 2024

DC vs Vampires: World War V #5 moves the plot forward a decent bit, bringing multiple sub-plots together so that the narrative doesn't feel as scattershot. However, it is hard to feel too excited about how things will play out, having seen lackluster payoffs far too often when it comes to this series. The backup featuring Black Lightning was a neat little delight that ended satisfactorily, so maybe I can hope.

View Issue       View Full Review
8
Justice League Unlimited (2024) #1

Nov 27, 2024

I had my apprehensions about an Unlimited style of Justice League, and frankly, I still do. But this issue does a fantastic job of realizing the idea of such a League. While the plot is generic, there are some solid hooks, especially around the character of Air Wave, who looks to be a key character moving forward. I will look forward to seeing if the new series can maintain this level of quality in the upcoming issues.

View Issue       View Full Review
6
Red Hood: The Hill (2024) #3

Apr 9, 2024

It's difficult to shake off the feeling that I'm reading two stories awkwardly stapled together. While the story of the Hill is genuinely interesting, with some decent dialogue and art, Red Hood has yet to acclimate to his new surroundings and ends up sticking out like a sore thumb. Considering that a certain character – who is arguably more popular than Jason – makes an appearance on the last page, I don't think he's even doing enough to sell this series at this point.

View Issue       View Full Review
5
Red Hood: The Hill (2024) #4

May 14, 2024

I feel like my opinions have completely flip-flopped from the last issue, where I was more invested in the Watch than whatever was going on with Jason, Karlee Jr., and the rest. But thanks to some good writing, I'm now more interested in a new set of characters and how they interact. Unfortunately, this appears to have occurred at the expense of the other characters, who now look to be permanently sidelined. At least some appropriate art choices by Sanford Greene and Matt Herms give this book a nice indie feel, which feels tone accurate to the story.

View Issue       View Full Review
3.5
Red Hood: The Hill (2024) #5

Jun 12, 2024

This is a mess. What should be the culmination of all the story elements presented so far resembles a tangled collection of threads. I'm trying really hard to find something to praise besides the art, which remains satisfactory but is nothing too remarkable. Hopefully, it all comes together in the end, but I remain doubtful.

View Issue       View Full Review
4
Red Hood: The Hill (2024) #6

Jul 31, 2024

While Jason finally gets to shine in his own comic for once, there really isn't anything else that I can hold up as great in this issue. Overall, this series – which I should remind you is a prequel to Gotham War for some baffling reason – should have been something right up my alley. Revisiting an old DC idea done years ago with plenty of untapped potential? Yes, please!!! Sadly, it's better if some things are left as a concept instead of seeing it executed in a lackluster fashion.

View Issue       View Full Review
3
The Question: All Along the Watchtower (2024) #2

Dec 18, 2024

The only thing this issue confirmed for me was that sometimes it is best to leave characters on the proverbial shelf once their arc was completed in a satisfactory manner. How many times can we talk about Renee's alcoholism and struggles in her love life without turning them into punchlines? I know she has self-doubt about her job, but do we have to wait till the 3rd act of the movie for her to overcome it? I'm glad DC is giving characters like Renee and Cassandra their own series, and I love that Jenny Sparks and Black Canary have gotten some love as well, but it still needs to be a comic worth reading.

View Issue       View Full Review

Reviews for the Week of...

December

November

More