Joe Hill is doing something wonderful with Hill House. He is reinventing things we thought we knew. He set us up in issue 1 for a different kind of horror than what he delivers in Plunge #2. He dropped glowing eyed, worm infested, math zombies. That's right. You need to have a cursory knowledge of math to read this book. That doesn't even bug me it is just that good. Bravo Mr. Hill, Bravo! Read Full Review

With four issues left and an island full of questions that need answers, Hill continues to move the story along at a brisk and captivating pace. There's lots of interesting threads pulling this story together, and readers will want to stick around to find out what the Carpenter Salvage crew pulls out of the water next issue. Read Full Review

Final Verdict: 9.2 "Plunge" #2 seizes on the work that was done in the debut issue and takes the story to the next level, ratcheting up the tension and expanding the mystery. A great script and great art, dive in and enjoy. Read Full Review

Id love to be more critical of this issue and this series as a whole but I really dont feel that giving anything less than the rating below would be doing it, or the creative team, justice. Read Full Review

What the freakin' hell? Talking centipedes that come out of peoples faces, enormous sea monsters living in sunken ships, and zombies lighting floating ships on fire. Joe Hill does a great job of giving each character their own voice, and the art is just so good! So far this series has been a must-read. Also, I learned about something that I was not aware of: fire retardant grenades. Read Full Review

Joe Hill is following the classic haunted house model with this title, and adding a unique new setting that lends itself to some heavy-duty horror. The last book in the Hill House line is turning into one of the best. Read Full Review

Plunge #2 continues the psychological horror thriller adding to the mystery of it all and going for unease instead of scares. It delivers a fantastic mix of characters and settings with a look that helps create a creepy tone. This is a must for those that enjoy this sort of horror and for even those that don't. Read Full Review

Even though it treads mostly well worn paths it does it with enough skill to allow the reader to appreciate why they are so well trodden. Read Full Review

Much like the debut issue, this second chapter into the series continues to blend a number of polar, aquatic, and undead horror tropes into a compelling new narrative, though this installment was much wordier than its predecessor, which Joe Hill fans will likely appreciate while other riders might find it difficult to digest. Read Full Review

A fun read!

Better than #1, this issue drops a little more horror from different directions. So far following the cosmic horror template to a T. Hopefully they plan on throwing some twists in. Immonen's art seems almost too clean in a few panels, but gets gritty when needed. Solid enough to stay on for #3.

I really liked this more than I though I should. It was way too sci fi for my liking but it worked and im invested in the mystery. Immonen does a really good job on the art as usual.

This one gave me a bit of a chill, possibly because I fear and dread both the ocean and caves. I don’t really like math horror as a concept, and the dialogue is weak. This comic is definitely not perfect but it’s way above other comics in this series.

Disappointingly average. Dropped.

Like the previous issue, this was fine. The characters are still rough, especially the comic relief. Really hope this one gets going soon.