-
10
This was Great !
-
10
This issue was pretty good, it has some great slice of life stuff in it and some fun light moments that are really a joy to read.
-
9.5
Wow, that was a fun start! Like everyone else, I'm hoping that Tamaki's run is where this book turns a corner and becomes a book that's consistently fun to read again. Wonder Woman going to Ikea was a hoot.
-
9.5
Tamaki hits a home run in her debut issue. Can't wait to read the next issue.
-
9.0
After a lot of false starts , this one I am really into!
-
8.5
This was actually really good, I had a nice time reading it. And I liked the art a lot.
-
8.0
I'm so surprised this was good. It's been so long since we've had a good Wonder Woman issue. I'm so excited by the notion that maybe, just maybe, Wonder Woman won't be a horrific slog like it used to be. I've read a lot of Mariko Tamaki's writing, and the results are kind of all over the place, but here's hoping this is one of the good runs. I even liked Mikel Janin's art more than usual. Maybe the coloring has something to do with it. The aesthetic is brighter than Batman, and that may have helped take away the doll factor in his art.
-
7.5
The Mariko Tamaki/ Mikel Janin run begins, and it takes a decidedly different route than recent interpretations of Wonder Woman.
I appreciate the reframing of the character to better line up with how Patty Jenkins is presenting her in the movies. But I have to wonder if making WW more of a street level character with an apartment, a quirky neighbor and half the book focused on a highway car chase diminishes the character. But that's a core tension with the character. Is WW supposed to be soaring with the Greek gods a la Perez (my WW) or talking to bunnies, going to IKEA and running secret agent missions?
I was thinking the same thing coming out of the introductory pages. Specifically, highlighting Cheetah. Again, it's a movie tie-in and a smart one. (As is Maxwell Lord.) But as a main nemesis, Cheetah is pedestrian. Fighting evil gods like Ares -- now THAT'S big time and befitting WW. And I think WW should be more of an epic character than just "the best female character at DC."
But that's all big picture.
Taking the book as it is, accepting the basis for how Tamaki is handling the character....it's very good - perhaps great - for what it is. And Janin's art (the fantastic layouts especially!),is even better. I'll give it a 7.5/10, this one as an optimistic down payment on what appears to be a competently grounded start.
This has the potential to be one of DC's better books if it takes off from here. (Even if I don't automatically agree with how the character is framed.) more
-
7.5
Jumped back onto this book to give Tamaki a shot. And you know what, she showed up. After drags of boring crap from countless writers, I finally found a WW Rebirth story that intrigues me. Albeit, a mere introduction to whats to come and with hints of something that might be really worth investing myself in.
Tamaki surprised me, I thought she would just be another writer from the call-book that merely feels like a stand-in filler for the actual story that never came. But her writing wasn't bad, boring, or both. It was actually good. The monologue, and just the normal interactions between WW and normal people was done well. And the transitions in this book is the definite strong point of this issue.
Art by Janin, I have mixed feelings. He has done art for Batman and Grayson, but the way he draws faces sometimes can come across as creepy even when its not supposed to. They kind of felt like dolls more than people when he draws. He also doesn't have great background art. But overall, his art style was solid. I don't want to get my hopes up to high since so all the previous WW Rebirth arcs have failed to excite me, but this was a good hook to keep my interest. And we got a real killer WW villain, so looking forward to the next issue. more
-
7.5
It's been a while since I've read wonder woman as an ongoing, not since rucka left rebirth. I feel like the character hasn't had a consistent writer since rucka left, but this issue is a good start. It's fun and sweet, and also has a nice little set up for the current arc. Deals with Diana's decisions with Maxwell Lord before infinite crisis, which doesn't really get brought up that often outside of infinite crisis. Overall, a solid solid book, I'll continue reading
-
7.5
I'm not a fan of Tamaki's previous works and because of that prejudice of mine, I was skeptical about her taking over Wonder Woman's series. I have to say I'm positively surprised so far - it may have not been the greatest comic I've ever picked up, but I'm glad I gave it a chance. It offers some character driven drama, action and a mystery to be unraveled in the foreseeable future. Sure, you could argue if Diana would be so detached when it comes to furniture after spending decades in men's world, but hey, it's comics, they make us believe people can fly, shoot lasers from their eyes and completely selflessly fight completely selfish evil-doers.
I'll look forward to the next issue. If it build on what's here, I may end up adding it to my pull list. more
-
1.0
Auuuuuuuuggggghhhhhh yeeeeaaah, traced 3D models with a plot of incredibly low stakes to go with it (but Tomaki is a winner of the all-important Eisner awards so what do I know).
-
10
-
10
-
9.5
-
9.5
-
9.5
-
9.0
-
9.0
-
9.0
-
8.5
-
8.5
-
8.5
-
8.5
-
8.5
-
8.5
-
8.0
-
8.0
-
8.0
-
8.0