Decent first issue, I just wish Coccolo wasn't pulled off Immortal Thor.

Script is solid, but art is not. After Coccolo, it feels like no artist has rose to the colossal task of this series. Ewing and Thor deserve better.

Great art in this issue.

Really enjoyed this. Lot of great stories from past Thor writers and Artist, with the highlight of the issue being Straczynski and Coipel's pages. Still enjoying the main story from Cates and Klein as well. Klein did a really nice looking double page spread of Odin's funeral.

The only thing I didn't like in this issue was Jason Aaron's story. When I read the description saying we're getting a tale about Odin that only Aaron could tell, I thought this was a little odd because Jason Aaron seems to hate Odin. But I guess it makes sense, only Aaron could tell this story because no one hates Odin more then him. more

Great finale to the arc and some of the best art I've seen from Nic Klein this run. Only con was Angela still feeling kind of shoehorned in. There's also some pretty blatant MCU synergy inserted at the end, but it worked for the issue.

Another great issue

After that twist ending, I'm back on board with this arc.

Not bad, but not really grabbing my attention the way the Black Winter and Donald Blake arcs did.

After the last 7 months, it's good to see the book getting back on track.

This isn't a bad issue but it's safe to say there are some HUGE plotholes that I can't ignore just because it's Hickman. So Charles and Erik know that Mystique is basically the biggest danger on Krakoa but they're somehow stupid enough not to have any contingencies against a shapeshifter that could impersonate them and get access to stuff she's not allowed to. Yeah, sorry, I can't pretend that makes any sense. These are two mature characters, they're not idiots, first thing they'd do is make sure Raven doesn't get away with that kind of stuff. Also, there's a huge error in art. Last issue "Magneto" has the black costume when he goes after the Cerebro helmet, here he's wearing the white one. This coming on top of the fact that last issue Hickman changed the dialogue from HoX-PoX between Moira and Destiny is annoying because the inconsistency is becoming a frequent issue. I don't think it's too much to ask for a little bit of coordination. Also, while Caselli's art isn't bad, it's not anywhere near Larraz' work on HoX-PoX or X of Swords, Silva's work on HoX-PoX and not even on Schiti's work on S.W.O.R.D. or on the last issue. I love Hickman but I feel like his heart isn't in it here and I think that's in part because of the fact that he isn't following his original plan and the other writers have forced his hand to write the story in a way he doesn't want to. more

Really enjoyed the issue overall, but I need the main plot back

Was it enjoyable? Sure. Was it that good? Not really. Its fun and somewhat humorous but, i need more excitement from this series.

It's okay.

It's filler. Not necessarily bad filler, but after 6 months of issues like this, it gets kind of frustrating.

I'm glad Nic Klein is coming back next month, I just wish there wasn't a 7 month gap between main story arcs.

When Marvel announced the original heroes returning for the Fresh Start relaunch, Bruce Banner got the least amount of enthusiasm. A lot of readers even doubted how many good stories there were left to tell about the character. Three years later, Al Ewing and Joe Bennett conclude one of the most acclaimed series in all of comics.

I don't know if this issue was meant to make us like Freyja, hate Odin or remind us that Angela from Spawn is a Thor character now, either way, not a lot happened.

I love Iron Man, and I was a fan before the movies. I have been a fan for a long time, so when I say this, I say it with love. Tony Stark is an egotistical douche. And I'm sick of people acting like he's not. That's part of the charm of the character. Seeing him called on it by a *woman*, or if a few of you prefer, a *femoid*, doesn't faze me. The art does a good job looking and feeling like CAFU. In fact, at some points, I assumed that the credits page was a misprint, and CAFU was actually doing the art. more

Solid issue with great art by Michele Bandini. I especially liked the Berserk vibe from the last page.
In an earlier Beta Ray Bill issue, we learn Odin's been spending his time brewing beer, now we see what Freyja's been up to.
The readers complaining about the smaller arcs feeling like filler will probably just see this issue as a teaser for next months issue though, and the readers who are burnt out from Mjolner drama might not like this one either. I myself am still a little disappointed with how Odin is being written in this series, but I'm still looking forward to the arc finale next month. more