It is a info dump.

Read this issue and #0 it is like comic book heaven

I have to be honest: I think this series is the weakest among all the mutants ones. Hickman is probably a genius (he creates universes and species with scientific details in this series), but almost all his stories feel... Empty. We read of all these characters (Xavier, Magneto, Apocalypse, Wolverine, Summers family, Jean Grey...) but nothing happens. Flashbacks, metaphors, ideas. I personally think that New Mutants and especially X-Force are definitely more interesting and less bland. more

A very engaging first issue, the best iron Man relaunch in years.

Art is so good too

I like that this issue seemed to be a big filler, but it is really important and have some funny moments.

Characters really act dumb here.
In a moment Rictor is mad at apocalypse and moments later he does what he asks and kill mutants.
betsy doesn't do anything and is bad at her job of being captain britain.
Rogue do nothing.
Gambit has the chance to screw apocalypse plans but does what apocalypse asks, gambit since first issue doesn't trust him.
So they all helped Krakoa enter a war that will have a big costo to krakoa. more

So why exactly does she need tats on her fingers for this? Also, now every female is a lesbian/bi/queer coded? I’m ok with diversity, but it’s feeling forced t this point. Kitty, Illyana, Rachel, Emma...

After the build-up from the funeral issue this is a massive disappointment. It didn't push the story along enough and what we're given in terms of reunions isn't enough to warrant a full issue of Kitty meandering around Krakoa vaguely plotting revenge with Emma. Really hoping Duggan can right this ship after X Of Swords.

a bloody mess.
There is really a lot of bloody on this issue.
Basically no detective work was made again, only first issue had it. The whole cast seems to have 14

It's a team book or justa Kitty/Emma book?
Wolverine said more words than 3 chaarcter of the cast of the book?
Lolli art is also not the best.

A bit directionless, as there is a lot to close.

Thor is great here

This is the reason FF exists: Family.

there's nothing good about this issue, other than a couple jabs at rich people here and there. the art is terrible, the characterization of John feels (unfortunately) more New 52 than Vertigo, with a flaming hand at one point, and glowing sigils on his walls, Lucifer is bastardized once more, disrespecting the fantastic character masterfully written by Neil Gaiman and Mike Carey, and worst of all, this issue presents cops as decent people, and even has John refer to one of them as "a good'n." gross.

DC should cancel this thoroughly disappointing title immediately, and renew the masterpiece Si Spurrier's been writing. that's the Hellblazer we need. more

Tom Taylor makes a decent attempt at John Constantine but it’s just not authentic. The art, dialogue and general feel of this book is very much reminiscent of the dark days of New 52. It’s genuinely hard to understand how the recent Si Spurrier series wasn’t renewed or which John Constantine DC actually want

This issue is getting a lot of hate because of its alleged Tumblrism, and as someone who has been dragged kicking and screaming into a Tumblr blog here and there, I don't see the issue. It's actually a lot more tame than I thought it would be. So, meh, everyone who had such a complaint is wrong. This was a fun issue and I like seeing these characters interact. Daken is probably the best part of the issue so I hope he's not actually gone. more

Solid first issue. pencils and color is on point

The writing here is bad, but I really liked the art. Noto is so good.

Glob with the most generic mutant backstory.

Also the book seems to forget that mutants can be ressurrected

The writing for Cable continue to be dumb and awful.

Every time I read this comic I am filled with trepidation, and actually finishing it doesn’t make the trepidation go away.

Did the writer get the memo that she's suppose to writte a comic book and not some bad fanfic? The text try to hard to be fun, but it feels like some really bad tumblr/twitter talk, like some old man trying to keep it with the kids, it's extra cringe, try harder Williams.

Blah. At this point, I can't wait for Hickman to be done with this story, and I don't even care what the big reveal he's obviously building towards is anymore.

Leah Willians is just not good. She writes every single character as if they were 15-year-old twitter/tumblr users full on snark and banter all the time. It's exhausting. It's like she writes for the sole purpose of fishing for reactions of a small but vocal twitter fanbase.