-
10
Another top notch issue with great drama and a great introduction of characters. Love how alpha Clark and Zala are.
I hope this story isn't going to be as predictable as it's shaping up to be, looks like Bruce is going to be the banished bastard son when the Els find out who he is and he'll end the war with a mega climactic fight against Clark.
-
10
A very, very cool issue. I didn't expect nothing from this story, but is actually great.
The story arc advances with rhythm, and Kala Jor-El is a fine addition to the story - and her romance with Diana was unnexpected, but really cool. By the way, not just Kala, but Constantine, Lois Lane, Amanda Waller, Taylor's Suicide Squad (he won't let DC forget those characters), all great additions to the story, in very interesting roles.
And Yasmine art is beautiful as ever. To finish: let's bring war!
-
9.5
I have to say this Tom Taylor writes amazing elsewhere stories, I just read the superman annual which was shit and this is amazing , and its written by the same writer.
There are some really interesting topics damn, and exited what comes next
-
9.0
This series is just brutal, no restraint and moving things along. Godamn, what is happening? Fun story and awesome visuals that's what's happening! I would never believe DC superheroes would fit so good in a medieval world xD But I gotta say, I've been swayed.
-
9.0
It wasn't as strong for me but I still really enjoyed it. I need more Constantine, felt that while Kal's reaction was excessive, it made sense. Especially in the context and time period this story is taking place. People are more brutal here, even the Els. People need to stop saying how, "out of character" this or that feels in a story especially one where the DC characters are in the age of Camelot. Kal is going to be pissed even at someone he views as his brother and it's only going to get worse. I'm here for it. The art is gorgeous, I need to check out more of Putri's work. I'd also like to add to the people who "review" these books and proudly write that they didn't buy the books that YOU, not the writers or DC's agenda are what is wrong with comics. You should be ashamed not that you know what that means. more
-
9.0
@nd issue continues the strides left in issue 1. Taylor is taking his time with not only setting the stage for this story, but also expanding the world & cast of characters. We introductions to a new son for Jefferson & clark's sister. She's brand new & appears to me more temperamental & "act first, think later" in her actions. Love the teases for other characters like Blu Devil, Flash, Gorilla Grodd, etc. This was a fun issue.
-
9.0
Excellent book. Excellent writing. Excellent art
-
8.5
Nearly as good as Dark Ages, which I read back-to-back with this. This is super engaging, and here's the thing: High Fantasy is garbage. But I enjoyed this for what it was, even still.
Oh, and I wouldn't rely on Merlyn to know how to properly approach LGBT characters in fiction. "Let's not normalize two women kissing because it's too funny and cringe. Because normalization is bad, and I'm definitely not a bigot." These claims of Taylor not knowing what he's doing in this regard is just poor subterfuge for someone to say they don't like gay people without having to be open about it. This is the same as all those GamerGate idiots going around saying, "Well, if you just did diversity *right*" The key is knowing there's no "right way" to these people. They're just cowards. more
-
8.5
a pretty solid second issue with interesting character development. This may be Tom Taylor's greatest achievement.
-
7.5
"Honesty [...] it's the most loyal thing there is"
And issue #2 is just as good.
We get a nice, dynamic opening, continuing from the ending of the last issue, and the story moves after that with a nice, brisk pace, showing us more of the world created and more familiar faces in new situations. It's still funny though that they are calling Black Lightning - King Jefferson Pierce. It's just doesn't sound very medieval-like.
I still can't believe that this is the same guy that writes Son of Kal-El. The quality of writing here and there is just too different. The only thing that could point that this is, in fact, the same Tom Taylor, is his affinity for showing members of the House of El having same-sex kisses. But even then it only raises questions. Is Tom Taylor trying to tell us something about himself or is he just trying to score more points?
Whatever the case this was a fun issue. I will be definitely checking the next one. more
-
7.0
I've never been Tom Taylor's biggest fan. I've often felt his writing for characters never goes past surface level pop culture stereotypes in some cases (Superman) or just actively bad (Wonder Woman) and unlike most else, I only thought the first issue of this series was decent aside from the shocking twist at the end (which if you're familiar with Taylor's work, you should expect). This continues to be decent for the most part but still feels rather more decompressed than it ought to be.
I do have to question how smart this version of Black Lightning though, did he seriously expect no follow or consequences from what he ordered last issue.
Putri's art is obviously the standout here. Nothing really more to say on that front.
As I've said, I think anytime Taylor's written Wonder Woman (Injustice, DCeased) he's been pretty consistently terrible; never rising above generic "Warrior Woman who speaks in platitudes" or a foil for the characters he actually cares about (Superman, Batman) . And I'll be honest, this series lives or dies for me based off how he portrays her here.
There's not much to go on here, personality wise, as she only has one scene but probably the most noticeable thing here is she makes out with this universe's version of Supergirl. I'll give him points for having Diana actually making out with another woman (something DC has yet to allow in her main book).
But I do have to role my eyes that he couldn't have done it with someone from her own mythos rather than making her an appendage to Supergirl. more
-
6.0
It looks like war is coming as we see the immediate fallout from the death of Jor-El at the hands of Green Arrow. Two kingdoms will suffer a death in the family by the end of this issue. This issue caused my interest in the story to wane a little bit, but we'll see if that continues to be case or if Tom can rally.
https://youtu.be/9u80XN6O9pc
-
6.0
It is clear to me, clear as day, that Tom Taylor hates Batman from the bottom of his heart, given how many times he has characters scorn him. Yes, he does "cool" things with him here and there, but that's just for the fanbase because he is the type of writer who knows his skills are limited and relies a lot on pleasing the fanbase, it's his modus operandi, hence also the "Jon is bi thing".
I didn't like how Superman acted here either, he's way too douchy. Yes, he's in pain and yes, this is an elsewhere story but I still felt that some lines, particularly towards Bruce were totally uncalled for. And I have to say, I burst in laughter at the Wonder Woman and Zala kiss page. Taylor really doesn't know how to present a LGBT story, does he? He just slaps a page where two men/women kiss and waits for the applause, "hey, look at me, I'm so very progressive, aren't I the best?" But at least he pandered to his fanbase, that's what matters after all, isn't it?
I also cringed at Harley pretty hard, I know Taylor likes her and in Injustice he wrote her pretty decently, but here it was just cringy.
All in all, it turns out one good issue was all Taylor could do before he went back to his old, cringy and stupid ways. more
-
6.0
Okay.
-
6.0
I'm glad I didn't buy the first issue or this issue. And I had to resist for the incredible art of Putri. But the story stopped liking me, becoming completely predictable and very amateurish, for my taste. I love medieval stories, knights, wizards and maidens, even fanciful ones, but this was felt again with lots of cameo characters and little development. The intrigue could have been better. And the relationship between the half-brothers shake it in a better way.
Amazing the second book and I've lost interest (not a complete disaster, maybe salvageable, but I doubt it), shame about Putri's art, I really would have liked to buy the TP
-
3.0
I loved this worldbuilding. Perhaps, the book lost me with the batcentrism and the storytelling making Bruce the poor bastard who will probably reign and develop his powers and everyone gonna love him and blablabla. Maybe the next time Taylor should say this is another batbook and not the crap of "Nono guys, is DC Universe book, I swear, batman is only in the tittle because sales"
-
10
-
10
-
10
-
10
-
10
-
9.5
-
9.5
-
9.5
-
9.5
-
9.5
-
9.5
-
9.0
-
9.0
-
9.0
-
9.0
-
9.0
-
9.0
-
9.0
-
9.0
-
9.0
-
9.0
-
9.0
-
9.0
-
8.5
-
8.5
-
8.5
-
8.5
-
8.5
-
8.5
-
8.0
-
8.0
-
8.0
-
8.0
-
8.0
-
8.0
-
8.0
-
7.5
-
7.0
-
7.0
-
7.0
-
7.0
-
6.0
-
6.0
-
6.0
-
5.5
-
5.0
-
4.0