It seems like things just keep getting better for Guardians fans. Maybe not for fans of the lineup from the movies that have been the norm in comics for the past 10 years (as that's now a thing of the past after Infinity Wars), but each time we get a new writer, it seems that we get closer and closer to the popular "as good as DnA" level that Guardians comics get judged upon. When Duggan took over, it was definitely a breath of fresh air for the team, but now with Donny Cates in charge, one issue in and we're introduced to one heck of a story and one hell of a new Guardians team that appears to be closer to that level than... well... since DnA. The forced humor we saw in the Bendis era is mostly gone, and this continues Duggan's trend of fixing things from that series as well as raising the stakes and adding a much-needed seriousness, in what is one of the best #1's I've read in a while, as I had high hopes for this series and they were met or exceeded on almost every level. Of course, the final, official, new lineup isn't what many probably expected from the big roster showcased on the cover, but it's still promising enough to guarantee this will be a must-read series. more

Brisson writes this sort of thing really well and though his art won’t be for everyone, I love Burnett’s art. That said, I’m just not a huge fan of gory violence and indiscriminate killing in my mainstream superhero books so I’m not sure if this one is for me. I’ve preordered issue 2 so we’ll see if that turns me around. I still couldn’t rate it too low because I think it is of a high quality, just not perfectly to my tastes. more

Great art and one of the better issues here imo. Yeah, there’s a time jump but it’ll all make sense halfway through and I loved seeing the Young XMen get the spotlight. They are characters that aren’t so established that there’s a real danger that one or all of them can end up hurt and I also always love the “should we kill” moral dilemma stories.

Hell of a climax to a fun series. It was worth waiting a few weeks in order that the book look as good as it did. Really didn't see the ending coming and I felt it was a good last run for the time-displaced O5. I know this era got a lot of poop thrown at it, but I enjoyed the Blue and the non-Bendis All-New a great deal and was happy to see their story get proper closure.

A fun little issue, but definitely a bit of a step down from the last few.

I thought the last few issues felt a little disjointed and that this was a return to form. Liked the art a lot too. Very classic 80s style Marvel looking.

Never really cares about these characters, bought first issue on a whim but I’ve really been enjoying things. It gets a little convoluted at times but it’s never less than entertaining.

A crazy mixed bag of cosmic weirdness is always fun, even though it was a bit jumbled.

I like Claremont a lot and am doing a read of his original legendary run so it was fun to see him take a look into the Summers family male lineage. I was quite impressed too with the first story, which fit some good meat on the bones of a character I don't know all that well (I wasn't reading too many Marvel books when Hope became a thing). Overall a very good issue that doesn't spoil Extermination in the slightest. more

Probably my least favorite issue so far of the new Uncanny as it felt the most disjointed to me (the multiple writers may have taken its toll on the flow). But still overall good fun.

Been looking for a comic to get me back "in" with the DC Universe and everything I've tried hasn't really hit the spot (I am just not a big Scott Snyder-style writing fan) but this was just what I wanted! Geoff Johns at his most playful! I've always liked his work, but this shows that he's continued honing his craft as there's just the right amount of humor/heartwarming moments/action/revisionism and it's capped off with one big old jaw-dropping cliffhanger and another softer/fluffier but equally fun cliffhanger. This is everything I wanted in a great DC Superhero Comic Book. more

Outstanding issue from Jason Aaron. His story just got immensely intriguing by all of the insane twists and reveals. That JLA nod was great especially with Agent. Marquez and McGuiness were perfect. Plus Irving, Kubert and Sorrentino delivered even more set up/future stories. This is the best $6 i spent in a long while.

Great issue. Better than the last. Picked up those threads and ran with them. I like Spencer's stuff so far. He's handling those angles very well. Ramos and Bandini delivered the goods and fit well together.

I liked the character writing for the Black Order’s leaderand this sort of violent gonzo sci-if tale is what Tan excels in drawing but overall it went by a little too fast Tim feel like anythiñ othe than an appetizer. I’ll probably stick around for the series though because there’s something I like about this sort of cosmically tale and it reads better than Infinity Wars and Avengers: No Surrender. more

This was a perfect modern superhero comic. Wonderful art, action, intrigue, great character writing, tons of set-up, decent payoff. If every book were this good I’d go broke from buying them all. Literally no complaints here. I want to reread it tomorrow, and the day after.

Top tier superhero title. The stories move in interesting and unexpected directions while keeping the characters true to themselves and the villain's plans are interesting. The art was really nice too, more like this please.

Great start to the new Uncanny. Great art and story, my only complaint is that the backups aren’t quite as engaging as the main story, though the Bisohop story kicks ass.

A nice intro to a new storyline that seems to have appeal but I just don’t have the nostalgia for these characters needed for this to fully land. If you do hold BSG Classic near and dear you’re in for a treat, otherwise you, like me, probably won’t be along for the ride. Still appreciate the free digital zero issue as I’d never have tried it out otherwise,

Claremont knows Magneto inside and out and he writes a surprisingly modern script that made me happy inside and out. The art is a little lackluster but the backup strip is awesome so the half point lost for art is made back up there. I would buy the hell out of a Claremont Magneto mini.

Thought this was a great Cyberpunk Elseworlds reimagining of X-Men. There seemed to be more backstory than they could fit in a single issue so I wouldn’t be sad to see this spun into a miniseries. Also, both artists had radically different style, but they integrated wonderfully.

Exciting, action-packed and still room for decent character work. Pretty great mini so far.

The amount of story in this issue amounted to the pre-credits scene in a TV show. What's there is fine and the art is great, but rarely has the phrase "written for the trade" felt more true.

Good setup, but very decompressed.