Immortal X-Men #9 is a perfect thrill ride. Gillen keeps things light, but the stakes never feel unimportant. Werneck and Curiels art complements the script beautifully. Immortal X-Men remains an amazing book. Read Full Review

For a story involving almost ludicrous amounts of physical carnage, this story was both hilarious, deeply worrying, and very, very fun. Read Full Review

Another solid entry from Gillen, 'Immortal X-Men' #9 keeps readers in the (time) loop on Council goings-on, while also continuing to build towards Sins of Sinister. Read Full Review

Immortal X-Men #9 is a delightfully deranged deconstruction of the lives of Moira X as presented in House of X/Powers of X. Read Full Review

Immortal X-Men #9 sets up the next issue but doesn't give Kate Pryde the attention I was expecting based on previous issues. Read Full Review

I love the work with Mr Sinister in this book

Wow!!!! I absolutely love everything about this issue! This is brilliant! I love the direction this is heading and can't stop thinking of all the possible scenarios that could play out. This is the best I love it

God, this was good!

The plot certainly develops with a vengeance. Sinister is at his sneering, villainous best, and the other characters sound good too. It's illustrated with admirable detail and impressive gore. The pace varies a little too much, but the story flows smoothly through a complicated structure. Taken altogether, it's a nigh-perfect issue.

Good lord, I love this book. Sinister's ten attempts to kill the Quiet Council were very entertaining to read, with credit going to the fantastic duo of Kieron Gillen on the scripts and Lucas Werneck on the art. Gillen has consistently made Sinister a very fun and interesting character throughout this series, while Werneck brings so much detail and intricacy to his pages. Great stuff once again from this series.

This was so entertaining lol

This book continues to be great as Gillen presents Sinister's very own HoxPox. He really played on our expectations perfectly this month. Each issue of Immortal X-Men has focused primarily on one character and in having Sinister interrupt Kitty Pryde's turn to take the lead, it added a nice little layer of meta to the story at hand.

Lots of really cool things to notice in this issue too.
- Sinister never kills Storm in any of his attempts, instead opting to choose a time when she's not present.
- The Dark Beast appearance and the little comment that Sinister knows what 616 Beast is up to.

- The various timelines from issue #3 also appear to be converging on one singular point too, as Judgment Day appears to be a fixed point since Sinister commented that he refuses to reset back before it.

- And especially the little conversation between Sinister and Destiny, where it basically confirms she's ok with what he's doing. Is Destiny being driven by self-interest? The book has spent a lot of time on her relationship with Raven. So it feels logical that she would try to steer the timeline toward any possible outcome that would keep her alive, even in the face of the revelation at the end of issue #3.

I'm just gonna say it: the X line is in a great spot right now and any complaints about it missing Hickman, while we're getting fantastic books like this that are steeped in his initial ideas, are entirely misplaced. more

If there's one star at the top of Gillen's Christmas tree it's Sinister, a character he pretty much owns now. Maybe his best issue yet of Immortal?

Wow, was this solid! I'm sure it is paving the way for next year's "Sins of Sinister" event, but good Lord! So, so much bits and gore! And the things Sinister has set in motion, so intriguingly interesting!

Some will piss and moan, that this wasn't what Jonathan Hickman had intended! To that I say, "Poppycock!" Hickman has said he left notes behind, and while I believe Steve Orlando is •RUINING• MARAUDERS, I think Gillen is killing, doing the an awesome job, one that I believe Hickman would approve, and appreciate!

Weird! X-Men meet Deathloop.

A good issue that leaves me wanting Sins of Sinister. I feel like there is a lot of potential.

Edit: Gillen is cooking but I have to give Werneck his props. Looking back at the art I really like his style and he is improving his action sequences a lot.